Reopening the provinces’ debate

Interior Minister returns to the fray with a new proposal

Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi had started the debate over new provinces by saying flatly that more provinces were needed, so it was perhaps fitting that he revived the debate by saying that a referendum should be held. The debate seems to have died down after it became obvious that there were no political forces interested enough in such a scheme to put much weight behind it. Mr Naqvi had to say, as did some senior PML(N) figures, that this was his personal opinion. He is considered close to President Asif Zardari, whom he visited in Nawabshah on Thursday to discuss this idea. He talked to journalists in Lahore after meeting Mr Zardari, and said that a referendum was necessary before the matter could be pursued further. He also said that the parties in the ruling coalition would also have to be brought in agreement on the issue.

Mr Naqvi is not only closer to President Zardari than any other coalition figure, but he is also considered close to the establishment, from which voices in support of new provinces has been heard. However, there does not seem to be any clarity about the scheme, Unless there is a detailed proposal before them, a referendum might prove to be analogous to asking voters to sign a blank cheque. There are formidable political obstacles to be overcome. President Zardari was also the right person to contact, not just because of his party’s earlier support, expressed in a resolution in the National Assembly, for the creation of Seraiki provinces, but also because the most violent opposition to the creation of more provinces came from the Sindh PPP. The opposition to any extra-constitutional mechanism was also strongest within the PPP.

The PML(N) has not taken a stand on the issue, though Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal has said that new units were needed, or districts had to be empowered. An overwhelming response was that the local councils had to be made as active as was contemplated in the Constitution. It does seem that unless an existing constitutional provision is not tried out and found to be wanting, it does not seem wise to plunge into something that needs a referendum, a massive constitutional amendments, enabling resolutions from all provincial assemblies, as well as a bureaucratic kerfuffle lasting several years.

内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅