Government Playing Hide-and-Seek Over Provinces and Referendum: Shehzad Iqbal

Senior journalist Shehzad Iqbal said Shehbaz Sharif is on board, but Nawaz Sharif and Maryam Nawaz have yet to agree; he said the issue within the PPP is Bilawal Bhutto, and that in reality it is not two parties but only some members of two families who are opposed.

ISLAMABAD, (UrduPoint News - 16th Nov, 2026) Senior journalist Shehzad Iqbal said the government was playing hide-and-seek over the issue of provinces and a referendum. Speaking to anchor Alina Farooq Sheikh on Geo News’ programme “Report Card,” he said Khawaja Asif was so far the most prominent leader from the PML-N and government ranks to speak openly about the matter.

Malik Ahmad Khan had earlier also said that there would be a referendum and that the matter could go to a constitutional court. He is the Speaker of the Punjab Assembly.

Iqbal said those speaking openly within the government and the PML-N were people who felt no hesitation in expressing their views and believed the system was hybrid and that they had to work together within it. Khawaja Asif held a position in the government and was also the defence minister, so, Iqbal said, he may have received information from the institutions under his authority about what they were thinking.

Iqbal said it was surprising that all this could happen in December, within a month, with the question of a referendum being raised and discussed. He said that not only Khawaja Asif but also Mustafa Kamal had said the previous day that a referendum was going to be held in December.

He said the problem was that the public and media were not aware of the matter, while government and PML-N leaders continued to deny it. Iqbal said he had asked Khawaja Asif the previous day what Shehbaz Sharif thought, but Asif had no answer. “We do not know what Shehbaz Sharif is thinking. We do not know what Maryam Nawaz is thinking,” he said.

The senior journalist said the PPP had passed a resolution in the Sindh Assembly rejecting the possibility of creating provinces in Sindh.

Discussing the constitutional and administrative aspects of creating new provinces, Iqbal said the matter would require rewriting the entire Constitution, rather than changing one or two clauses. He cited water issues, the distribution of other resources and the National Finance Commission (NFC), saying every constitutional provision would have to be addressed.

He said the exercise would be similar to the 18th Amendment. At that time, a 26-member committee was formed, and even parties with just one seat were represented so they could give their views and proposals on the constitutional amendment. “But nothing is happening on this matter at the moment,” he said.

Iqbal added that the statements issued after meetings between the president and the prime minister made no mention of the matter. Nor, he said, had anything officially emerged after Mohsin Naqvi met the president about whether the provinces had been discussed.

He said, however, that people could see what was happening: one day Mohsin Naqvi was speaking about a referendum, the next day he met the president, and the following day the president met the prime minister. “So it is not the case that nothing is happening,” he said, adding that many people outside the government could also explain what was taking place.

Criticising the government’s conduct, Iqbal said playing hide-and-seek over the issue was unfair. If the government’s position was that new provinces should not be created, it should state that openly. But, he said, the government was not in a position to do so, and everyone knew it had been part and parcel of the circumstances in which it was formed and what followed. “It cannot now step forward and then pull its hands back,” he said.

Iqbal said the parties would not be able to resist for long. He said he did not know what the PPP would do, as he had thought it would oppose the move to the end. But it was surprising that Khawaja Asif was saying the matter had already been discussed and that further progress would be made by December.

He asked how the PPP would accept the proposal and what narrative it would present. One view emerging, he said, was that if people in Sindh were also asked to express their opinion, it might make matters easier for the party by establishing that the position reflected public opinion.

Discussing Sindh’s political situation, Iqbal said he had spoken to two senior Sindh leaders who opposed the PTI. They told him that all of Sindh was united on the issue and that no political party wanted provinces to be created in Sindh.

He added that they had said they opposed the PTI and criticised it over corruption and governance issues, but were united on this matter. He compared the unity in Sindh to the way people come together in wartime.

Is there a division within the PML-N and government on the issue? Anchor Alina Farooq asks

In response to the anchor’s question, Iqbal said he had been told that Shehbaz Sharif was on board, while Maryam Nawaz and Nawaz Sharif had not yet agreed to the proposal. According to him, those in charge said Asif Ali Zardari also understood how important it was to create provinces, but the problem was Bilawal Bhutto, who was less certain about the matter.

He added that, in reality, it was not two parties opposing the proposal but two families, and only a few members of those families were against it. The issue was also being debated among the public.

Iqbal concluded that all political parties should state their positions on the matter. Otherwise, he said, it looked as though an order had been issued and they were expected to reach a consensus on it.

内容来自 UrduPoint News,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅