Spy and sell: The murky history of economic espionage

The allegation that former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang was in a romantic relationship with a suspected Chinese spy is undoubtedly sensational. And potentially industry-shifting.

But as incredible as the story of Alice Huang may be, it's just the latest in a long line of cases, claims and accusations around China’s economic spying programme.

Central to this is a belief that China has been systematically gathering information on companies, technologies and entire industries as part of the country’s broader attempt to become the world’s economic powerhouse.

Because, while we tend to think of espionage as being about state secrets, political influence and military intelligence, it can also be about finding ways to gain an economic advantage on other countries.

That often takes the form of trying to access research or proprietary technologies - something that’s seen as particularly attractive to China as it tries to leapfrog the likes of the US in cutting-edge areas like technology and pharmaceuticals.

Though it should be said that European companies have also claimed to be the subject of Chinese spies - Germany has previously claimed to be losing tens of billions of euro and tens of thousands of jobs a year to economic espionage, with China the main culprit.

Spy hard

The ways in which China has been accused of spying on companies and industries have ranged from honeypot or honey trap schemes, to hacking and social engineering, to having agents get jobs in cutting edge companies.

China is also seen to use academic or business partnerships to gain access to sensitive company information.

Under Chinese rules, most American or European businesses that want to establish operations in China need to set up a joint venture with a local company and, as part of that, are required to share information and technology.

This is seen as one of the ways that China has been able to become a leader in the motor industry in a relatively short period of time.

The fact that the rest of the world now buys so much technology from China is also seen as another area ripe for exploitation.

In recent years, there have been particular concerns around the use of Chinese-made networking equipment in Europe’s critical infrastructure, and claims these devices offer a backdoor to China’s security and intelligence services.

The European Union has designated Chinese brands like Huawei and ZTE as 'high-risk’ suppliers - with some attempts being made to outright ban their devices in Europe’s telecoms network.

It should be said that China and Chinese companies, like Huawei, have routinely denied being involved with facilitated espionage of any kind - economic or otherwise.

Sunrise, sunset

Cases of Chinese economic espionage have gone beyond accusation.

At the start of this year, Linwei Ding was convicted of economic espionage and seven counts of theft of state secrets in the US. This related to thousands of pages of information he stole from Google relating to its artificial intelligence technology.

The court found that while Ding had worked for Google from 2019 to late 2023, for most of that time he also secretly held a position as an executive at a Chinese tech company - as well as leading his own AI-related start-up.

He was found to have covertly uploaded more than 2,000 pages of proprietary Google data to a personal cloud account for the benefit of these firms.

He finished up at Google on 26 December 2023 and booked a one-way flight to Beijing - but he was arrested before he left the US.

The economic espionage conviction was recently overturned, though, due to a lack of evidence that the data he took was used to benefit China. The charges relating to the theft of trade secrets were upheld.

Meanwhile, back in 2023 a man called Zheng Xiaoquing was convicted of conspiring to steal trade secrets from General Electric for the benefit of the Chinese government.

He was alleged to have hidden confidential files relating to the design and manufacture of turbines as binary code within seemingly innocuous photos of things like sunsets.

More honey, more problems

Jensen Huang with Alice Huang alleged spy
Jensen Huang with alleged spy Alice Huang

The honey-pot element of the Jensen Huang allegations has made this story particularly eye-catching - but it’s arguably also made it all the more surprising.

Because the honey-pot scheme is one of the oldest espionage techniques there is.

The term ‘honey trap’ was first coined by John Le Carré in ‘Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy’ in 1974, but it referred to a practice that was already thousands of years old at that stage.

You could argue that the story of Samson and Delilah, which is more than 3,000 years old, is essentially a story of a honey-pot - and it’s probably not even the oldest example.

(Generally, the term is used to refer to people who pursue romantic or sexual relationships as a way of gaining information or leverage - though it is worth noting that, in the tech world, a honey-pot can also be a decoy system set up to identify spammers and hackers.)

But what makes the Jensen Huang allegation so intriguing is the fact that the US tech sector in particular seems to be extremely paranoid about its executives' falling victim to the romantic kind of honey-trap.

There’s acute awareness of the amount of espionage that takes place in Silicon Valley - as well as the popularity of that particular technique - and as a result staff are routinely told to be conscious of the threat when pursuing personal relationships.

OpenAI apparently has run training sessions specifically focused on the risk of honey-pots as part of its attempt to prepare senior staff for the time that they become targets.

There are numerous private security and intelligence firms that Silicon Valley companies could employ to investigate the personal relationships of key staff and identify potential risks to the business.

Questions will now be asked as to whether Nvidia made similar attempts to interrogate or vet its CEO's relationships.

Trouble brewing

Black and white image of Robert Fortune
Robert Fortune was sent on a spy mission to China on behalf of the British empire in around 1850

Of course, China has been the victim of state-sponsored economic espionage too. In fact, one of the most significant cases is seen as a textbook example of the practice.

The story relates to Robert Fortune, a Scottish botanist who - in around 1850 - was sent on a spy mission to China on behalf of the British empire.

At the time, China had a global monopoly on tea - which Britain had a huge appetite for.

And while Britain had, for a time, imported the product in return for opium, a crackdown on that by Chinese authorities - and the resulting Opium Wars - made the empire realise just how beholden it was to China.

Which it didn’t like.

So Robert Fortune was sent to China to detail the process for growing, harvesting and producing tea - and often times disguised himself as a Chinese merchant in order to go undetected.

He was also tasked with smuggling high-quality seeds out of China.

That seed, along with some skilled workers and the knowledge he’d stolen, was then sent to India, which quickly developed itself as a major producer of tea. In fact, by the time Fortune died in 1880 India was a bigger exporter of tea than China.

It’s hard to understate the impact this bit of spy-craft had on global trade at the time - and the knock-on effects it had on China’s economic advancement. Something that was felt for many decades after the deed.

Needless to say, there are plenty of more modern examples of China allegedly falling victim to state-backed espionage.

There have been multiple arrests made in recent years of what the country claimed were US and UK spies. Though, much like with China itself, these claims are routinely denied by the countries in question.

Opponents often suggest that China’s espionage claims tend to be used as cover for political suppression.

Spy for a spy

Image showing the Bull logo on a microchip of a circuit board

Though it should not be a surprise that China would be both victim and perpetrator in the world of economic espionage. Because it seems to be a common tactic for many countries.

Just a few weeks ago we saw a case in the US where a Saudi national was charged over the alleged planting of a recording device in one of OpenAI’s offices in California.

And it’s not as though economic espionage is done solely between countries hostile to one another.

In the 1990s it was alleged that France’s Generate Directorate of External Security ran a spying operation on high-tech companies in the US - targeting the likes of IBM and Texas Instruments.

The claim was that it sought to gain access to those firms’ technical knowledge, which it would then pass on to Groupe Bull, a state-owned computer company that would have been a competitor at the time.

Even Air France was pulled into the controversy - as it was forced to deny claims that it employed spies and planted bugs in its seats in order to help with the data-gathering effort.

Separately, one of the revelations that came from Edward Snowden was the accusation that the US was spying on German and French businesses and their executives.

That’s because, after 9/11, the US and Europe agreed to a system where the US security services would tell European countries which people they wanted to put under surveillance, and those countries would essentially spy on those people on behalf of the US.

But it turned out that, within the hundreds of thousands of names sent to Germany’s Federal Intelligence Service, there included senior figures in the likes of Airbus and other major European industrial players.

Essentially German authorities had opened the door to allow the US to conduct economic espionage on its own businesses.

Spy business

Economic espionage is not confined to nation states, either. There have been plenty of companies willing to play dirty to gain an edge on their competitors - or at the very least to undermine them.

The López Affair relates to an accusation by car-maker Opel in the 1990s that Volkswagen had stolen some confidential information from it and its parent company General Motors.

This was said to be done via the recruitment of a number of senior Opel executives, including GM’s vice president of global purchasing, José Ignacio López.

Volkswagen never admitted fault and a criminal charge was dropped following a settlement between the two companies, which involved Volkswagen paying GM $100m in cash, and agreeing to purchase $1bn worth of parts over the following years.

In the early 2000s, intelligence contractors working on behalf of P&G did a bit of dumpster diving in order to gather strategic information about the haircare business of rival Unilever.

In fairness, this didn’t seem to be sanctioned by the company’s top brass. When it was discovered, P&G reported the case directly to Unilever and paid a reported £10m to settle the case.

A few years ago it emerged that - in around 2015 - Amazon ran a programme called the Big River Project where it set up a shell company in order to sell products on rival ecommerce platforms like Walmart and eBay. It did this to gain more information on how they priced items, how products were listed and payments were handled, which would help it gain an edge on its main rivals.

More recently, we’ve seen Google’s self-driving subsidiary Waymo accusing Uber of stealing trade secrets. Uber has also been accused of hiring ex-CIA agents in order to spy on rivals.

Even more recently, and closer to home, there is an ongoing case of alleged economic espionage with an Irish connection - which involved US payroll and HR company, Deel.

Its rival Rippling alleges that it tasked a worker in its Dublin office with gathering information like customer lists and pricing details, which were then fed back to Deel.

The claim is that Rippling identified the leak through a honeypot of its own - though this was a Slack channel rather than a romantic interest.

Deel has denied the accusations, has accused Rippling of engaging in a smear campaign, and of itself stealing information.

内容来自 RTE,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

用 HomepageTab 新标签页关注 RSS,打开浏览器就能看到更新。

安装 HomepageTab