Scotstown reach Ulster final after controversial finish
Scotstown reach Ulster final after penalties following controversial extra-time finish
Updated / Saturday, 21 Nov 2026 22:50
Scotstown (Monaghan) 1-24 St Eunan's (Donegal) 0-27 (AET)
* Scotstown win 4-2 on penalties
Conor McCarthy clinched an Ulster Club SFC final spot for holders Scotstown as his clinically struck penalty secured a 4-2 shoot-out win against St Eunan's in a magnificent battle at Brewster Park.
But there was huge controversy over Scotstown’s levelling point from Kieran Hughes to draw matters at the end of extra-time, with replays suggesting the ball had tailed right and wide.
Rory Beggan, Darren Hughes and Shane Carey were the other penalty scorers for the winners, who beat Newbridge on penalties at the same stage last year, while Niall O’Donnell and Dylan Doogan netted for Eunan’s.
Kieran Donnelly and his St Eunan's players will be angered it got that far though following that Hughes free, but referee Kieran Eannetta gave the point after the umpires made no signal.
The sides were level at the end of normal time after Oran Winston landed a two-pointer to tie matters on a score of Scotstown 1-18 St Eunan’s 0-21.
What a finish! Oran Winston with a two-pointer for St Eunan's to force extra-time. A fourth Ulster game in a row for Scotstown that has required an additional 20 minutes after Newbridge and Kilcoo last season and Magherafelt and St Eunan's this season. 📺RTÉ2 💻 RTÉ Player https://t.co/vN30W9LpCI
— The Sunday Game (@TheSundayGame) November 21, 2026
Scotstown had the wind for the first 10 minutes in a frenetic extra-time and led by 1-21 to 0-22 at the break thanks to points from Carey, Ryan O’Toole and Nicky Sherlock with Niall O’Donnell replying with a free for Eunan’s.
But there was even more drama in the second period.
Conor O’Donnell Snr and Kieran Hughes swapped points before Niall O’Donnell and a two-pointer from dual player Brian MacIntyre put Eunan’s into a 0-27 to 1-23 lead before that controversial finish.
Before all that extra-time drama, a scintillating scoring burst in the run up to half-time, in which they hit 0-06 in four minutes, pushed Scotstown towards yet another Ulster final appearance in Brewster Park.
St Eunan’s had the brighter start as Conor O’Donnell Jnr swept over a fine point after four minutes.
Eunan’s were in the ascendancy, and Eoin McGeehin doubled their lead in the sixth minute before Winston tagged on another.
Scotstown were struggling to get their hand on the ball but Monaghan star McCarthy hoofed over a fine two-pointer to leave just a point between the teams.
Controversy at the very end of the match. End result? We're off the penalties. 📺 RTÉ2 💻 https://t.co/ZfZ9mA9XTY https://t.co/GDModEO4vh
— The Sunday Game (@TheSundayGame) November 21, 2026
Eunan’s had plenty of prime possession but were finding it hard to break down the Scotstown defence before McGeehin punched a point from an acute angle.
Mattie Maguire replied with a point for Scotstown, who were growing into the game, and Carey levelled matters from a free in the 21st minute to leave it 0-04 to 0-04.
The Tir Chonaill champions hit a purple patch and went into a three-point lead as half-time beckoned, goalkeeper Shaun Patton coming forward to raise an orange flag with a fine free from the edge of the arc.
Following that, a poor Scotstown kick-out was punished when McGeehin pushed Eunan’s into a 0-07 to 0-04 lead.
But they also hit five wides and were hit with Scotstown's scoring blitz just before the interval.
Mattie Maguire had a great chance of a goal for the Monaghan kingpins, but his rocket just shaved the outside of Patton's post and went wide.
McCarthy did point a free before Donnacha Connolly added a snappy point.
Just as they did in last year's Ulster semi-final, Scotstown have won a penalty shoot-out 4-2 to advance to the provincial final. https://t.co/PiuZAR32an
— The Sunday Game (@TheSundayGame) November 21, 2026
Then came two great two-pointers, Tommy Mallen with the first before Rory Beggan landed an incredible effort - out of his hands - from a free 60 metres from goal.
Mattie Maguire stretched the lead on the resumption and McCarthy put them five ahead, 0-12 to 0-07.
The excellent Shane O’Donnell replied with a fine two-pointer and Conor O’Donnell Jnr made it a three-point game.
Francis Maguire responded at the other end, but two points on the spin from Niall O’Donnell left just two points between the sides after 42 minutes.
It was a real slugfest as Sherlock and McCarthy pushed Scotstown into a 0-16 to 0-12 lead.
But the Letterkenny outfit were not going away, and Niall O’Donnell hit a fine left-footed point with the help of the breeze.
"The man doesn't miss and he has the worst technique for a penalty." Rory Beggan spoke to RTÉ Sport after their Ulster semi-final penalty shoot-out win over St Eunan's. https://t.co/BtKY5KZjgs
— The Sunday Game (@TheSundayGame) November 21, 2026
Sherlock had a goal chance but took his point as Shane O’Donnell hit another two-pointer at the other end to leave just a point between the sides.
Luke McGuinness tied matters as the momentum seemed to have shifted to St Eunan’s.
However, Scotstown seemed to strike a hammer blow when corner-back Darragh Murray finished a fine move to the net in the 55th minute.
St Eunan’s refused to die and Conor O’Donnell Snr converted a soft free before Scotstown sub Max Maguire hit a fine effort from play.
Ciarán Moore had a half chance of a goal and scrambled a point before Winston tied matters with a soaring two pointer in the 64th minute to take this epic affair to extra-time.
From there the drama kept coming but in the end, Scotstown are back in another final.
Scotstown: Rory Beggan (0-02, 1tpf); Mark McCaffrey, Ryan O’Toole (0-01), Darragh Murray (1-00); Donnacha Connolly (0-01), Damien McArdle, Conor McCarthy (0-04, 1tp); Micheal McArdle, Darren Hughes; Gavin McPhillips, Shane Carey (0-04, 0-04fs), Francis Maguire (0-01); Tommy Mallen (0-04,1tp), Nicky Sherlock (0-02), Mattie Maguire (0-02).
Subs: Max Maguire (0-01) for Francis Maguire (47), Kieran Hughes (0-02, 0-01f) for Gavin McPhillips (52), James Hamill for Donnacha Connolly (62), Sean Óg McElwain for Mattie Maguire (64), Mark McPhillips for Nicky Sherlock (71).
St Eunan’s: Shaun Patton (0-02, 1tpf); Noah Barrett, Caolan Ward, Josh Hay; Kieran Tobin, Conor O’Donnell snr (0-01), Oran Winston (0-03,1tp); James Kelly, Eoin Dowling (0-02, 1tp); Ciarán Moore (0-01), Shane O’Donnell (0-05, 2tps), Luke McGuinness (0-01); Eoin McGeehin (0-03), Niall O’Donnell (0-04, 1tp), Conor O’Donnell jnr (0-03, 0-03fs).
Subs: Brian MacIntyre (0-02, 1tp) for Josh Hay (72), Evan Daly for Noah Barrett (75), Pauric McGettigan for Conor O’Donnell jnr (75).
Referee: Kieran Eannetta (Tyrone).
More stories on
内容来自 RTÉ - Sport,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗