Imaan, Hadi challenge convictions in IHC, seek release on bail
ISLAMABAD: Human rights lawyer Imaan Zainab Mazari-Hazir and her husband, Hadi Ali Chattha, on Friday filed appeals in the Islamabad High Court (IHC) challenging their convictions by an anti-terrorism court (ATC) in the security breach case.
They also filed applications seeking suspension of their sentences and release on bail pending the hearing of their appeals.
The appeals were filed by advocates Faisal Siddiqui, Riasat Ali Azad and Zainab Janjua under Section 25 of the Anti-Terrorism Act (ATA), read with Section 410 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), against the trial court’s judgment.
On October 29, the ATC sentenced Imaan and Hadi to 10 years in prison each in the security breach case. The court also awarded them one-year sentences and imposed fines of Rs50,000 each under Section 186 of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC), which deals with obstructing a public servant in the discharge of public functions. They were further sentenced to two years each under Section 353 of the PPC for assault or criminal force to deter a public servant from performing official duties.
In identical appeals, their counsel argued that the trial court had failed to meet the requirements of a fair trial and that the convictions stemmed from proceedings that were patently illegal and arbitrary.
They contended that the charge had been framed without providing the appellants with copies of the relevant documents as required under Section 265-C of the CrPC. They also claimed that a plea of “not guilty” had been recorded on their behalf despite neither of them having entered such a plea.
The appeals further argued that prosecution evidence was recorded in the absence of the appellants and their counsel, in violation of Section 353 of the CrPC and Article 10-A of the Constitution.
The counsel also challenged the jail trial, describing it as akin to a secret trial conducted without lawful authority. They maintained that the appellants had not been allowed proper and confidential consultations with their lawyers.
According to the appeals, state counsel had been imposed on the appellants against their wishes, while the trial court continued proceedings despite a transfer application pending before the high court, allegedly in violation of Section 526(8) of the CrPC.
On the merits of the case, the appellants argued that their convictions under Section 7 of the ATA were unsustainable because the prosecution had failed to establish the design or purpose required under Section 6 of the law.
They pointed out that the trial court itself had described the incident as “a very common nature, ordinary type of incident”. The evidence, they argued, showed that the appellants were on their way to court when they were stopped at the barrier.
The appellants have asked the IHC to set aside the judgment and acquit them.
In their accompanying applications for suspension of sentences, the counsel sought their release on bail, arguing that the convictions had been handed down while a transfer application was pending. They also contended that the restriction under Section 25(8) of the ATA was not absolute when read with Section 25(5) of the law.
Rights groups call convictions misuse of criminal justice system
Separately, 23 international human rights organisations, including Amnesty International, on Friday called on the government to “immediately and unconditionally” release Imaan and Hadi.
In a joint statement, the organisations condemned the sentences and called for an end to what they described as the “extensive misuse” of the criminal justice system against the two lawyers.
The signatories included Alliance for Lawyers at Risk, Défense Sans Frontière, the New York City Bar Association, the Council of Bars and Law Societies of Europe, the Geneva Bar Association, Lawyers for Lawyers and PEN Norway.
The statement said the convictions raised serious concerns about the use of anti-terrorism legislation to “criminally punish and intimidate lawyers undertaking permissible human rights work”.
Referring to the proceedings, the organisations noted that the verdict had been delivered despite a petition pending before the Supreme Court. They said the circumstances raised concerns about respect for due process and the right to an effective judicial remedy.
They also questioned whether the trial, held at Adiala jail in Rawalpindi, had met fair trial standards.
According to the statement, the couple had been kept in a “cage-like” structure in the courtroom throughout the proceedings, preventing effective communication with their counsel. The organisations also said the lawyers had not been given sufficient access to the two accused.
“The prosecution relied primarily on police testimony to establish the offence, while the defence were denied adequate opportunity to reasonably challenge prosecutorial evidence,” the statement said.
It added that Imaan and Hadi had denied the charges and maintained that they were being targeted because of their professional work and activism.
The organisations expressed concern over what they described as the “misuse of overbroad anti-terrorism legislation” in a case involving the alleged removal of security barriers, questioning the proportionality of the charges.
They said anti-terrorism laws should not be applied “arbitrarily or disproportionately" or used to intimidate individuals or punish conduct and activities that did not meet the applicable legal threshold.
The statement placed the convictions in the context of what it described as “successive, politically motivated, criminal proceedings” against the couple, allegedly intended to punish them and deter them from continuing their peaceful human rights work.
The organisations also recalled the Supreme Court’s September 17 decision to suspend the couple’s 17-year sentences in a separate case involving social media posts, followed by their rearrest.
“The successive proceedings in the barrier removal case, and their prolonged deprivation of liberty despite the SC’s intervention, reinforce our concern that the criminal proceedings are calculated to make an example of the two lawyers and risk creating a chilling effect on the independence of the legal profession in Pakistan and on access to justice more broadly,” the statement said.
Citing Article 10-A of the Constitution, which guarantees the right to a fair trial and due process, as well as Pakistan’s obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), the organisations said anti-terrorism legislation must not be used to criminalise peaceful assembly, protected expression, freedom of association or permissible professional activity.
“The arrest, prosecution or prolonged detention of the lawyers because of their professional representation, human rights advocacy and exercise of their right to freedom of expression not only violates their personal human rights — it also sends a stark warning to other legal professionals and human rights defenders,” they said.
They warned that such actions could have a wider chilling effect on the legal profession and undermine lawyers’ ability to represent politically sensitive and human rights cases without fear of reprisal.
The 23 organisations urged the government and relevant authorities to release Imaan and Hadi immediately and unconditionally and take appropriate steps to have their convictions quashed.
They also called for an end to what they described as the misuse of the criminal justice system against the lawyers, and demanded that charges and cases arising solely from their human rights work and defence be dropped.
Furthermore, they urged the government to review the use of the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act and anti-terrorism legislation against lawyers, journalists, human rights defenders and peaceful critics, and to ensure compliance with Pakistan’s obligations under the ICCPR through domestic laws and their enforcement.
“Judicial remedies cannot be meaningful if a grant of liberty by one court is followed immediately by detention through another proceeding without sufficient credible evidence,” the statement said.
The organisations expressed solidarity with Imaan and Hadi, as well as with lawyers in Pakistan who continued to defend human rights and the rule of law despite the risk of reprisals.
“We call on the Pakistani authorities to respect their international obligations, uphold the independence of the legal profession and ensure that lawyers can exercise their profession and their human rights without intimidation, retaliation or improper interference,” the statement concluded.
内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗