Two summits with different implications for Ukraine war

Two summits last Thursday - one in China, the other in Germany - had very different implications for the war in Ukraine.

In Shenzhen, the leaders of China, Russia and the United States were meeting on the sidelines of the APEC summit, an annual economic gathering of Asia-Pacific countries.

Some in Europe were concerned that the meeting between Xi Jinping, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin could form the basis of a Yalta-style agreement to end the war in Ukraine without either Ukrainian or European involvement.

In February 1945, then US president Franklin D Roosevelt, USSR leader Joseph Stalin and UK prime minister Winston Churchill Churchill met for a summit in Yalta in Crimea and agreed upon Western and Soviet spheres of influence in Europe.

For many in Poland and elsewhere in Central and Eastern Europe, the very mention of "Yalta" carries feelings of betrayal as a result.

But Shenzhen did not deliver another Yalta.

For starters, the meeting was over after 90 minutes, while the 1945 conference lasted eight days.

Russian President Vladimir Putin, China's President Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump arrive for a trilateral meeting
The three leaders agreed to work towards reforming the United Nations

There was no far-reaching agreement between Mr Trump, Mr Xi and Mr Putin on how to end the war in Ukraine or on redefining their countries' spheres of influence.

During their meeting, the three leaders did discuss the war in Ukraine, but a short declaration issued by the three leaders afterwards did not mention Ukraine at all.

Instead, the three leaders agreed to work towards reforming the United Nations, they told the International Criminal Court to back off and, in the same week as a COP summit was taking place, agreed to increase the production and supply of petroleum.

They also agreed to reduce the risk of nuclear armed conflict.

Two of those four points - rebuking the ICC and the shared commitment to increase oil production - will, however, affect Ukraine.

Russia’s leader is wanted on an international arrest warrant by the ICC for his alleged responsibility in the deportation of thousands of Ukrainian children to Russia.

Neither the US, China nor Russia are members of the ICC.

But Mr Putin has now put pen to paper with the leaders of the world’s two largest economies to argue that immunity for state officials is of "paramount importance" and that the ICC and other similar bodies "must not abuse their jurisdiction".

It read like a warning to the ICC to drop its case against Russia’s president and suggests that the US, at least until the end of the Mr Trump's presidency, will not champion the charges against Mr Putin.

Trump Xi and Putin meet at Apec summit
Almost five years after ordering the full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Mr Putin is no longer isolated

As for plans to increase Russian oil exports, that will only help to swell the Kremlin’s coffers and enable Russia to prolong its war.

But worst of all for Ukraine was simply the sight of Russia’s leader sharing the stage with the US and Chinese presidents and being treated as their diplomatic equal.

Almost five years after ordering the full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Mr Putin is no longer isolated and the US government has invited him to attend a G20 summit in Florida next month.

Even if he does not attend, Russia’s foreign ministry has confirmed that it will send a delegation to Florida, meaning the return of senior Russia officials at a high-level Western summit.

For Ukrainians, seeing Mr Trump greet Mr Putin on Thursday as his "friend" added insult to injury.

Mr Trump’s friendliness towards the Russian leader offered confirmation that his administration is now more unlikely than ever to increase economic pressure on Moscow to end its war.

The easing of US sanctions on Russian diesel exports last month said as much.


Watch: 'Who is he? He's my friend' - Trump on Putin


Just hours after Mr Trump had called Mr Putin his friend on Thursday, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky was meeting European leaders in Berlin for the latest Coalition of the Willing meeting.

The group of 36 mostly European countries, which includes Ireland, was set up early last year to coordinate support for Ukraine after it became clear that the Trump administration was going to reduce its support for Kyiv.

The coalition has become Europe’s main vehicle to ensure that Ukraine and the continent has a voice at any eventual peace negotiations to end the war.

Since the start of this Trump administration, Ukraine’s true friends have proved time and time again to be the Europeans, plus the Canadians.

Ukraine, US envoys and European leaders meet in Berlin
The Coalition of the Willing called for a ceasefire on energy infrastructure during the winter

European military, financial and humanitarian aid continues to keep Ukraine solvent and in the fight.

European diplomacy has made sure that Ukraine is not excluded from any deal to end the war.

In Berlin, leaders reaffirmed their demand for Europe to have a seat at peace talks and reiterated the need for Ukraine to be given robust security guarantees as part of any peace agreement.

The coalition also called for a ceasefire on energy infrastructure during the winter, an idea that Russia has rejected in the past and is likely to reject again.

Significantly for Ukraine, there were financial commitments from its partners too.

NATO member states committed to deliver €70 billion in military aid to Kyiv by the end of this year and the same amount next year.

The Berlin meeting came one day after the European Commission had proposed an additional €45bn in financial aid for Ukraine for 2027, on top of the existing €90bn support loan for 2026 and 2027 to cover Kyiv’s gaping budget deficit.

The coalition also said that any "agreements on wider European security issues" would not be possible while Russia continues its war against Ukraine.

steve witkoff and jared kushner pictured in Kyiv, Ukraine
US special envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner attended the coalition summit

German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said that a Yalta-style agreement would "not bring about peace" in a clear reference to the summit in Shenzhen.

US special envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner attended the coalition summit and that shows again that the US wants Europe to be involved in eventual peace negotiations to end the war.

After Thursday's trilateral summit in Shenzhen had ended, Russia's president defended the Yalta agreement, saying the February 1945 meeting did not divide the world into "spheres of influence".

Few Western historians would agree with that assessment.

"Yalta simply acknowledged the realities that had emerged in the wake of the Second World War," Mr Putin told reporters at a press conference.

He also said that "when it comes to today's conflicts, the realities on the ground will have to be accepted".

In effect, he was calling for Russia's occupation of one-fifth of Ukraine to be recognised.

Europe is getting closer to the negotiating table and that is good news for Ukraine and the future security of the continent.

But this week showed that Russia's president would still like to negotiate high stakes geopolitics the old way, between the leaders of other big countries and without the involvement of smaller ones whose fate will be decided by such decisions.

内容来自 RTE,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

用 HomepageTab 新标签页关注 RSS,打开浏览器就能看到更新。

安装 HomepageTab