An obituary for MAGA@Trump

The MAGA movement, built around Donald Trump’s promise to Make America Great Again, focused on economic revival, trade reforms and an inward-looking national policy. However, the policies introduced under his presidency have produced counterproductive results.

Crash landing for MAGA?

MAGA stands for Make America Great Again; the slogan which was the Republicans war cry under the candidacy of Donald Trump for the presidency in the November 2024 elections. The broad parameters of the four-word abbreviation were spelt out by Trump in his inaugural presidential speech at the White House in January 2025. That definition included new steps aimed at economy, trade and a more inward-looking policy. However, what happened proved to be counterproductive. 

Elaborating further, ever since the US participation in two wars in Afghanistan in 2001 and in Iraq in 2003, the hit to the economy and to the public welfare character of the state was such that the Obama vote was more of withdrawing the US military muscle from around the world and spending the resulting saving for the welfare of the American public in the domains of health, education and a general conducive environment for business.

Going forward, the MAGA philosophy will have credibility issues not just in the near future, where every Trump Administration step will be under the combined Congress and Senate radar, but it is likely that aggressive military postures so far maintained might have to be toned down. It will only be the possibility of Trump using his discretionary presidential power rather than anything radical happening in the Hormuz theatre. It is possible that with a much weakened Trump, Iran actually might get a deal, which even Zarif might not have contemplated or which might well be the one Mujtaba Khomeini will not hesitate to endorse. The next few weeks will be decisive

The Obama years were characterized by less involvement in the military domain, but the USA did not completely abandon its dominant role. The colored revolutions option was however retained in the form of the Iran file, where the Bush military campaign option was dropped in favor of supporting the Green Movement in the 2009 elections in Iran.

The end of the Obama years and the return of the Republicans under the first tenure of Trump, too was punctuated with less US involvement outside and was more inward looking. The tenure between 2016 to 2020 was punctuated with mild policies aimed towards more inward-looking economic measures. Warring states in the domain of trade were not targeted full blown, but isolated sanctions were practiced; the episode of Huawei whose monopoly in providing Apple its key components was broken. The Biden years were uneventful from the standpoint of US involvement; when even in the case of the Gaza campaign the USA did not involve itself beyond a certain point, till that inaugural speech.

For any third-party observer; the incumbent President seemed to be well meaning for Americans; more inward looking in spending on the public as what a welfare state should be doing. However, what transpired proved to be counterproductive. The MAGA project rested on trade wars, covert wars and if possible, precision strikes to achieve the listed goals.

The inaugural speech opened trade fronts across the map. Canada; an erstwhile ally of the USA and CENTCOM was shown the door with a prohibitive tariff; making its practically difficult for the Canadian economy to sustain itself; keeping in view the fact that the USA and Canada have been for decades tied under a Customs Union; NAFTA which on the pattern of EU, ASEAN and similar customs unions allowed the Canadian brand names a sort of market access, which is the first step towards a sustained trade-based growth strategy of any economy. 

Next on the line of fire, the EU too received a rude shock in the form of a prohibitive tariff. The jolt was twofold on the count that the fate of NATO too was put under the microscope by Trump. If that was not enough the Greenland issue was propped up by him for no apparent reason.

 As of now the damage done to NAFTA has proven to be such that in recent months the EU has offered Canada to formally join the EU Customs Union. That joining practically can be the prelude to dismantling US-Canada military ties in future in favor of more integration with EU. Lately there can be halfhearted attempts by Wshington to win back Montreal.  

A similar strategy was adopted towards China in levying duties on its products. If these anti trade tariff and non-tariff barriers were not enough, despite the inaugural speech pledge to MAGA and looking inwards; the Trump administration actually fell into the lucrative geopolitical trap.

The Venezuela campaign went according to the plan. The aim was exploitation of the oil resources and a manageable political dispensation in that nation.  Practically it was a cost-effective operation; all the nodes compromised, few jets and few helicopters and the expenditure on jet fuel was all the expenditure ledger on that day apart from the behind-the-scenes CIA expenditure.

The Iran campaign too was designed on that count. Going by the fact that disgruntlement against the theocracy was at an all-time high, the fact highlighted in 12 days war in June 2025 and again proven in 40 days war, where the IDF jets knew precisely which street or boulevard to be hit.

With that much support for the regime change in Iran by the disgruntled elements, it was a foregone conclusion that once the supreme leader was blown to pieces, it would be an easy ride for the pro-US forces, or rather the political forces, to do the needful. However, what happened proved to be the contrary.

The USA and IDF. despite the on-ground support. could not precipitate the repeat of 19 August 1953. The wounded Nezam again stood on its feet and leveled up the ledger with the combined US and IDF assault until the reformists intervened to precipitate a ceasefire on the back of supposedly avoiding a ‘massacre’. 

For the USA apparently, it was a good decision that the Iranian onslaught stopped under the pretext of the ‘ceasefire’; but that ceasefire well into the summers and now autumn conveniently translated into the position of stalemate.  Stalemate and attrition in such conflicts means that the forces involved in mobilization continues to bleed economically, along with the uncertainty that the goal is still unfinished. 

That stalemate combined with the ongoing trade wars created a situation where the type of ‘conducive economic atmosphere’ preached by the USA to the rest of the world was simply not there. The fallout of the economy geared towards ill-planned military campaigns and equally reckless trade wars translated into a general alienation amongst the US public; the swing vote states and others for the Republicans led by the President.

The Vice-President was candid in his remarks that the Iran war created that political debacle. However, what he said was only part of the truth. The combined impact of a war, which negated the election pledge of looking inwards and prosperity; the naïve approach towards the trade war with the rest of the world literally acting on autistic impulses; and a complete failure to empathize with the ground realities all caused the debacle.

The Republicans in a minority in the Senate and Congress for the next two years might find a bumpy road for their version of MAGA.  With two years still of Trump’s tenure, with an unfinished war at the doorstep; about which the dominant thought in the corridors of power is that a precision strike will solve all the problems and even account for the other shortfalls in expectations, it is unlikely that any such solo move by Trump will not invite opposition from the Congress and the Senate. 

With the Supreme Court striking down many of the President’s directives, the change of power dynamics in the legislature is likely to make the MAGA philosophy crash land in the coming months. The dent to the system will be manifold; the opposition of the judiciary right from the onset; the stakeholders’ dissatisfaction and finally the same was translated in the form of reversal of the electoral fortunes of the Republicans.

Going forward, the MAGA philosophy will have credibility issues not just in the near future, where every Trump Administration step will be under the combined Congress and Senate radar, but it is likely that aggressive military postures so far maintained might have to be toned down. It will only be the possibility of Trump using his discretionary presidential power rather than anything radical happening in the Hormuz theatre. It is possible that with a much weakened Trump, Iran actually might get a deal, which even Zarif might not have contemplated or which might well be the one Mujtaba Khomeini will not hesitate to endorse. The next few weeks will be decisive. 

内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅