UCD up on merit but 'bigger picture' at play - Cawley
On Saturday, the line-up for next season's SSE Airtricity Men's Premier Division was completed as UCD got the better of Drogheda United in the promotion/relegation play-off final at Tallaght Stadium.
The Students' victory made them the first outfit from the First Division to win the decider since Waterford beat Cork City in 2023, three years on from their own automatic relegation to the second tier.
In the wake of their win and promotion, UCD manager Willie O'Connor hit out at commentary from last week's RTÉ Soccer Podcast in regard to whether the university side's promotion would be good for the League of Ireland and whether a young crop could cope at the highest level over the course of a season.
Speaking to Extratime.com on Saturday, O'Connor said: "There were comments made about (the players) that they're just a bunch of lads that go out and play in the park from RTÉ pundits over the last few days. I think it's extremely, extremely harsh. The professionalism of these lads – these lads are training probably as much as anybody else.
"They're in five and six days a week, and how serious they take their football, how much they want to be footballers. I just thought a few of those comments were poor and uneducated. These boys are top professionals, and they want to go make a career in the game. The Premier Division now will aid that development even further."
On this week's RTÉ Soccer Podcast, former UCD and Shelbourne midfielder Alan Cawley addressed O'Connor's remarks and emphasised that the debate around the Students had never been about the players' professionalism nor their impressive on-field output.
Rather it was part of a wider question of where the league wants to head and how his former club fit into that within their current model, he said.
"That's totally fair. That is no problem. And he's entitled to say that and he's entitled to make those comments," Cawley said of O'Connor's response.
Listen to the RTÉ Soccer podcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever you get your podcasts.
"The one thing I did say last week about them was the fact that they were so well coached, well drilled, which is a credit to the manager, and we did say that.
"I know by looking at them. I know a team straight away, whether they're well coached or not well coached.
"And the football they play, that doesn't happen off the cuff. That's well drilled, well coached. And they stick by it.
"And as you said, the principles of play that they have in place there, Willie's obviously on the training ground with them three, four nights a week or whatever they do, and that's a credit to him.
"In terms of when I say 'a bunch of boys', it's a figure of speech in terms of that's all they are, they are a bunch of boys.
"But nobody was questioning their professionalism. Nobody was questioning anything to do with that. They're fit lads, they're young lads, you'd expect them to be fit.
"They have all the facilities, all the resources over in UCD. I know myself, I have a soft spot for UCD. I started my career at UCD. I've great time for them in everything that they offer. But it's a different UCD that's there now compared to (when) I played."
Cawley explained that the key issue he and others were highlighting was the continued development of the top flight across various metrics and UCD's place in that within as they are modelled now.
"I'm just talking about the bigger picture, separating it from all the praise we gave them in terms of the football side of things," he said.
"They're there on merit, absolutely nobody's disputing that and we've just given them all the praise and rightly so.
"I'm just saying in terms of the league is a bigger picture in what we're trying to enforce and build an industry and have stadiums and big huge fanbases and all that kind of stuff that will feed into the industry, I just don't know where their place is and I don't see it in the Premier Division.
"If someone from UCD can come over to me - the head people or whoever - and they can say to me, 'Yeah, our long-term plan is to do this and we want to be part of the Premier Division and we have aspirations to build this stadium and do that and have our lads as full-time footballers', I'm all ears. I will listen to that.
"But what I see right now at this moment, I don't see where they fit into the Premier Division in terms of what I feel the Premier Division should look like and where it's heading or where we want it to head.
"And finally, we have government on board and government funding in terms of academy structures.
"I know they have a very good academy actually over there in UCD. But just in terms of their place of what they're offering for an education and playing in the First Division, I can see that.
"I can't see them in the Premier Division. They're going to be there next year and we'll have the chats and we'll see if they can start getting a fanbase and people going in and do up the Belfield Bowl and do whatever they have to do and maybe improve things over there but I don't think they have aspirations to do that and that's my point on it in terms of the bigger picture for the league and I think that's a fair point and a fair assessment.
"I also have a lot of time for them, and I will praise them for the football absolutely and Willie O'Connor and the job that he's done, but I think that's a very fair assessment."
Watch Austria v Republic of Ireland in the UEFA Nations League on Saturday from 7pm on RTÉ2 and RTÉ Player. Follow our live blog on RTÉ.ie/sport and RTÉ News app and listen to live commentary on Saturday Sport on RTÉ Radio 1
We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences
内容来自 RTÉ - Sport,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗