A new frontier in climate governance
Solar Radiation Modification (SRM) is emerging as a potential climate policy option to reduce global temperatures as emission-cutting efforts fall short. However, Pakistan, one of the world's most climate-vulnerable countries, has limited participation in global discussions on this technology.
A new frontier in climate governance
Solar radiation modification
By: Dr Muhammad Mumtaz and Prof Athar Hussain
Currently, the world is taking action against carbon emissions and climate change, but it is short of what is expected. The gap between what scientists suggest with empirical evidence and what governments actually do is widening, resulting in a new and unsettling idea that has moved from climate science into serious policy conversations: deliberately cooling the Earth’s temperature to counter the negative complications of climate change. Scientists call this solar radiation modification (SRM).
SRM is a technology used to reduce the amount of the sun's heat that reaches or stays trapped near the Earth's surface, rather than waiting for emissions cuts alone to bring temperatures down. This idea is being debated as a climate policy option. As for Pakistan, a country that ranks among the most climate-vulnerable in the world, it has a limited participatory presence in the global discussions revolving around SRM.
Even though considerable funding is being directed toward SRM research globally, it is concentrated largely in the Global North. Hence, the way forward is ensuring Pakistan and comparable Global South countries are equipped to direct a meaningful share of that funding toward regionally led research. Given Pakistan's climate vulnerability and the unpredictable regional consequences SRM deployment may carry, remaining disengaged from this debate is not a viable long-term option
What is SRM? Several methods, like stratospheric aerosol injection (SAI), cirrus cloud thinning (CCT), and Marine Cloud Brightening (MCB), come under SRM. SAI involves releasing fine sulphur particles high in the atmosphere to reflect a small amount of sunlight back into space, whereas CCT works by thinning out high clouds so that more heat can escape from the Earth back into space. MCB involves making ocean clouds slightly whiter and more reflective, and is already being piloted in small trials near the Great Barrier Reef and in parts of the Arctic.
Even though building the scientific and technical capacity to deploy SRM responsibly requires higher financial and technical capacity, its relative financial feasibility makes it an attractive measure while the world continues to work towards lowering emissions. Therefore, scientific institutions across the globe are now putting serious efforts into further investigating SRM as a promising solution to tackle climate change impacts.
SRM Governance: SRM could potentially reduce the worst impacts of climate change. This includes protecting the most vulnerable regions to climate change from crop destruction, heat waves, glacial melts, and flash floods. SRM doesn’t have to replace emission reduction; however, it is a potential solution that could work along with mitigation and adaptation.
However, this does not mean unregulated SRM deployment would be an option. Even though it is a potential solution that could be more effective than emission reduction, extensive research and development regarding SRM has just begun over the last few years. It is also stated that unregulated deployment of SAI particles could accelerate ozone layer depletion, and deploying SRM technologies could lead to global conflict and threaten international peace.
Even though the climatic side-effects of SRM technologies can be projected in advance, non-climatic consequences remain unknown. Regional temperature and rainfall patterns could shift in ways that are difficult to predict, with knock-on effects for agriculture and food security in exactly the parts of the world least equipped to absorb the shock. Apart from this, the serious health impacts of SRM technology deployment are also highlighted, especially in areas that are already vulnerable to climate change impacts.
Governance is required to prevent unauthorized deployment and to detect irresponsible research that could pose socioeconomic or geopolitical risk. Despite more than two decades of research, there is no binding international legal instrument that yet governs SRM at any scale. This is partly because scholars have not identified which forums are best suited to govern it.
Under-representation of the Global South in SRM: Scientific bodies have made several attempts to build governance norms around SRM deployment, publishing various principles and frameworks under the banner of codes of conduct and policy implementation procedures. But, the governance capacity for SRM remains concentrated mostly in Global North countries. Most of the work on SRM is based in Europe and North America, while authors from Africa and South America combined accounted for only 3.1 percent of the total. Despite this, the impacts of these complex technologies are often borne by poorer nations. It is therefore imperative to involve countries from the Global South to ensure participation and decision-making on SRM.
Several workshops held in low-and-middle-income countries, including in Africa, have highlighted concern for risks to regional agriculture from SRM implementation, while also revealing a knowledge and capacity gap. This is why there is an urgent need to investigate public perceptions of SRM in the Global South, enabling comparison with the Global North.
The South Asian region has initiated objective research on SRM to understand its potential implications. India is advancing towards building the structural frameworks that are required to have a real argument in the global discussion surrounding SRM. A recent Indian survey found strong public support for a national SRM policy and a government-led coordinating committee. However, Nepal has almost no tangible activity on SRM, with no dedicated national effort to support advanced research on SRM.
In Pakistan, recent modelling research by the COMSATS University Islamabad (CUI) examined SRM’s impact on health, such as vector-borne diseases like malaria in Pakistan. The research demonstrated that evidence-based approaches are important for effective SRM deployment in the Global South as the region is facing disproportionate climate shocks. Therefore, serious efforts are required for the Global South countries to participate in collecting empirical evidence regarding SRM, as they are the countries that are most vulnerable to climate change impacts.
We have been observing and participating in the ongoing SRM governance debate over the last few years, including participation in COP30, in which a side event on SRM was documented on the UNFCCC's website, though it was not part of the primary agenda. Alongside this, we had extensive discussions at different forums: a public engagement workshop in the UK, participation in the Co-Create initiative's SRM activities in Brussels, discussions at the Gordon Research Conference in the United States, and continued involvement in different workshops, conferences and seminars discussing SRM governance and research. Most recently, we were invited to a discussion on SRM at CUI. In parallel, we contribute to an ARIA-funded (UK) project examining public perception of SRM across Pakistan, India, Bangladesh, Nepal, and Bhutan, involving sustained community engagement in each country.
Three observations emerge from this engagement. Firstly, SRM-related research in the Global South, and in Pakistan specifically, remains in its infancy. Secondly, public awareness of SRM in Pakistan is quite limited except for a small circle of specialists. Thirdly, Pakistan is unable to separate itself from the SRM debate given its acute climate exposure and the unpredictable regional implications SRM deployment could carry, which could include altered precipitation patterns and biodiversity effects specific to South Asian ecosystems; the outcomes remain inconclusive.
However, one of our experiences at Fatima Jinnah Women University, Rawalpindi illustrates how quickly this awareness gap can narrow. A talk conducted by Hassan Sipra affiliated with DSG, a US-based organization, with 70 to 80 students found that virtually none of the students were familiar with SRM beforehand. However, after the talk, much awareness had been created and consequently, one student, Munaza Rauf, completed her thesis on SRM governance under the supervision of Dr Mumtaz. We have since incorporated a dedicated discussion of SRM debates into the climate change policy courses we teach to create further awareness among students of public policy, therefore bridging the gap between research and academia.
The ongoing efforts for SRM governance and our field experience point toward a consistent policy position that it is not yet appropriate to integrate SRM into formal climate governance frameworks, in Pakistan or more broadly, given the current state of evidence and the unresolved ethical and governance questions surrounding the technology. What is required instead is advanced, ethically grounded research, sustained investment in public and policymaker education, and collaboration between regional and international actors.
For Pakistan specifically, this entails building independent research capacity, engaging government stakeholders proactively rather than reactively, and pursuing capacity-transfer partnerships that position institutions such as CUI as genuine co-producers of SRM knowledge rather than passive recipients of externally generated conclusions.
Even though considerable funding is being directed toward SRM research globally, it is concentrated largely in the Global North. Hence, the way forward is ensuring Pakistan and comparable Global South countries are equipped to direct a meaningful share of that funding toward regionally led research. Given Pakistan's climate vulnerability and the unpredictable regional consequences SRM deployment may carry, remaining disengaged from this debate is not a viable long-term option.
The writers are:
Dr Muhammad Mumtaz, Climate Policy Expert, Assistant Professor, Fatima Jinnah Women University, Rawalpindi, Pakistan.
Professor Ather Hussain, HoD Department of Remote Sensing and GIS, COMSATS University Islamabad, Pakistan.
内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗