Punjab’s air quality dashboard stops at 500 even as pollution rises further

Punjab Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) dashboard uses a scale ranging from zero to 500, with seven categories covering conditions from good to hazardous.

LAHORE: Punjab’s official air quality monitoring system does not display readings above 500 on the Air Quality Index (AQI), making it difficult for residents to determine the actual severity of pollution when smog levels exceed the scale’s maximum value.

The Punjab Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) dashboard uses a scale ranging from zero to 500, with seven categories covering conditions from good to hazardous. However, once the AQI reaches 500, the displayed figure remains unchanged even if pollution continues to increase.

This means that readings equivalent to 600, 700 or higher cannot be distinguished on the public dashboard, raising concerns among environmental experts about the availability of detailed pollution data.

According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency, an AQI of 500 represents the upper boundary of the standard index rather than the maximum possible level of air pollution. The agency also provides a mechanism for communicating conditions that exceed the conventional scale.

Punjab Senior Minister Marriyum Aurangzeb defended the government’s approach, saying the AQI was similarly capped at 500 in several countries, including the United States.

She maintained that the provincial government was not withholding information and explained that pollution beyond the index’s upper limit was classified as hazardous.

Environmental lawyer Altamash Saeed acknowledged that making real-time readings from government monitoring stations publicly accessible was a positive development but argued that a single index value could not adequately explain the extent of pollution.

He said information about individual pollutants and their concentrations across different neighbourhoods was necessary for residents, researchers and policymakers.

When all readings above 500 appear identical, it becomes difficult to identify which areas are experiencing more severe pollution or whether conditions are improving or deteriorating.

Mariam Shah, an expert associated with the Pakistan Air Quality Initiative, offered a different assessment, explaining that a maximum displayed AQI of 500 did not necessarily establish that pollution information was being deliberately concealed.

She pointed out that the highest category already indicated extremely dangerous air quality and warranted avoiding outdoor activities.

However, Shah also stressed the importance of publishing concentrations of fine particulate matter, or PM2.5, which she considered a more useful measure of pollution in Pakistan and other South Asian countries.

She explained that AQI calculations differ internationally and can depend on the pollutants used to determine the index, making direct access to PM2.5 concentrations particularly valuable.

The absence of more detailed readings also presents difficulties for academic research.

Nosheen Fatima, an environmental sciences student at the University of Punjab, said researchers needed accurate location-specific measurements to compare pollution levels across different parts of the province.

Without figures beyond the index’s maximum, she said, meaningful comparisons between severely polluted areas become difficult.

WWF Pakistan Director General Hammad Naqi also called for unrestricted public access to accurate air quality information, arguing that residents needed reliable measurements to make decisions about protecting themselves and their families.

Meanwhile, Abdul Rehman, a resident of Lahore’s Gulberg neighbourhood, alleged that limiting the displayed readings could create the impression that the government’s pollution-control measures were producing better results than the actual conditions suggested.

内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅