Neoliberal and austerity policies, and climate crisis
Interest rate rises are counter-productive
In his recent statement at this years’ flagship annual climate summit globally, ‘Conference of the Parties’ (COP) now in its 31st year, the Prime Minister of Pakistan reportedly called for provision of ‘grant-based finance,’ which ‘does not deepen their debt.’. While this makes sense, especially given Pakistan is already under a debt programme, that is, resilience and sustainability facility (RSF) with International Monetary Fund (IMF), and which is why it is important that climate finance amounts need to increase from multilateral sources, in particular in terms of enhanced allocation of special drawing rights (SDRs) on an annual basis over the medium-to-long-term by IMF for highly climate vulnerable countries like Pakistan, at the same time, it is important that the tide of neoliberal, and austerity policies is quickly, and deeply turned back.
There are two negative channels that are especially important in which these policies hurt the fight against the climate change crisis in particular. Firstly, the limited role of the public sector, seen under neoliberal policies, both within, and outside of IMF programmes over the last number of decades, has meant that public sector capacities have continued to diminish. At the same time, governments taking a back seat, in terms of mainly reducing themselves as a ‘fixer’ of market failures, and to merely a ‘facilitator’ of the private sector, has not provided enough signals to the economy to reach much better productive-, and allocative efficiencies.
On the other hand, ‘post-distribution’ policies, have not allowed better provision of opportunities in a meaningfully inclusive way, and in turn, on the flip side have inordinately allowed vested interest groups to unwarrantedly have more say in economic production. This, in turn, has increased inequality, and reduced political voice, which has meant lesser role of public opinion on public policy.
Altogether, this has meant both sub-optimal economic growth, and low-quality growth, which in turn has kept contribution to climate change crisis, in terms of high levels of negative externalities not adequately addressed under ‘market fundamentalism’ that neoliberal policies advocate, only to be checked under low-level regulation, which falls well short of proactive role of government to tackling negative externalities.
In her recently published book The Common Good Economy: how to make capitalism work for us all, renowned economist Mariana Mazzucato, indicated in this regard ‘…how to have the kind of government policy and governance structure that shape markets to create a more inclusive and sustainable capitalism. Outcomes orientation in this view means that instead of just viewing bad things that arise in the economy as ‘externalities’, we can better understand how those bads are produced by the way of markets work even in ‘perfect’ form, indeed through the very logic of the market. The transition to a market-shaping view, driven by the common good, needs to thus start with an economy that has objectives, and markets are then shaped to achieve them. Through such a lens, relationships are no longer simply about cost benefit or supply–demand decisions and transaction cost economics, but rather are designed to achieve the objectives that markets are being shaped for. …Critical for market shaping is not seeing ‘bads’ as externalities independent from how the market is shaped in the first place. …Indeed, the investment firm Schroders has shown that if the externalities were truly addressed, 55 per cent of global profits (and hence a large chunk of global GDP) would be eliminated…’
Austerity– or aggregate demand squeeze– policies, has been the second channel, has led to N unnecessarily high policy rate (monetary austerity) to curb inflation, even when inflation is at least equally a fiscal phenomenon in developing countries in general, and requires governance, and incentive structures to active shape markets, so as to better manage aggregate supply side of the economy, and in turn, inflationary pressures coming from supply shortages, and over-profiteering tendencies.
To make matters worse, rather than reducing these unnecessarily high interest payments, which in turn, put pressure on the budget deficit– both through higher expenditures, and lower revenues at the back of lower growth as a result of the aggregate demand-squeeze policy of raising interest rate to curb inflation – fiscal austerity is practised, whereby non-interest payment related expenditures are curtailed, and given the developing country context of weak economic institutional quality, and high level of inflation means that development expenditures, and not non-development (or current) expenditures are generally what get slashed.
This, in turn, leads to economic growth sacrifice on one hand, and on the other, higher interest payments, leave less for spending on infrastructure, and social sectors, which are, otherwise important to make for building public-, and private sector capacities– especially of those of the vulnerable sections of the population– to better deal with climate change crises, and to reduce the carbon footprint.
To make matters worse, rather than reducing these unnecessarily high interest payments, which in turn, put pressure on the budget deficit– both through higher expenditures, and lower revenues at the back of lower growth as a result of the aggregate demand-squeeze policy of raising interest rate to curb inflation – fiscal austerity is practised, whereby non-interest payment related expenditures are curtailed, and given the developing country context of weak economic institutional quality, and high level of inflation means that development expenditures, and not non-development (or current) expenditures are generally what get slashed. This further adds to negative pressures on economic growth, and in turn, employment levels, and further diminishes resilience effort in the economy.
Noted economist Isabella M. Weber in her recent book Anti-fascist economics: in defense of affordability, dignity, and democracy pointed out in this regard ‘Central banks react to inflation by raising interest rates, cooling the economy and suppressing wage growth in an attempt to bring prices down. But when inflation originates in supply shocks to a handful of essential sectors, interest rate hikes are not only regressive but also ineffective. They cannot fix a disrupted harvest or a geopolitical energy shock… And since people can’t do without consuming essential goods, and services, reducing their income won’t do much to reduce demand in the sectors experiencing high prices either. What interest rates can do– and do do– is raise debt-servicing costs on lower-income households and the debt burden on developing countries, suppress job creation at the bottom of the labour market, and increase the cost of very investments needed to build resilience against future shocks and transition out of fossil fuel capitalism. If monetary austerity is paired with fiscal austerity, it only compounds the damage.’
内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗