A tale of two cities

The rulers of Washington and Tel Aviv are unchanged, but they are badly shaken

AT PENPOINT

Elections in wartime are not all that rare. So long as a country is able to organize them, they take place. Notable postponements were the UK in World War II, which went to the polls in 1945, after the war was won in Europe but before Japan, leading to Winston Churchill going to the Potsdam Conference of the Allies but being replaced during it by Clement Attlee; and Poland only last year, when the invasion of Ukraine by Russia was held reason enough to postpone the presidential election, and allow Volodymyr Zelensky to continue in office. The British election had been held after 10 years, the previous poll having been held in 1935. The elections which could not be held in a number of European countries during World War II is numerous.

The holding of an Israeli election was not problematic, even though the country was still at war with Iran, for no Israeli territory was occupied by Iran. The same applied, with even greater force, to the USA, which provided, during World War II, a clear example of not postponing elections.

However, though the conduct of the war was the main theme of both elections, in Israel, it also highlighted a problem that is an existential threat for Israel, and which will convert it into something so far from its concept of itself as to make it unrecognizable. The election resulted in an Arab list getting 19 seats in the 120-seat Knesset, while Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud-led bloc got 53 seats. His opponents, led by Gadi Eisenhot, a former chief of defence staff, got 49. The two Arab lists have won a total of 18 seats. That means they are essential to forming a majority. There is the option of Netanyahu and Eisenhot combining. It must be noted that even now some Arabs vote for Jewish parties, mostly for Eisenhot, for if all Arabs voted for the Aran lists, they would win 24 seats, or 20 percent of the Knesset.

In a way, the US and Israeli elections have delivered different results. While the USA saw an overwhelming defeat for the pro-war party, the Israeli government lost ground, but it was certainly not wiped out in the way the Republicans in the USA have been.

One problem that Israel’s leftist founders created for the future is that Israeli elections are held on the basis of proportional representation, with the entire country being one constituency. Thus gerrymandering is not possible. The situation will only worsen with time, as the higher Arab reproductive rate mean that the situation will grow worse for Jews.

Then there is the Greater Israel project, where the Occupied Territories, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip are absorbed.  Are the Palestinian residents to be given citizenship rights? It will mean the Israeli population goes from 10 million, of which 2.2 million are Arab, to 13.5 million, of which 5.7 million are Arab. If the Arabs vote together, they could get 50 or 51 seats in the Knesset. Jews could still form the government without Arab support, but it would mean sticking together, and depending on a narrow majority.

Both Trump and Netanyahu are stalwarts of their respective parties, but the elections have shown how they have driven their countries into the ground. Maybe the shrinking space around them will make them change course, but their track record says they will not. However, it may be that they will now realise that their policies are not just wrong and destructive, but lack support.

One way would be to introduce territorial constituencies, and then gerrymander with a vengeance. Another would be to introduce an oath of office that could not be taken by a non-Jew in good conscience. One can understand Netanyahu’s support for the idea of declaring Israel a Jewish state, but it will be no help unless the empty declaration is accompanied  by substantive legal provisions.

It should be noted that despite all Zionist efforts, the Jewish population of pre-Independence Palestine reached only 32 percent. The efforts of the Jewish Land Fund were even more dismal, with only seven or eight percent of the land owned by Jews. The Nakba, the Catastrophe, in which Palestinians were expelled forcibly and wholesale, was necessary if Israel was to be owned by Jews. the Palestinians had to be thrown out. The same position prevails now.

In this context, the Israeli insistence on the vacation of Gaza, and the attempt to kill off its people make sense. It is not only about creating room for settlements, but about denying Arabs the right to vote in Israeli elections.

It must be remembered that Palestinian refugees cannot claim Israeli citizenship. They do not have the Right of Return which has been given to Jews. They are stateless persons, even those who have been born in the refugee camps. However, a lot of the diaspora has obtained citizenship of the countries where they have settled, thus ensuring their ineligibility for Israeli citizenship and thus the right to vote in its elections. One of the phenomena noted in this election was the large number of Israelis who came from abroad to vote. None were Arab.

However, Netanyahu has alleged that the election was rigged, an allegation since rejected by the Electoral Committee after re-examining 79 oollng stations. He also is pushing the lie that the Arab parties received Qatari money, which was another way of saying the Muslim brotherhood, which was another way of saying Hamas. That seems to be a lesson he has learnt from his US mentor, Donald Trump, who seems to have a simple touchstone for judging the fairness of an election: if he wins, it is fair; if he loses, it is unfair.

Israel seems to have been caught in a bind. The one-state solution gives Palestinians a share in governance. Appearing strong, essential for any elected government, requires such suppression of Palestinians as to drive them to voting separately to voice their interests. This will oblige the Arabs to form a bloc 

It might be taken as a highlighting of the flaws of proportional representation, or even of democracy itself. This can also apply to the US midterms. Midterms have become a sort of referendum on the sitting President, in which case Trump has received as resounding a rebuff as is possible in the USA. More important. It reflects that he has possibly lost the control he once had over the Republican Party.

To a certain extent, he has already entered the lame-duck phase of any president (when his successor has been elected, but has yet to be inaugurated), for not only is he in the last two years of his tenure, but he now faces a hostile Congress. His ability to prosecute the war with Iran is greatly restricted, as he himself has publicly realized. He has no political incentive to launch an attack, though he retains a motive as President: the need to subdue Iran. However, it does not seem he has any way of doing this, except to hope that his sanctions work, even though they have not for some years.

Another factor is that Netanyahu is not out of the electoral game. He not only remains caretaker PM, he may get the hod permanently. There may be another election soon if a government cannot be formed, in which case he will be the standardbearer of the right.

Both Trump and Netanyahu are stalwarts of their respective parties, but the elections have shown how they have driven their countries into the ground. Maybe the shrinking space around them will make them change course, but their track record says they will not. However, it may be that they will now realise that their policies are not just wrong and destructive, but lack support.

内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅