LHC Acquits Man in Toddler’s Death Case, Citing Gaps in Evidence

  1. English News
  2. Pakistan News
  3. LHC Acquits Man in Toddler’s Death Case, Citing Gaps in…

The Lahore High Court set aside the conviction and Rs2.05 million diyat order, saying witnesses had not seen the tractor hit the child and the remains’ identity was not established.

LAHORE, (Pakistan Point News - 13th Nov, 2026) The Lahore High Court (LHC) has acquitted a man convicted in a case involving the death of a two-year-old girl in an alleged tractor accident,setting aside his conviction and a diyat payment of Rs.2.05 million after finding serious flaws in the prosecution's evidence.

In a 14-page detailed judgment released on Friday,Justice Tariq Saleem Sheikh allowed the criminal revision petition filed by the convict,observing that the prosecution had failed to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.

The court ordered his immediate release if he was not required in any other case.

According to the prosecution,Haikal Bibi(2) was allegedly run over by a tractor while her family was harvesting potatoes in a field at Chakbedi,Pakpattan,on March 12, 2019.

Her grandmother,Sakina Bibi alleged that the tractor driver concealed the child's body beneath empty sacks after the incident.

However,FIR was registered on October 8, 2019,nearly seven months after the incident.

The trial court had convicted the petitioner under Section-322 of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) and directed him to pay Rs.2,055,936 as diyat to the deceased's legal heirs.

His appeal against the conviction was subsequently dismissed by the appellate court.

In his judgment,Justice Tariq Saleem Sheikh observed that neither of the two prosecution witnesses had witnessed the tractor hitting the child.

He also pointed out contradictions in their statements and noted that Kalsoom Bibi,the deceased girl's mother and a key natural witness to the incident had not been produced before the trial court.

The judge observed that the unexplained delay of six months and 26 days in registration of the FIR,coupled with the fact that the accused had not been nominated initially,further weakened the prosecution's case.

The court also identified serious shortcomings in the identification of the child's remains,which had been exhumed several months after her burial.

The medical officer had admitted during cross-examination that the skeleton was unidentifiable and that she could not confirm whether the remains belonged to Haikal Bibi.

The judgment noted that neither DNA testing nor radiological examination had been conducted to establish the identity of the remains or confirm the alleged fatal skull fracture.

The medical officer had also acknowledged that she could not give a final opinion without the Punjab Forensic Science Agency (PFSA) report.

The court further observed that the prosecution had failed to establish any forensic or physical link between the tractor allegedly driven by the petitioner and the child's death,adding that the vehicle had neither been produced during the trial nor subjected to mechanical inspection.

The judgment also laid down guidelines for cases involving exhumation,particularly regarding the identification of graves and human remains,medical examination,preservation of forensic samples and maintenance of their chain of custody.

Emphasising the principle of criminal justice,the judge observed that the benefit of every reasonable doubt must go to the accused as a matter of right rather than as a concession or favour.

Consequently,the court set aside the conviction and sentence,acquitted the petitioner and ordered his immediate release,provided he was not wanted in any other case.

Related topics PakistanAccidentLahore High CourtPunjabDriverVehiclePakpattanSaleem SheikhMarchOctoberCriminals
Next story PakistanHavelian Administration Reclaims More Than 30 Kanals of Government Land

内容来自 UrduPoint News,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅