Pochettino takes control of a marooned, drifting tanker
People who pay casual attention to the Premier League are probably surprised to learn that Mauricio Pochettino hasn't managed Manchester United already. Surely he got a spin sometime between Jose Mourinho and Ruben Amorim, no?
Whenever a managerial vacancy arose at Old Trafford, his name was always among the first to be circulated, in the same way that Joe Kinnear's face used to appear in the papers whenever Ireland needed a manager.
He was in the frame to get the job way back in 2014 and then again in 2022 - but was twice passed over for Dutch coaches, one a venerable old-stager nearing the end of his managerial career, the other a youthful up and comer near the start of his career.
Neither of them worked. The first one was sacked despite winning the FA Cup, which many later came to view as a mistake. The second one managed to avoid the sack due to winning the Cup, which many immediately came to view as a mistake.
Now, for the want of any better ideas, the weary and shop-soiled executives at Old Trafford have finally gotten around to giving Pochettino the job.
The good news for the incoming manager is that expectations have surely been tempered already. Pochettino takes over a team sitting in 18th place with an easy run of fixtures already under their belt.
Their best player, the reigning Player of the Year, wears a perpetually pained expression and is permanently in a state of barking frustration with everyone around him. Their defence - as in the 4-4 draw with Aston Villa - sometimes calls to mind one-time RTÉ pundit Ossie Ardiles' brief reign as manager of Spurs.
In the medium term, Man United's best chance of adding another Premier League replica will be if trophies already handed out to others are formally reassigned.
In all likelihood, Alex Ferguson, aged as he is, probably has a stronger chance of winning another league title as Man United manager than Poch does of winning one.
Harking back to the Ferguson era feels a bit redundant at this point given so much has happened their ennobled great departed for the directors' box.
Since then, the United Kingdom has left the EU, Scotland just about stayed in the UK, Donald Trump ran for President, became President, lost the Presidency, refused to accept he lost the Presidency, won back the Presidency.
Fergie, meanwhile, has taught a module at Harvard Business School and toured the world with Jimmy Nesbitt by his side. He's survived and recovered from a brain haemorrhage which almost killed him.
Man United have had about 27 managers (and the fans' job was to stand by each and every one of them) and 21 interims in the mean-time.
All of which is to reiterate that it may be a bit much to still be banging on about him. He belongs to history now, like Matt Busby and Jock Stein and Napoleon Bonaparte.
But on another level, there's no getting away from him. They clearly haven't been right since he left.
Looking back through the long lens of history, the striking thing is how quickly they stopped being right after he'd gone. More or less instantly, in fact.
His departure for the soft seats in the directors' box didn't so much represent a change of figurehead as a full-on lobotomy.
Evidently, the club's entire accumulated institutional knowledge was contained within Fergie's ears and left Carrington when he did.
Ferguson was at Old Trafford such an abnormally long time that the club's entire identity became bound up with him.
They're completely rudderless and adrift without him there, overseeing and scrutinising every inch of the place. His very omnipotence and sense of authoritarian control left them even more vulnerable when he was gone.
The defining image of Manchester United in their imperial phase was that of Ferguson surveying his team from Old Trafford's magnificent raised dugout.
These days, the club's identity is more associated with Mark Goldbridge going nuts on his live-stream, reacting to every goal concession like Basil Fawlty when his car failed to start.
Perhaps it's the way with empires that when they collapse, they do so spectacularly.
Certainly, the sense of panic that is engendered by downward mobility does not appear to promote sound decision-making.
We've seen this at Manchester United in the post-Fergie era. We saw it at Liverpool in the early 1990s.
Arguably, the most disastrous example was at Rangers when, in the aftermath of their monopolisation of the Scottish league in the 1990s, they responded to Martin O'Neill's early success at Celtic by promising to spend a tenner for every fiver their hated neighbours forked out. Thereby, setting in train a process which eventually bankrupted them.
Both Solskjaer and Carrick had their best periods as manager when they were still 'interims', when their chief attribute was that they were not their immediate predecessor. As soon as the interim prefix was discarded and they officially joined the ranks of Fergie's successors, things started to go to pot.
Though to be fair, Solskjaer did oversee a fairly decent 2020-21 season, where they finished distant runners-up before the shallow and dysfunctional hierarchy decided to foist Ronaldo on him, a classic bit of nostalgia-ridden unseriousness that has typified the post-Fergie United.
This sort of brainless sentimentality that has typified Man United since Fergie left is at odds with the great man's own brutal lack of sentimentality while he was micro-managing every aspect of the club.
Solskjaer and Carrick are the only of Ferguson's ex-players to have had a go at replacing him - Ryan Giggs, Ruud Van Nistelrooy and Darren Fletcher have all served very short spells as caretaker managers, usually near the end of a season when a manager has been bumped off.
Most of the luminaries of Man United's gilded age seem much happier on the podcast circuit. There's relatively easy money to be made with none of the stress and headaches associated with management.
Most of the Class of '92 have their internet soap-boxes to expound angrily on the current game and reminisce fondly about the old days. Wayne Rooney and Rio Ferdinand both have their platforms.
Roy Keane has obviously decided that earning a fortune for nibbling a few croissants and arguing with his mate Wrighty on camera is far preferable to trying to get a tune out of a load of Gen Z tw**s that he can't stand.
We have ample evidence that Keano's tough love - 'tough hatred' might be more accurate - managerial philosophy goes down as well with the modern player as Brenda Power columns do on BlueSky.
His fondness for the savagely withering put-down was very much at odds with sports psychology best practice but he couldn't help himself all the same. This predilection works far better in podcast live-shows than it did in dressing rooms.
Frank Lampard aside, a lot of the heavy hitters from English football in the 90s and 2000s are participating in the podcast bubble and left the managerial paddock free for Spaniards with beards and Germans with economics degrees. The latter are all hungry to make their name in the game whereas the former find it far too easy to monetise their existing name.
Maybe, looking back, the real downside of Fergie's trophy-laden epoch is that it left Manchester United hopelessly in thrall to the cult of the manager in its 20th century incarnation, just at the moment when football at the highest level was evolving in another direction.
The supposed brains trust that sits high above the dugout in the South Stand, their mouths hidden under zipped up coats, have now been pegged as the real culprits, alongside the hated Glazers.
Instead of directing club operations in a coherent fashion, they seem to be permanently reacting to events. They are permanently appointing coaches whose ideas are hopelessly ill-suited to the crop of players their predecessor has lumbered them with. The sense of continuity and sure-footedness that characterised the club in the Ferguson era is a sadly distant memory.
Pochettino is the latest daring volunteer to plunge himself into this morass. The glory that will come his way if he can turn the tanker around will be unbounded. But it looks like a multi-year project and all recent history suggests the odds are heavily stacked against him.
内容来自 RTE,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗