The People are sovereign, and they make the state

Pakistan’s political discourse increasingly promotes the idea that the state must always come before its people. However, the state is an institution created to protect citizens’ rights, ensure dignity and serve public interests, not an end in itself.

The state is only successful if its people prosper

A peculiar political philosophy has taken root in Pakistan’s public discourse, one that places the state above the very people whose collective existence gives it meaning. The assertion that the state must always come first is repeated with such conviction that questioning it can sometimes be interpreted as questioning patriotism itself. Yet, beneath its apparent simplicity lies a fundamental misunderstanding of political theory. The state is not an end in itself. It is a political institution created to serve human beings, protect their rights and provide the conditions in which they can live with dignity. To reverse this relationship is to confuse the instrument with the purpose for which it exists.

The state is a means, not an end. Its institutions, authority and sovereignty derive their ultimate justification from the people they are meant to protect. A country does not become stronger by placing its citizens beneath its institutions. It becomes stronger when those institutions work for its citizens. The people do not exist for the state. The state exists for the people

The foundations of modern political thought offer a compelling explanation of this relationship. John Locke, one of the most influential thinkers of liberal political philosophy, argued in his Second Treatise of Government that individuals establish political authority through consent to protect their natural rights. Government is a trust, not an absolute entitlement. Its legitimacy depends on fulfilling the responsibilities for which people consented to its creation. When authority ceases to protect those rights, it undermines the very justification for its existence. The implication is unmistakable. The state derives its legitimacy from the people and remains accountable to them.

Jean-Jacques Rousseau developed this argument further in The Social Contract, published in 1762. He located sovereignty in the collective body of citizens and maintained that legitimate political authority must reflect the general will. Although Rousseau’s conception of popular sovereignty differs from Locke’s emphasis on individual rights, both challenge the notion that political authority possesses an independent moral claim over society. The people are not the property of the state. They constitute the political community from which legitimate authority emerges.

The principle that people constitute the foundation of political authority is not confined to Western political philosophy. The Charter of Madinah, established by the Holy Prophet Muhammad (SAW), offers an important historical perspective on the formation of a political community through an agreed compact among its constituent groups. Rather than treating political order as an arrangement imposed upon society, it established a framework of shared obligations, collective responsibility and mutual protection.

Its significance for the present argument lies in the recognition that political authority and communal order derive their purpose from the people brought together under them. The political community was not created to serve an abstract institution but its organisation was intended to secure the welfare, rights and peaceful coexistence of those who constituted it.

Thomas Hobbes, whose political philosophy is often associated with an exceptionally powerful sovereign, also offers an interesting perspective. In Leviathan, published in 1651, he described the state as an artificial political person created through the authorisation of individuals seeking protection from insecurity and disorder. Hobbes favoured concentrated sovereign authority because he believed that security was essential to human survival. Yet the starting point of his argument was the vulnerability and needs of individuals, not the inherent superiority of an institution. The state was established because human beings needed it, not because human beings existed to serve it.

This distinction matters enormously in countries where the language of national interest is sometimes invoked to subordinate individual rights and democratic accountability. National security, territorial integrity, institutional continuity and constitutional order are undoubtedly essential. No functioning political community can survive without them. But these are not independent objectives detached from human welfare. Their ultimate purpose is to secure the lives, freedoms and collective well-being of citizens. Security without human dignity becomes an empty achievement, while sovereignty that does not translate into the protection of citizens loses much of its moral significance.

Abraham Lincoln’s celebrated formulation of democracy as government of the people, by the people and for the people captures this relationship with remarkable clarity. The state cannot claim democratic legitimacy merely because it possesses institutions, territory, administrative machinery or coercive authority. Its legitimacy also rests on how it treats those living under its jurisdiction. A country may maintain an impressive institutional structure and demonstrate considerable coercive capacity, yet fail its citizens through inadequate education, inaccessible healthcare, economic exclusion, injustice and the erosion of fundamental freedoms. Institutional survival alone cannot be equated with national success.

Pakistan needs to examine this distinction more seriously. The language of state survival and national interest frequently dominates public conversations, while the everyday experiences of citizens receive considerably less attention. Millions struggle with the cost of living, unemployment, inadequate public services, unequal opportunities and limited access to justice. For many, the state is encountered not as an institution of protection and opportunity but as a distant administrative authority, sometimes inaccessible and often unresponsive. The contradiction is difficult to ignore. If the state is strong, its strength should be reflected in the security, dignity and opportunities available to its people.

The Constitution of Pakistan itself provides a framework for understanding this responsibility. It guarantees fundamental rights, including security of person, dignity, equality before law and protection against discrimination. These guarantees are not decorative constitutional language. They define the obligations that give political authority its constitutional character. A state that demands loyalty must also demonstrate responsibility. Citizenship cannot be reduced to obedience, just as patriotism cannot be measured by an individual’s willingness to remain silent in the face of institutional failure.

None of this suggests that individual interests should always override collective responsibilities. Citizens have obligations towards their country, including respect for law, protection of public institutions and participation in the common good. But these obligations are reciprocal. The state also owes its citizens justice, security, equal treatment and the protection of their fundamental rights. A relationship built exclusively on demands from one side cannot sustain the trust upon which a legitimate political order depends.

Perhaps the most important distinction Pakistan needs to recover is between the state as an instrument of collective human welfare and the state as an unquestionable end in itself. The former is consistent with the social contract tradition and democratic constitutionalism. The latter risks turning political institutions into objects of unquestioning loyalty, irrespective of their performance or treatment of citizens. A state should not measure its success merely by its ability to command obedience or preserve its authority. It should be judged by the quality of life it enables its people to achieve.

The state is a means, not an end. Its institutions, authority and sovereignty derive their ultimate justification from the people they are meant to protect. A country does not become stronger by placing its citizens beneath its institutions. It becomes stronger when those institutions work for its citizens. The people do not exist for the state. The state exists for the people.

内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅