Ukraine and the return of great-power politics

Harking back to Yalta

The prospect of a broader security agreement between the USA and Russia has opened a new debate about the future of European security. What initially appeared to be an effort to end the war in Ukraine is now raising questions about NATO's position, Europe's strategic autonomy and Russia's ambitions to regain influence over the countries that once formed part of its political and strategic neighbourhood.

The controversy intensified after US President Donald Trump met Russian presidential envoy Kirill Dmitriev at the White House on November 5. Trump suggested that an agreement with Moscow could extend beyond Ukraine and involve the wider European continent. Although he offered few details, his remarks immediately attracted attention in European capitals. The possibility that Washington and Moscow might negotiate a new security arrangement without the full participation of European governments has created considerable unease among the USA's traditional allies.

The proposed initiative comes at a critical moment. The war in Ukraine has fundamentally altered Europe's security environment, exposed divisions within the Western alliance and revived questions about the limits of US commitments to European defence. For Moscow, the conflict has also become an opportunity to challenge the post-Cold War security order, particularly NATO's expansion into Central and Eastern Europe. Russia has consistently argued that NATO enlargement threatens its national security.

Before launching its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, Moscow demanded restrictions on NATO's expansion and changes to the alliance's military presence in Eastern Europe. Its demands included a rollback of military deployments and weapons systems in countries that joined NATO after 1997. These proposals were rejected by Washington and its European allies, who maintained that sovereign states have the right to determine their own security arrangements.

The emerging US initiative has therefore raised an important question: is Washington prepared to accommodate some of Russia's longstanding security demands in exchange for an agreement ending the war in Ukraine? European governments are particularly concerned that negotiations could gradually establish a new understanding of European security based on the interests of major powers rather than the sovereign rights of individual states. Countries such as Poland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Romania regard NATO membership as the foundation of their national security. Any arrangement restricting the alliance's military presence or future expansion would have direct consequences for their strategic calculations.

The concern is not simply about NATO's military deployments. It is also about the political principle underpinning Europe's post-Cold War order. Since the dissolution of the USSR in 1991, countries in Central and Eastern Europe have sought closer political, economic and security relations with Western institutions. Their decision to join NATO and the European Union reflected their own national preferences, not merely the strategic calculations of Washington or Brussels. Allowing Moscow a determining role in these decisions would raise serious questions about the sovereignty of smaller European states. It could also establish a precedent in which powerful countries claim special rights over the foreign and security policies of their neighbours.

The question facing Washington is therefore not simply how to reach an agreement with Moscow, but what kind of European order that agreement would create. A settlement that ends one war at the expense of the security and independence of other countries may leave the foundations of another crisis firmly in place.

For Vladimir Putin, a revised European security arrangement could provide an opportunity to secure strategic concessions that Russia has been unable to obtain through diplomatic negotiations or military pressure. Moscow may seek limitations on NATO's eastern presence, restrictions on Ukraine's future military cooperation with the West and recognition of Russian security interests in neighbouring countries. However, the US position remains less clearly defined. The Trump Administration presents its initiative as an attempt to address the security concerns of all parties and create conditions for a lasting settlement. Jared Kushner, who is involved in the diplomatic effort alongside US special envoy Steve Witkoff, has identified post-war security guarantees, economic recovery and mechanisms to prevent renewed conflict as important elements of the negotiations.

The immediate test will come at the planned trilateral talks between the USA, Russia and Ukraine in Abu Dhabi on November 10 and 11. The discussions are expected to address the termination of hostilities, security guarantees, humanitarian arrangements and the future of Ukraine. European representatives are also seeking involvement, arguing that decisions affecting the continent's security cannot be taken without their participation. The debate inevitably recalls the Yalta Conference of 1945, when the USA, Britain and the UUSR discussed the political arrangements of post-war Europe. The historical circumstances are considerably different, but the comparison highlights a familiar concern: whether major powers can determine the future of smaller states through negotiations conducted largely among themselves.

There is, nevertheless, a distinction between accommodating legitimate security concerns and accepting a sphere of influence. Arms-control arrangements, military transparency, crisis communication and reciprocal reductions in tensions could contribute to European stability. Such measures would not necessarily undermine NATO or compromise the sovereignty of its members. The problem would arise if these arrangements imposed restrictions on countries that were not parties to the negotiations. Europe, meanwhile, faces an uncomfortable strategic reality. Its dependence on American military capabilities has become a subject of renewed debate. If Washington pursues a separate understanding with Moscow, European governments may accelerate efforts to strengthen their own defence capabilities and reduce their reliance on US security guarantees. This could reshape relations within NATO even without any formal change to the alliance.

Ultimately, the future of European security cannot be determined solely by an agreement between Washington and Moscow. Ukraine must have a meaningful role in decisions concerning its territory and security, while European countries must participate in negotiations affecting their collective defence. Ending the war is an important objective, but the terms of peace will matter as much as the cessation of fighting. An agreement that recognises national sovereignty and establishes reciprocal security commitments could help reduce tensions. One that divides Europe into competing spheres of influence would risk reviving the very political conditions that the continent sought to leave behind after the Cold War.

The question facing Washington is therefore not simply how to reach an agreement with Moscow, but what kind of European order that agreement would create. A settlement that ends one war at the expense of the security and independence of other countries may leave the foundations of another crisis firmly in place.

内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅