“Reykjavík is becoming known as a prostitution hub”

In a detailed post on Facebook, Minister of Justice Þorbjörg Sigríður Gunnlaugsdóttir outlines the background and objectives of the bill targeting buyers of sexual services, which she introduced this week, while also examining the prostitution market in Iceland. mbl.is/Karítas

The aim of the Minister of Justice's new bill on prostitution is not to send buyers of sexual services to prison, as the minister envisages that such offenses would generally result in suspended prison sentences. Rather, the goal is to strengthen deterrence and reduce demand by making buyers' names public.

In a detailed article, Minister of Justice Þorbjörg Sigríður Gunnlaugsdóttir outlines the background and objectives of the bill targeting buyers of sexual services, which she introduced this week, while also discussing the prostitution market in Iceland.

Purchasing sexual services was criminalized in 2009, partly to reduce demand. However, she says those measures have not been sufficiently effective because prostitution cases have been handled as offenses punishable by fines.

"And now Reykjavík is becoming known as a prostitution hub."

Most enter prostitution because of desperate circumstances

The fundamental change proposed in the bill is that when police handle cases involving the purchase of sexual services, formal charges would be brought instead of allowing the case to be settled through payment of a fine.

"Hundreds of women are advertised for prostitution in Iceland, as revealed in an episode of Kveikur earlier this spring," Gunnlaugsdóttir says. "The program showed buyers of sexual services coming and going from accommodation in Reykjavík at all hours of the day and night."

During a major international police operation targeting human trafficking last year, 36 potential trafficking victims were identified.

"Almost all the victims were women. The vast majority were being sold for prostitution. Most were from Romania, but victims also came from Colombia, Paraguay, Malaysia, Britain, Portugal, China, Nigeria and Ghana."

Gunnlaugsdóttir writes that it is essential to acknowledge the reality that most women and girls involved in prostitution are there because desperate circumstances have driven them into it.

Classified as a sexual offense for a reason

Under current law, purchasing sexual services is punishable by a fine or imprisonment of up to one year. In practice, however, first offenses have been settled by paying a fine of ISK 200,000 to the police.

"That approach does not reflect the seriousness of prostitution. It means that no charges are brought and the accused never appears before a court. His name is not made public."

She also points out that offenses involving the purchase of sexual services fall under the sexual offenses chapter of the General Penal Code, and that this is no coincidence.

Organized crime

Gunnlaugsdóttir therefore argues that attention must be directed not only at those who organize and profit from prostitution, but also at those who sustain the market through demand.

"Where prostitution thrives, other criminal activity thrives as well. If we intend to make progress in combating organized crime, we cannot exclude this market. Purchasing sexual services is part of a broader reality in which human trafficking, exploitation and organized crime flourish because of the demand for prostitution," she writes.

She says the circumstances faced by many women and girls involved in prostitution are well documented, although this is, of course, not true in every case. It must therefore be possible to discuss the market in a broader context.

"A 2022 study by Stígamót found that prostitution is often a last resort for people in difficult social circumstances and that its effects on physical and mental well-being are serious, profound and long-lasting.

"Stígamót's experience also shows us that the boundaries between prostitution and human trafficking can be extremely blurred," Gunnlaugsdóttir writes. "What may initially appear to be a path toward financial independence can develop into a situation in which others exploit a person's vulnerability."

She says individuals may take advantage of those selling sexual services by offering security, accommodation and intermediary services, ultimately leaving the person without any control over their circumstances or independence.

"We simply know too much about the prostitution market to pretend that, in most cases, it is merely a matter of an individual's free choice."

“Purchasing sexual services was criminalized in 2009”

Gunnlaugsdóttir therefore proposes ending what she describes as special treatment for buyers of sexual services within the justice system, noting that defendants' names are generally made public in court proceedings unless anonymity is necessary to protect victims.

In cases involving the purchase of sexual services, she says there is usually nothing about the circumstances of those selling the services that would justify withholding the buyer's name.

"When purchasing sexual services was criminalized in 2009, the objectives included reducing demand and combating human trafficking. Those objectives have not been achieved because of the way these cases have been handled, with offenders simply paying fines," she writes.

"And now Reykjavík is becoming known as a prostitution hub."

Imprisonment is not the objective

The minister emphasizes that the aim is not to sentence buyers of sexual services to prison. She envisages that such offenses would generally result in suspended sentences.

The goal, she says, is simply to ensure that offenses of this nature are handled in a manner reflecting their seriousness.

"We must not lose sight of the objective of combating human trafficking and serious exploitation associated with prostitution," she concludes.

"It is therefore my political position that taking this step is both right and important. And I am proud of this bill."

内容来自 Mbl.is - News in English,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅