Supreme Court Orders Full Trial In Inheritance Dispute Over 1931 Land Mutation

The court upheld the Peshawar High Court’s decision to remand the case, saying contested inheritance rights and evidence should not be decided at the preliminary stage, while noting limitation rules still apply.

ISLAMABAD, (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 6th Nov, 2026) The Supreme Court has ruled that an inheritance claim cannot be dismissed at the preliminary stage merely on the basis of a nearly century-old land mutation, observing that under Muslim Personal Law, inheritance rights devolve upon legal heirs immediately after the death of the predecessor.

The court held that failure by a heir to claim his or her inheritance share during their lifetime does not automatically extinguish the right, which may subsequently devolve upon their legal heirs.

A two-member bench comprising Justice Shahid Bilal Hassan and Justice Muhammad Shafi Siddiqui dismissed a petition challenging a Peshawar High Court judgment in a property inheritance dispute from Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.

According to the judgment, the plaintiffs had challenged Mutation No. 50 sanctioned on November 17, 1931, in favour of Mukhtaram Khan and Mst. Taja, seeking recognition of their inheritance rights in the disputed property.

The defendants argued that the mutation could not be challenged after such a long period.

The trial court had dismissed the suit on September 27, 2023, under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, a decision subsequently upheld by the appellate court.

However, the Peshawar High Court, through its judgment dated December 16, 2024, accepted the civil revision, set aside the lower courts' decisions and remanded the case to the trial court for adjudication after recording evidence from both sides.

Upholding the High Court's decision, the Supreme Court observed that objections raised in a defendant's written statement could not be treated as established facts merely because they had been pleaded.

It emphasised that where a dispute involves contested facts, inheritance rights or assessment of evidence, courts should exercise caution before dismissing a suit without a full trial.

The bench clarified that this did not mean every inheritance claim was exempt from the law of limitation or that old land mutations could never be challenged. The applicability of limitation would depend on the nature of the suit, relief sought, accrual of the cause of action and relevant legal provisions.

Referring to its earlier judgment in Faqir Ahmad Khan (deceased) through legal heirs v. Riaz Ahmad (2020 SCMR 346), the court reiterated that an inheritance right could pass to the legal heirs of a deceased heir.

The Supreme Court directed the trial court to provide both parties an opportunity to produce evidence and decide the case on its merits, preferably within six months in view of its age.

The parties were also directed to appear before the concerned district judge on November 16, 2026, without waiting for further notices.

内容来自 UrduPoint News,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅