Spent nearly 24 hours at Keflavík Airport, denied compensation
The man was ordered to remain in a designated area of the airport terminal and arrange a flight out of the country. mbl.is/Eggert Jóhannesson
Spent nearly 24 hours at Keflavík Airport but denied right to compensation
Reykjavík District Court has dismissed a claim against the Icelandic state by an Albanian national seeking recognition of his right to compensation following a decision to refuse him entry into the country and his nearly 24-hour stay at Keflavík Airport.
The court found that the police decision to refuse the man entry had not been in accordance with the law. However, it had not been demonstrated that the police had acted negligently or wrongfully in a manner giving rise to liability for damages. The court also rejected the claim that the man had been unlawfully deprived of his liberty within the meaning of the compensation provision of the Constitution.
The ruling was handed down on November 2. Each party was ordered to bear its own legal costs.
Purpose of visit deemed unclear
The man arrived on a flight from Italy on the morning of December 12, 2023. Police questioned him at the airport and concluded that he could not adequately explain the purpose of his visit to Iceland.
According to the police report, the man stated through an interpreter that he intended to explore Icelandic nature. He had booked accommodation and held a return flight ticket for four days later.
Police nevertheless considered that he had failed to provide sufficiently clear information about what he intended to do in Iceland or where he planned to go. The decision to refuse him entry also took into account the fact that his traveling companion had a criminal record in Iceland.
The man was instructed to remain in a designated area of the airport terminal and arrange a flight out of the country.
His lawyer requested that the case be reopened later that afternoon. Police granted the request and withdrew the refusal of entry the following morning. The man was then permitted to enter Iceland.
Court rejects claim that restrictions amounted to a travel ban
The man argued that he had been unlawfully deprived of his liberty and based his compensation claim partly on provisions of the Criminal Procedure Act and the Constitution. He also referred to the Tort Liability Act and general principles of liability for damages.
The court found that the evidence did not establish that the man had been arrested. Although he had been required to remain in a designated area of the airport terminal, he had been free to return to his home country.
The court found no basis for his claim that the measures amounted to a travel ban, noting that police had, on the contrary, instructed him to obtain a ticket to leave Iceland.
The police intervention had not been connected to a criminal investigation, and the man had not been treated as a criminal suspect. The compensation provisions of the Criminal Procedure Act therefore did not apply, nor was there justification for applying them by analogy.
Same answers assessed differently
In assessing the refusal of entry, the court noted that no new evidence or explanations appeared to have emerged before police reversed their decision.
The police commissioner had therefore interpreted the man's original answers differently and subsequently deemed them sufficient.
The court concluded that the initial decision had been based on an inadequate assessment of his answers and had not been in accordance with the law. However, the man had failed to present convincing arguments to support his allegations that police had violated various principles of administrative law.
The court found that the requirements for establishing fault had not been met. Among other things, determining whether a foreign national had sufficiently substantiated the stated purpose of a visit involved a considerable degree of judgment.
Furthermore, the police commissioner had responded promptly to the lawyer's request, reopened the case and withdrawn the refusal of entry.
Consequently, the conditions for recognizing liability for damages under the general fault-based liability principle had not been met, nor was the man entitled to non-pecuniary damages under the Tort Liability Act.
The Icelandic state was therefore cleared of liability.
内容来自 Mbl.is - News in English,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗