Uganda: Uganda's Mining Sector - Can Community Development Agreements Deliver a Fair Share?

From Karamoja's Rupa community to the national policy debate, Community Development Agreements promise to give people living alongside mining projects a stronger voice and a greater share of the benefits. But can negotiated commitments translate into lasting development? Ronald Musoke reports.

A community of over 43,000 people cannot easily bargain with a mining company as individuals. But give that community a legal identity, elected leadership and a plan for managing its resources, and the balance begins to change.

That was the thinking behind the work in Rupa Sub-County, Moroto District, in the northeastern region of Karamoja, where mineral and energy lawyer Geoffrey Ojok Odur helped organise residents into a community trust capable of negotiating with investors; not simply over access to land, but over what mining could mean for the community long after the minerals have been extracted.

The ambitions are substantial: community-led commercial ventures, health and education facilities, local employment, opportunities for women and a plan for life after mining. The Rupa experience is now being held up as an example of how organised communities can negotiate a greater stake in mineral development. But it also raises a bigger question for Uganda: how can the country ensure that the wealth generated beneath its soil translates into lasting benefits for the people who live above it?

Keep up with the latest headlines on WhatsApp | LinkedIn

That question took centre stage on Nov. 6, at Protea Hotel in Kampala, where government officials, civil society organisations, mining-sector representatives, academics, development partners and community actors gathered to examine how Community Development Agreements (CDAs) could strengthen benefit-sharing and accountability in the extractives sector.

The national dialogue, organised by the Uganda Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (UGEITI), the Advocates Coalition for Development and Environment (ACODE), the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI) and the Uganda Association of Artisanal and Small-scale Miners (UGAASM), brought together participants under the theme: "From Mineral Wealth to Community Development."

The message running through the discussions was clear: publishing figures on mineral revenues is important, but it is not enough. Communities need to know what is being extracted, what government and companies are earning, what benefits are due to them, and whether the promises made in their name are being honoured.

The wealth beneath the ground

Uganda's mining sector is becoming an increasingly important part of the national economy. The country's Fifth Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) Report, covering the 2023/2024 financial year and launched on Sept. 23, puts total extractive-sector revenues at about Shs663.24bn. Mining and quarrying accounted for about Shs 336.97bn. The figures offer a measure of the sector's economic contribution. They also sharpen the question of how the benefits are distributed.

Uganda has implemented the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) since 2020. The initiative brings government, companies and civil society together to improve transparency and accountability in the management of natural resources. Its reporting process discloses information about payments made by extractive companies and revenues received by the government.

Yet transparency does not automatically mean that people in mining areas enjoy better roads, improved health services, more jobs or stronger household incomes. For communities, the costs of extraction can be immediate and deeply personal. For instance, land access becomes contested, livelihoods are disrupted, the environment comes under pressure and traditional ways of life may be affected. The economic returns, by contrast, can appear distant, complicated or difficult to trace.

That gap between resource wealth and local development was central to the remarks of Onesmus Mugyenyi, the Deputy Executive Director of ACODE. He described it as the "paradox of poverty amidst plenty." "The value of the resource is consistently going up (while) the communities that host the resources are consistently either stagnant or going down," he said.

For Mugyenyi, the challenge is not simply to produce more reports or publish more revenue figures. Citizens and community organisations must be equipped to use the information to demand accountability. "We need to move away from just transparency to what we call transformative accountability," he said.

That means asking questions beyond how much companies pay and how much the government collects. Are revenues reaching the communities entitled to benefit? Are local governments using their allocations to improve services? Are household incomes and livelihoods improving? Are women, young people and vulnerable groups benefiting from investment in the sector? These are the questions that give transparency its practical value. They also point to the role CDAs can play in making companies' community-development commitments more specific, measurable and open to scrutiny.

What the law requires

Uganda's Mining and Minerals Act, 2022, provides a legal basis for this approach. Under Section 229, holders of qualifying mineral rights are required to negotiate Community Development Agreements with representatives of communities likely to be affected by mining operations. The requirement excludes holders of prospecting, exploration and artisanal mining licences.

The agreements are intended to provide a framework for identifying community development priorities, setting out company commitments and establishing ways of monitoring implementation. Consultations should be open, inclusive and non-coercive, with deliberate efforts to involve women, youth and vulnerable groups.

The distinction between a CDA and corporate social responsibility is important. Corporate social responsibility activities may be undertaken at a company's discretion and can reflect its own priorities. On the other hand, a CDA is a statutory requirement for qualifying mineral-right holders and is negotiated around the needs and priorities of affected communities.

In his presentation, Odur stressed that communities should not simply receive whatever a company decides to offer. They should have a meaningful role in identifying what is needed and negotiating commitments that respond to their circumstances.

A well-negotiated agreement can also provide for monitoring, evaluation and the resolution of disputes between a company and the community. In other words, it should be more than a list of good intentions. It should establish obligations that can be followed up. But the law alone cannot guarantee a fair outcome. Communities need the organisation, information and negotiating capacity to engage companies on more equal terms. That is where the experience of Rupa becomes particularly instructive.

Rupa: organising before negotiating

Odur's account of Rupa Sub-County offered participants a practical illustration of what community organisation can achieve. When he began working with the community in 2017, he said, it was difficult for an investor to engage with a population of about 43,000 people without a recognised structure through which decisions could be made and represented.

The response was to establish the Rupa Community Development Trust, which became a legal entity in 2017. The trust brought the community's beneficiaries into a formal structure, with an elected board of trustees and an annual general meeting at which the board reports to the wider membership.

The three clans identified as landowners were represented in the arrangement, alongside women's representation. The aim was to create a structure that could speak for the community, manage its interests and be held accountable by its members.

The community land was subsequently titled in the name of the trust and converted to freehold, Odur said. This gave investors a legal entity with which to negotiate, rather than requiring them to deal separately with thousands of individuals. It was a significant step.

Without a recognised community structure, negotiations over land, compensation and development commitments can become fragmented, leaving individuals with limited bargaining power and creating opportunities for disagreement over who speaks for whom.

Odur described mining governance as a relationship involving three principal parties; the central government, which holds mineral rights on behalf of the people; communities, which have interests in the land and are affected by mining; and investors, who bring the capital needed to extract the minerals. "There must be a marriage. There is a marriage to ensure that each party benefits from the mining," he said.

The metaphor captures the central argument of his presentation- mining should not be treated as a transaction in which one party gains at the expense of the others. It requires a relationship in which the interests and responsibilities of government, investors and communities are recognised.

He also emphasised that the community affected by mining is not limited to people whose land is directly occupied. It includes those indirectly affected by activities such as noise, pollution and other environmental impacts. That broader understanding matters. A mine may occupy a defined area, but its effects can extend beyond the boundary of the land being worked.

Compensation is not community development

One of the important lessons from Rupa is the need to distinguish between surface-rights agreements and Community Development Agreements. Surface rights relate to the use of land for mining activities and compensation for those whose land is directly affected. A CDA, on the other hand, concerns wider community development priorities and the commitments negotiated with the mining company.

Odur told participants that the Rupa arrangement included Shs8.8 billion in compensation for the directly affected community. He described this as separate from a further Shs 6.8 billion commitment for community development projects. The distinction is crucial. Compensation for land directly affected by a mining operation is not the same as investment in facilities and opportunities intended to benefit the wider community.

Odur said the Shs 6.8 billion was negotiated for projects identified by the community, with the funds intended to be channelled towards those projects. The community's decision to direct resources towards projects rather than simply distribute cash also reflected concerns about the long-term value of compensation. Odur recalled the community's reasoning: "Money should not be given to us; it should be put in terms of projects."

The thinking was that one-off cash payments could be quickly spent without creating lasting assets or opportunities. Investment in community priorities, by contrast, could help build infrastructure, skills and economic activities that continue generating value.

That approach is not without challenges. Projects require sound planning, competent management, transparent procurement and ongoing oversight. A school, health facility or commercial venture does not become sustainable merely because it appears in an agreement. It must be properly delivered, maintained and managed.

From promises to an economic base

The Rupa model seeks to go beyond the conventional idea of a company providing a few community projects. It aims to turn negotiated commitments into a foundation for longer-term economic participation.

Odur described plans for the community to engage in commercial activities linked to mining, including lime and marble production and the supply of materials to companies. He said a small-scale mining licence had been carved out of a larger mining lease to enable community participation in lime production. The proposed uses of the lime include supplying gold miners, producing fertiliser and supporting manufacturing. He also described arrangements for the community to supply marble to a paint-manufacturing company.

The ambition is to create a continuing source of income rather than rely solely on a one-time payment. In Odur's account, some of these arrangements are intended to operate over a 49-year period. The trust has also established a company wholly owned by the trust to undertake commercial activities. The idea is to separate the trust's role in representing and overseeing community interests from the business operations of the investment arm.

Profits generated through the company are intended to support community development. Odur presented this as a way of keeping the value created from community resources within a structure that can reinvest in the people it represents. "Let us manage these resources," he said.

The approach is ambitious, but it also raises important questions about commercial risk and governance. Community-owned businesses need sound business plans, professional management, transparent accounts and clear rules on how profits are used. They must be able to withstand fluctuations in mineral prices, changing markets and the eventual closure of mining operations.

A community company that depends entirely on one investor or one product may remain vulnerable. The long-term test will be whether the ventures can become commercially viable and diversify the community's sources of income.

Health, education and women's participation

The proposed benefits in Rupa also include social infrastructure and human-capital development. Odur described plans for a Level III health centre and an ambulance to serve a geographically dispersed community. The need, he explained, became particularly apparent during a difficult childbirth experience he witinessed during one of the community engagements. That graphic scene, he said, highlighted the challenges women face in accessing health services. An ambulance, he said, would help transport patients and expectant mothers from more remote areas to the health facility. The community also negotiated for irrigation infrastructure and a dam to support livelihoods.

In education, Odur outlined a commitment for 10 university students from the community to receive scholarships annually over 49 years. He described a further arrangement intended to support students at secondary level and create a pathway into university education.

These are significant commitments if fully delivered. But they should be measured by actual outcomes: how many students receive support, whether they complete their studies, whether the health facility becomes operational and whether the infrastructure meets the needs of the people it is intended to serve.

Women's participation in mining-related opportunities emerged as another important issue. Odur said the arrangement included a commitment to train 10 women annually over 49 years for roles in mining activities. He described training opportunities in truck driving and equipment operation, among other areas.

Yet he also acknowledged cultural barriers. Some men, he said, remained resistant to women taking up work in mining, reflecting attitudes that confine women to domestic roles. The point is significant because a community agreement can include commitments on women's employment and training, but implementation depends on whether women can access those opportunities in practice. Inclusion must be reflected in the design of projects, the selection of beneficiaries and the distribution of economic opportunities--not merely in the language of the agreement.

Planning for the day the mine closes

Mining is temporary. Even where operations continue for decades, deposits eventually decline, markets change and companies move on. For communities that depend heavily on mining-related activity, closure can leave behind disrupted land, lost employment and an economy that has not developed alternatives.

Odur said the Rupa model includes planning for what happens after mining. He described proposals for a limestone quarry pit to be converted into a lake that could support livestock, irrigation and farming. The idea is to ensure that land altered by extraction can serve another purpose once mining ends.

Such planning is essential to responsible mining. Closure and rehabilitation should not be treated as matters to consider only when operations are winding down. They need to be built into the life of a mining project, with clear responsibilities, resources and community involvement. For Rupa, the proposed lake is one example of how a community might think beyond the immediate revenue generated by extraction and consider what assets will remain when the company leaves.

Transparency needs to deliver results

The national dialogue in Kampala placed these local concerns within a wider debate about the purpose of transparency. UGEITI's Fifth EITI Report provides figures on extractive-sector revenues, including the Shs336.97 billion attributed to mining and quarrying. But the figures are only a starting point. They do not, on their own, tell communities whether the benefits of extraction are reaching them or whether the costs are being properly addressed.

Mugyenyi's call for transformative accountability was therefore an appeal to use information to assess real outcomes. Civil society organisations and communities need the capacity to interpret reports, ask questions and follow up on the answers.

Minister Amos Lugoloobi also highlighted the need to strengthen institutional capacity and accountability in the sector. He questioned how effectively Uganda tracks minerals extracted in one region and processed elsewhere, asking whether communities in places such as Karamoja are being left better off or more disadvantaged.

He also challenged stakeholders to consider whether the country is maximizing the value of its minerals before they leave Uganda, and whether the revenues generated are translating into infrastructure, employment and better services

His sentiments underline the fact that benefit-sharing is not solely a matter between a mining company and a host community. The government has responsibilities too: regulating operations, collecting revenues, monitoring production, protecting the environment and ensuring that public resources support national and local development.

A challenge from the mining sector

But the discussions in Kampala also exposed a tension that policymakers and advocates of CDAs will need to address: how to secure meaningful community benefits while keeping the mining sector commercially viable.

Kenneth Asiimwe, the Chief Executive Officer of the Uganda Association of Artisanal and Small-scale Miners (UGAASM), argued that transparency alone does not create practical incentives for mining businesses.

"There is nobody who benefits from just being transparent," he said. His argument was not that transparency is unnecessary. Rather, he challenged the government and development partners to connect it to tangible benefits for companies that comply with reporting and governance requirements.

He proposed incentives such as preferential financing for transparent companies through the Uganda Development Bank, better access to smelters and refineries, improved mineral pricing and more support services for small-scale miners. He also urged government to invest in extension services and shared facilities that could help small-scale operators improve their productivity and formalise their activities.

Sign up for free AllAfrica Newsletters

Get the latest in African news delivered straight to your inbox

The intervention offered an important counterpoint to the focus on large mining projects and negotiated community agreements. Uganda's mining economy includes thousands of small-scale operators whose livelihoods, investment constraints and relationships with government differ from those of large companies.

Asiimwe warned against treating the arrival of a mining company as a substitute for the government. Companies can make important contributions, but they cannot be expected to replace the state's responsibility to provide public services and establish the conditions for local development.

His sentiments also raise a practical question for CDA implementation: how can agreements be designed so that community benefits are real and enforceable without imposing commitments that undermine the viability of mining operations? That balance will require clear rules, realistic obligations, open negotiations and a shared understanding of what companies, government and communities are each responsible for delivering.

A model agreement-and the test of implementation

The government itself acknowledged that more work is needed to ensure agreements deliver fair outcomes. During the dialogue, Minister Lugoloobi said some CDAs submitted for review had not adequately benefited the communities concerned. He called for stakeholders to contribute to the development of a model agreement that mining companies could use, so that communities do not feel cheated and companies have a clearer framework for meeting their obligations. The call points to a weakness that can undermine even well-intentioned legislation: unequal negotiating capacity.

A community may be legally entitled to negotiate, but that does not mean it has access to the technical, legal and financial expertise needed to assess a proposed agreement. Nor does it mean all members of the community are adequately represented in the process.

The Rupa experience suggests that organised representation can make a difference. But a trust or community association must itself remain accountable to the people it represents. Regular reporting, transparent financial management, inclusive decision-making and accessible information are essential if community structures are not to become another layer between residents and the benefits intended for them.

The Mining and Minerals Act's emphasis on open and inclusive consultation is therefore not a procedural detail. It is central to whether CDAs can work. Women, young people and vulnerable groups must be able to influence priorities and participate in the opportunities created by agreements. The lessons also extend beyond Karamoja. Odur also pointed to mining communities in Buhweju, Tororo, Busia, Namayingo, Katwe, Kitgum, Ntungamo and other areas where community engagement and better benefit-sharing arrangements could be valuable.

The real measure of mineral wealth

Uganda's mineral resources offer opportunities for investment, public revenue, employment and economic transformation. But the value of the sector cannot be measured only by the volume of minerals extracted or the revenue reported by government.

It must also be measured by what happens in the communities that host mining operations; whether livelihoods improve, whether local businesses grow, whether women and young people gain meaningful opportunities, whether environmental responsibilities are met and whether public infrastructure is stronger because mining has taken place.

Rupa offers one possible route towards that ambition. Its experience, although not yet perfect, shows the importance of organising communities before negotiations, separating land compensation from broader development commitments, identifying community priorities and exploring ways to turn resources into long-term economic activity.

But the model's promise will ultimately be judged by delivery. The negotiated funds must reach the intended projects. The health and education commitments must translate into services and opportunities. The commercial ventures must become sustainable. The community's leadership must remain answerable to its members. And plans for mine closure must be more than aspirations.

For the government, the challenge is to make the law work consistently and ensure that public revenues and regulatory oversight support development. For companies, it is to treat community commitments as obligations to be honoured, not public-relations exercises. For communities, it is to organise, participate and hold their representatives and partners accountable. The question raised in Kampala was not whether Uganda should develop its mineral resources; it was whether the country can do so in a way that leaves host communities with more than memories of extraction.

内容来自 AllAfrica - Business,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅