Cunningham: Coleman 'hybrid role' a mistake

Kenny Cunningham: Uncertainty over Seamus Coleman's 'hybrid role' can't go on much longer

Updated / Friday, 13 Nov 2026 19:32

Seamus Coleman ahead of a training session at the Raiffesian Arena in Linz

Former Republic of Ireland captain Kenny Cunningham says that Seamus Coleman's present 'hybrid role' is not sustainable and a decision needs to be made on his status within the set-up soon.

The 38-year old Coleman is without a club after leaving Everton at the end of last season and once again has been excluded from the 24-man squad for this week's international window.

However, unlike the previous four-game window, Coleman is around the camp this week, with Heimir Hallgrimsson explaining that the full-back would be involved in a hybrid capacity that will encompass training with the squad and a support role alongside the coaching staff.

The Euro 2016 veteran, whose return to the starting line-up for the October and November games last year helped trigger a revival after the loss in Armenia, played the full 90 minutes and the opening period of extra-time in Ireland's agonising first round play-off shootout loss to Czechia in March.

He recently said he "edging towards" retirement in a UK media appearance but so far has yet to make that call.

"I think this is a mistake and I feared we might get to this position some months ago with Seamus," Cunningham said on RTÉ Radio 1's Inside Sport.

"After that game at the Czech Republic, we all knew it was going to be two and a half years down the road until the next major finals at the European Championships.

"That's a long time for someone who is Seamus's age, somebody who's not playing regular first team football."

Cunningham feels that the best decision that could have been made was for Coleman to retire from international football in the aftermath of the game in Prague and for him to step into a coaching role immediately.

"My gut feeling was what would be best - and again this may be not my place to say - would be if he stepped aside then and a role was made for him on the coaching staff immediately.

"He's hugely respected within the squad, his words carry weight. And I think it could have been the start of something with Seamus as part of the coaching set-up going forward for Ireland.

"And in the meantime, he would have had a hands-on role in finding the players in the full-back positions who could replace him.

"James Abankwah is there at the moment. I don't think he's a natural fit. I don't think there is one at the moment.

"The way we're playing at the moment. We haven't got a natural successor to Seamus, particularly in the right-back position.

Heimir Hallgrimsson and Seamus Coleman

"Seamus's value going forward after the Czech Republic game would have been as a coach, as a mentor to maybe those small group of players who Heimer felt could replace him in that area of the pitch.

"But that hasn't happened. So Seamus has continued.

"He hasn't got a football club, hasn't been playing competitive football, hasn't been taken onto the coaching ticket, but yet he's been brought into the squad.

"We're told not as a player and certainly not as part of the coaching staff. He won't be involved in the conversations between the coaches in terms of run-up to the game. So I think it's very messy."

Coleman will be around the current guise for this window but Cunningham is adamant that when the squad reconvene in March - either for a promotion-relegation play-off or for a pair of friendlies - the full-back's role needs to be placed on a surer and more defined footing.

"From Seamus's point of view, I think it's a strange one in terms of how he sees himself in that particular setup," Cunningham argues.

"I think it's got to be one or the other. You pick Seamus as a player in the squad and he competes with all the other players as he has done for the last 15 years for a place within that squad on his own merits.

"Or you pick him as part of the coaching staff. And for me, that was the best decision to be made, and it should have been made some months ago.

"This can't go on. After this window, the players will come back together next March and this needs to be resolved one way or the other.

"Because this hybrid role can't continue for much longer."


Listen to the RTÉ Soccer podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts.

Watch Austria v Republic of Ireland in the UEFA Nations League on Saturday from 7pm on RTÉ2 and RTÉ Player. Follow our live blog on RTÉ.ie/sport and RTÉ News app and listen to live commentary on Saturday Sport on RTÉ Radio 1

More stories on

Read Next

内容来自 RTÉ - Sport,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅