Balochistan PAC Orders Recovery Over Rs12.11bn C&W Irregular Expenditure

The committee also ordered special audits of projects in Nasirabad, Noshki, Zhob and other districts, while seeking reports on Project Directors and directing recovery of disputed construction payments.

QUETTA, (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 6th Nov, 2026) The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) of the Balochistan Assembly on Friday expressed serious concern over more than Rs12.11 billion in irregular expenditure incurred by the Communication and Works (C&W) Department during the 2023-24 financial year and directed authorities to ensure full recovery of funds involved in audit objections and financial irregularities.

The meeting, chaired by PAC Chairman Asghar Ali Tareen in the new committee room of the Balochistan Provincial Assembly, reviewed audit reports relating to the Communication and Works Department. Committee members Wali Muhammad Noorzai, Rahmat Saleh Baloch, Zamrak Khan Achakzai, Fazal Qadir Mandokhail, Mir Muhammad Khan Lehri and Ghulam Dastagir Badini attended the session along with Director General Audit Shuja Ali, Additional Accountant General Balochistan Noor-ul-Haq, C&W Secretary Babar Khan and other senior officials.

During the meeting, the committee examined audit observations contained in the 2023-24 Audit Report, which revealed that the department had made irregular expenditures exceeding Rs12.11 billion during the fiscal year.

Chairman Asghar Tareen and committee members voiced strong concern over the scale of the irregular spending, stating that such a large amount incurred within a single financial year raised serious questions about the department’s financial management and performance.

The committee also reviewed an audit para highlighting alleged irregularities involving more than Rs130 million and directed the department to ensure 100 percent recovery of the amount.

The PAC further scrutinized the department’s financial performance during the 2022-23 fiscal year. According to the audit review, over Rs44.42 billion had been allocated to the department under development and non-development heads, of which more than Rs41.18 billion was spent.

However, the audit report noted that over Rs3.24 billion remained unutilized and subsequently lapsed. Committee members expressed concern over the lapse of significant public funds, emphasizing that unused allocations should be surrendered in a timely manner so that resources can be redirected to other priority development projects.

The committee also raised reservations regarding the system of appointing Project Directors (PDs) for development projects. Chairman Tareen stated that the committee was not convinced of the necessity of maintaining a parallel structure when the relevant departments already existed to implement projects.

The PAC directed authorities to submit detailed reports on all projects being executed under Project Directors. The chairman said the rationale behind appointing separate PDs and the necessity of creating additional administrative structures should be clearly justified.

Committee member Mir Muhammad Khan Lehri argued that projects initiated through the Planning and Development Department and the C&W Department should remain under the responsibility of the concerned departments rather than being handed over to separately appointed Project Directors. He observed that many incomplete projects are ultimately transferred back to the departments concerned, raising questions over the effectiveness of the existing system.

The committee ordered special audits of various projects in Nasirabad, Noshki, Zhob and other districts, including the Kachhi Plain Water Supply Scheme and the Balochistan Livelihoods and Entrepreneurship Project (BLEP).

PAC members noted that the appointment of Project Directors often leads to additional financial burdens on the public exchequer through the purchase of official vehicles, payment of high salaries and recruitment of extra staff. Concerns were also raised that some Project Directors are initially appointed without supporting staff and subsequently recruit personnel, resulting in avoidable expenditures.

The committee sought comprehensive details regarding these appointments and related expenses.

While reviewing the 2023-24 audit report, the committee discussed cases of financial irregularities and excess payments in various construction projects. Under Audit Para 4.2.1, auditors identified excess payments amounting to Rs90.34 million made to contractors in different building divisions during the 2021-22 and 2022-23 financial years due to payments above approved rates and errors in quantity calculations.

The audit report stated that recovery had been recommended and the relevant offices were instructed to present the required record, but progress had not been reported by the time the audit was finalized. Expressing strong concern, the committee directed the department to provide complete details, submit the relevant record and ensure full recovery of the losses caused to the public treasury.

The meeting also discussed audit objections related to construction projects in Sherani district and other areas where implementation of audit recommendations had remained pending.

Under Audit Para 4.2.2, auditors pointed out irregular payments of Rs40.41 million resulting from execution and payment of construction works exceeding the quantities approved in PC-I documents, estimates and contractual agreements. The committee instructed the relevant authorities to ensure 100 percent recovery within 10 days.

The PAC stressed that all government development projects must strictly comply with approved rates, quantities and contractual conditions, while transparency and complete financial records must be maintained for every payment made from the public ex of those cases was deferred. The committee decided to reconvene on November 30 to review the remaining audit observations.

内容来自 UrduPoint News,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅