Homicide conviction deemed too old

The man has repeatedly violated Icelandic immigration laws.

The man has repeatedly violated Icelandic immigration laws. mbl.is/Karítas

There appears to be considerable room for interpretation as to how far an individual must go before Icelandic authorities are permitted to deport them on public interest grounds.

A recent ruling by the Immigration Appeals Board has sparked strong reactions after the board overturned a decision to deport an Albanian national who has been convicted of homicide and is currently under investigation on suspicion of a sexual offense against a child under the age of 15. The man has also repeatedly violated Icelandic immigration laws, including by residing and working in the country without the required permits and entering Iceland despite an active re-entry ban. Nevertheless, the board considers that it has not been sufficiently demonstrated that his deportation is necessary on public interest grounds.

2007 conviction insufficient on its own

In 2007, the man was convicted in Albania of homicide and firearms offenses. The offenses were committed in 2004 and included the fatal shooting of a man in collaboration with others. He was sentenced to 18 years in prison, but one-third of his sentence was remitted, reducing it to 12 years.

The board concluded from the judgment that the man had completed his sentence sometime between 2016 and 2017. However, no documentation from the Albanian prison authorities regarding the period of imprisonment was available.

In its assessment, the board took into account a specific legal provision permitting deportation on the grounds of foreign criminal convictions. This provision applies to individuals who, within the previous five years, have been sentenced or served a sentence abroad for certain criminal offenses.

In light of this, the board concluded that the 2007 conviction alone was insufficient to establish that the man's deportation was necessary on grounds of national security or public interest.

Disagreed with police assessment

A police statement from June 2025 indicated that the man had been suspected of working and residing illegally in Iceland, violating a re-entry ban and driving without a valid driver's license, among other offenses.

Taking into account his homicide conviction, police considered him a genuine, imminent and sufficiently serious threat to the fundamental interests of society, even though he had not been convicted in Iceland or, according to the statement, been suspected of particularly serious offenses.

The board disagreed that the previous conviction and the aforementioned offenses were sufficient to justify that conclusion. Although his conduct demonstrated a certain pattern of offending, it was not considered to constitute a threat to the public interest.

Furthermore, the police statement did not take the sexual offense case into account. Its assessment therefore did not encompass all the circumstances of the case and was consequently considered inadequate.

Limited evidence in sexual offense case

According to information obtained by the board, a case involving suspected sexual offenses by the man against a child under the age of 15 was being handled by the District Prosecutor.

The board considered the case serious and acknowledged that it could concern the fundamental interests of society. However, it remained under investigation. Very limited documentation regarding interviews was available, and no charges had been filed or judgment handed down.

Applying the deportation provision required a thoroughly reasoned police assessment and evidence demonstrating the existence of the alleged threat. The available documentation was insufficient, and further information needed to be obtained.

Rejected arguments for enhanced protection

The man's appeal was primarily based on his claim that he enjoyed enhanced protection against deportation as a family member of an EEA citizen. He was married to an Icelandic woman, with whom he had a child over whom they shared custody.

The board rejected the argument that special provisions governing EEA citizens and their family members applied. Nothing in the case documents indicated that the couple had established family life in another EEA or EFTA member state. The man's rights were therefore based on Icelandic domestic law.

Nevertheless, the board concluded that the conditions of the deportation provision invoked by the Directorate of Immigration had not been met. The decision to deport the man and impose a 12-year re-entry ban was therefore overturned.

“ They simply want the man deported ”

Notably, the board takes into account the five-year time limit applicable to deportation based on foreign criminal convictions, even though this limit does not apply to the separate legal provision allowing deportation on public interest grounds, on which the Directorate of Immigration based its decision. The legislative explanatory materials clearly distinguish between these two legal provisions. The board's decision to consider the time limit in its assessment is therefore its own, rather than a condition imposed by the legislature for applying the public interest provision.

Sigríður Á. Andersen, parliamentary group chair of the Centre Party, says the board's ruling does not surprise her in light of current immigration legislation.

“I understand what people are saying. They simply want the man deported. However, we need to stop and consider whether it is appropriate to deport him before putting him on trial if he has committed an offense,” Andersen tells Morgunblaðið.

内容来自 Mbl.is - News in English,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅