How Creative Art Replaces Viewer interest in a Hard State

Twitter, now known as X, has become a major global platform for news dissemination, political communication and public debate. Political parties, influential personalities, government institutions, analysts and journalists increasingly use the platform to share their views.

Twitter or X; whatever name you may take for the prime news dissemination channel across the globe; where political factions, personalities and establishments make it a point to flash their point of view in a bid to reach out either to the stakeholders or be in touch with the people. Other than the elite crowd, analysts, journalists also make it a point to disseminate their point of view with increasingly electronic or ‘online’ words.

Likewise, Facebook is the next signpost on the social media highway where people are kept informed about ‘unconfirmed’ reports. It also acts as a place where people can vent their anger online without going to the nearest boulevard or city centre to record their protest. The two platforms consequently are the place to gauge the public sentiment; keeping in focus the assumption that the right to express views is not fraught with problems; foremost an individual relation with the nation state or the government (establishment) in question. In third-world countries like Pakistan; rather particularly a country like Pakistan, with a history of underdeveloped polity and media, such things are likely to raise their head as the political make-up of the state during the decade has changed into a relationship between an individual and the state fraught with suspicion. In a few words, that is the position where we can conclude that it is the hard state that has strengthened purposefully or inadvertently during the period.

For the businesses it is a good development as viewership of any hit serial determines the advertising strategy and the definition of the prime time. For the polity and the system of a state as a whole, the creative arts not just provide a cryptic outlet to the pent-up thoughts, but also keeps the population engaged still in a pastime, which saves them from drowning into the cesspool of despair. The caption under discussion can generate enough thoughts to compile a book; but that expression of ideas can be a teaser for further debate

In such a scenario reminiscent of the Zia years when political reporting was muted, commerce reporting was encouraged and all types of geopolitical events were fervently reported and covered, the creative art scene was the only area where people found common cause; firstly with content being churned out by the state TV in the form of adaptations of the classic novels, with long plays a substitute to the two-hour movie made by the film industry; in the case of Pakistan packing all illogical scenarios in the story plot, the PTV long play was a sought=after creative product.

Once done with the content being churned out of the novels and classics, the next point where the audience concentrated were the actors themselves, actors associated with the particular portrayal of a character, like A R Khatoon ‘Shama’ or ‘Afshan’, names like Ghazala Kaifi (Shama) and Javed Sheikh (Shama Hero) which were a mix on old and new faces in acting, the audience either identifies with them or what can be called personality worship. During the same period, more than the political office bearers of the political parties being known to the common man names like Nusrat Thakur, Mohsin Ali or Muhammad Nisar Husain, the producers and directors of these art forms, were literally the household names to remember for the young and old alike; and so were the names of actors like the late Abid Ali, Uzma Gilani, and many others. From another angle, a Pakistani or a private person found it safe to like an actor or the drama, and stay glued to the TV for a particular drama serial, rather than think of protesting over inflation, low wages, how the country is being run or other such ‘dangerous’ questions.  

Coming back to the current trends; with statements emanating on the electronic media where the common man is warned to be careful in expressing his or her views, sharing those views, expressing support or vice versa for any political trend or views, any sane individual will find it safe to follow the creative arts, the actors playing the roles and the storyline of any particular drama serial.

These trends in the case of Pakistan; during the current period have pointed to the increased interest in what is being packaged as drama serial. The Pakistani crowd on Twitter can be found posting crucial clips of youthful romantic stories like Meri Zindagi Hay Tu featuring Hania Amir and Bilal Abbas, Mitti day Baway featuring Wahaj Ali and Mahira Khan, among others. For an audience not religiously glued to seeing any drama serial, even a visit to Twitter can reveal what are the trends in the particular drama serial, and what is the new development in the storyline. Another Drama to name one in the rating ladder Dar Nejat featuring a character named Abu Bakr is sometimes more prominent on Twitter than US Secretary of State Mark Rubio’s statement on the latest in the Iran crisis.

The reasons, which are subject of this opinion piece emanates from the fact that the general viewer not just plays safe in not indulging in the political debate, the characterization, the philosophical rationale of the storyline, the script, the acting and the limits of the creative production houses in tackling the subjects, all make it a convincing case for the common man to follow or idolize the drama characters or the actors playing the roles.

Consequently, what we see in an increasingly fast world and daily routines, where there is not much time left for the working ladies and men to return to home at 8 PM and get glued to the TV and LCD, a quick run through the YouTube Shorts, Facebook Reels or the Twitter video uploads keeps the interested viewer to learn what is the latest storyline development in this or that drama serial.

The shifting of the public attention is not just due to the better quality of equipment or better script, but it is a simple mathematics of human interest. If the access to a certain product, political news or holding political views is discouraged discreetly if not totally stopped on the back of an executive order, it is a natural flow of the market trends that the consumer settles for the next best possible product. It is just like that if mutton is not affordable, people switch to chicken or beef. 

If the political reporting is not present, political news is stale, people are likely to find a much greater common cause with the recent days trending drama serial Mitti day Baway main character Iqbal Chanan alias Bala; who incidentally is shown to be a common man pressed hard by the circumstances, further disadvantaged by the prevalent class structures and invisible social prejudices. All his acts of defiance with the authorities even if they be religious; in the case of the serial the heroine herself a Peer, the society, the people of his locality are applauded by the audience.

That applause brings home another hard fact, which might be a food for thought for the social observers. The man by his or her very nature shuns regimentation and oppression. The pressures of the state and society might push him or her to conceal his views, but a character like ‘Bala’ equals the 1980s Maula Jutt or Sultan Rahi in terms of identifying with the personality which not just defies the ‘authority’ but also in the process delivers justice. Even if justice is not administered, the catharsis of that common man on the street is the centrepoint of that shift in the viewer's preference.

For the businesses it is a good development as viewership of any hit serial determines the advertising strategy and the definition of the prime time. For the polity and the system of a state as a whole, the creative arts not just provide a cryptic outlet to the pent-up thoughts, but also keeps the population engaged still in a pastime, which saves them from drowning into the cesspool of despair. The caption under discussion can generate enough thoughts to compile a book; but that expression of ideas can be a teaser for further debate.

内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅