Debunked: Old, discredited claims revived saying that Pfizer vaccines cause infertility
FALSE CLAIMS THAT secret data shows that mRNA vaccines are a “bioweapon” that makes people infertile have been re-shared hundreds of times online since they were shared by former television host Aisling O’Loughlin.
The claims had first spread in American conspiracy theorist circles years ago, largely by the author Naomi Wolf, who appears in a video posted by O’Loughlin citing a trove of safety data provided by Pfizer to US authorities, often called the “Pfizer files.”
However, Wolf’s claims were quickly debunked by fact-checkers, who noted that she misrepresented what was in the files, as well as misunderstanding how the safety data was collected and analysed.
Huge amounts of data were collected by Pfizer and medical authorities in efforts to identify negative effects of the vaccines. However, this evidence suggests that they do not adversely affect fertility.
While similar claims about “bioweapons” and infertility caused by vaccines were also spread in Ireland and Europe, these rarely cited the Pfizer files as a source. This is likely due to the free availability of European data on adverse events from when the vaccines became available.
Naomi Wolf came to prominence as a feminist author in the 1990s, though has been criticised for serious inaccuracies in her work and subsequent promotion of numerous conspiracy theories often featuring Covid-19 and vaccine misinformation.
Last St Patrick’s Day, Wolf posted on X suggesting that banners up around Dublin were Satanic, as they featured stylised images of snakes.
Aisling O’Loughlin, a former presenter of TV3 programme Xposé, has spread misinformation about Covid-19 and vaccines on social media since 2021.
In a video posted to Facebook on 3 November, O’Loughlin interviewed Wolf, who spoke about documents she claimed were “supposed to be hidden”.
“These documents, there are tens of thousands of them, reveal the greatest crime against humanity in recorded history,” Wolf says, adding that the vaccines were aimed at “destroying human reproduction, especially female reproduction”.
Wolf went on to say that “mRNA injections are a bioweapon” and that the files included “charts of tens of thousands of women whose menstrual cycles have been horrifically disrupted by the mRNA injection”.
She continues: “They ruined these tens of thousands of women’s menstrual cycles and lives and didn’t stop, but kept going. That is one of the key points to me that points to that this was really an intentional war on women, and a war on reproduction.”
These claims are false, and similar comments made by Wolf on GB News were found by the UK broadcasting regulator to have breached their rules against potentially harmful content after 422 complaints were received about the segment.
Even without delving into the data mentioned by Wolf, there are serious reasons to doubt her claims.
Ireland had one of the highest vaccination uptake rates, with about 98% of working people reportedly taking at least a primary course of vaccines, and more than 95% having subsequent boosters.
If vaccines were a “bioweapon” that made people infertile, one may expect the country’s birthrate to have suddenly dropped by about 98% since the vaccine rollout.
Ireland’s birth rate has been falling for decades, plummeting by about 4.5% a year in the late 80s, though it did see a period of marginal growth between 1994 and 2008.
However, this decline has lessened since the rollout of the vaccine. Live births per person dropped by 3.48% in 2018. The same measure has been about 1.65% a year since 2023.
In other words, if the vaccine was meant to further cause infertility, it didn’t work.
What about the files that Wolf was referring to?
Essentially, to get the go-ahead to distribute their vaccine, Pfizer had to submit huge amounts of data and documents to the US drug regulator, the FDA (Food and Drug Administration).
They and the FDA continued collecting safety data after the vaccines were publicly released to detect whether there were any negative effects of the vaccine that were not detected during the initial testing.
However, much of this safety data involved recording any adverse effects in recipients following the vaccine, even if there was no reason to suspect a causal effect.
Those reports have long been falsely claimed to be evidence that the vaccines cause harm.
While some of this safety data has been publicly available since 2020, vast tracts of the documents started to be released by the FDA in 2022 following a lawsuit — these are what are often referred to as the “Pfizer files” and are said to contain proof that the vaccine is fatal, or a bioweapon, or that it makes people infertile.
However, these events would only be meaningful if they were higher than one would expect to see in a control group who had not taken the vaccine.
For example, the number of patients getting a cold would be concerning if vaccine recipients were getting sick at a higher rate than normal.
Menstrual irregularities are very common, as are infertility and miscarriage.
The HSE says that one in six couples has difficulties becoming pregnant.
It is estimated that more than 15% of pregnancies where a heartbeat is detected are subsequently lost (about 23 million a year).
However, this is likely an undercount of pregnancies overall. Studies of women trying to conceive find that the total rate of pregnancy loss after implantation was 31%.
As such, we would expect to see significant amounts of reports on menstruation, infertility and miscarriage when looking at any large swaths of the population, let alone at the billions of people who were vaccinated for Covid.
However, the vaccine would only be considered a cause if these problems occurred at a higher rate than would have been expected.
So, what does the analysis of the data show?
The Pfizer vaccine does increase the chances of having menstrual irregularities, such as worse cramps or longer or shorter cycles.
This is a real and documented issue caused by the vaccines, which has been shown from safety data. However, it also quickly became clear that these irregularities were short-lived and had no long-term effect on overall fertility.
Wolf has seriously misrepresented what the data says by claiming that vaccines “ruined these tens of thousands of women’s menstrual cycles and lives”, apparently conflating reports of a missed or longer period with a serious life-altering injury.
“Several studies have shown that mRNA Covid-19 vaccines do not cause complications in pregnancy, either for expectant mothers or their babies”, the European Medicines Agency’s website reads.
“On the contrary, Covid-19 vaccines protect expectant mothers and their babies.”
The US authorities who had analysed the data came to the same conclusion.
As it happens, the extensive monitoring of safety data has brought to light real negative effects of the vaccines, such as very rare cases of myocarditis, inflammation of the heart muscle.
However, multiple studies of patients who developed this disease after the vaccine showed there were no deaths and analysis of the numbers shows that these real but small risks caused by vaccination are dwarfed by the serious risks of being unvaccinated — not least that Covid infections cause myocarditis at more than 40 times the rate of the vaccine.
The Journal’s FactCheck is a signatory to the International Fact-Checking Network’s Code of Principles. You can read it here. For information on how FactCheck works, what the verdicts mean, and how you can take part, check out our Reader’s Guide here. You can read about the team of editors and reporters who work on the factchecks here.
内容来自 TheJournal.ie,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗