Export financing risks failure

Pakistan's latest attempt to expand its export base through subsidised long-term financing risks repeating the failures of earlier export promotion schemes unless the government ensures that businesses receiving cheap credit become permanent exporters rather than merely recipients of subsidised machinery, a new analysis has warned. In a pointed assessment of the government's new Long-Term Export Growth Financing Facility, Professor of Economics and Registrar at the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE) Dr Nasir Iqbal argues that Pakistan has become adept at helping businesses enter export markets but has repeatedly failed to ensure they remain there once government incentives disappear. The challenge, he says, is not simply to make financing cheaper or relax eligibility conditions, but to create productive businesses capable of winning repeat orders, improving export prices and sustaining their presence in international markets. The issue has gained urgency following the Economic Coordination Committee's (ECC) November 20 decision to reduce the minimum export requirement under the EXIM Bank-administered facility from 80% to 50% of sales within four years. In his research titled "Can Pakistan Finance Its Next Exporters?", released on Saturday, the economist highlights a striking mismatch in the original policy design: the average listed Pakistani exporter earns only Rs27 out of every Rs100 in sales from abroad, yet the new facility initially required businesses to generate 80% of their sales through exports. The relaxation is therefore a welcome move towards bringing potential exporters into the financing framework. However, Iqbal argues that lowering the threshold addresses only the question of who can enter the scheme, leaving unanswered the more important questions of who will remain an exporter and who will be held responsible for the results. A costly bet on export growth The financial commitment makes the effectiveness of the programme particularly important. The government expects to provide Rs350 billion in financing and absorb approximately Rs196 billion in interest costs over 10 years, including Rs25 billion during the current fiscal year. Borrowers will pay 2% interest for the first two years, followed by a fixed rate of 5% for the remaining eight years. Iqbal calculates that the arrangement amounts to approximately Rs56 in public subsidy for every Rs100 lent. While the concessional financing is intended to encourage investment in export-oriented projects, he questions whether the government has built sufficient safeguards to ensure that the resulting investment translates into sustainable export capacity. The policy has already undergone a significant change within four months. The ECC approved the facility in July with an 80% export requirement, only for the threshold to be reduced to 50% in November. The economist points out that the financing runs for 10 years, while its eligibility conditions changed within four months. For an entrepreneur considering machinery with a decade-long operating life, such uncertainty can undermine confidence in the policy framework. He argues that the terms agreed with businesses should remain protected for the life of their loans, with any subsequent changes applying only to new borrowers. A machine is not an export capability Iqbal's central economic argument is that purchasing machinery does not automatically make a business more productive or internationally competitive. A company could acquire new equipment through subsidised credit, increase production and sell most of its additional output in the domestic market without developing a sustainable export business. In that case, public money would have financed additional production capacity without achieving the export objectives for which the subsidy was provided. He draws on the World Bank research by Gonzalo Varela on Pakistani firms, which found that latent exporters, businesses preparing to enter international markets but not yet exporting, were 26% more productive than firms that never exported. Firms that exported consistently were a further 21% more productive than latent exporters of comparable size and sector. The research describes this process as learning by exporting, highlighting how exposure to international markets can improve business productivity. Iqbal also points to a worrying longer-term trend among listed companies. The proportion of firms that export declined from 60% to 51% over a decade, while exports as a share of sales among exporting firms fell from 31% to 27%. Exports have also declined from a peak of 16% of GDP to below 10%. These trends, he argues, explain why the original 80% threshold was poorly designed. Businesses that most need long-term financing are often those with export shares of 20% or 30%, which are trying to move into international markets rather than companies already deriving almost all their revenue from exports. The appropriate test of the subsidy, therefore, should come four years after financing: whether beneficiaries are selling more abroad, obtaining higher prices per unit and generating greater output per worker. Six institutions, but who owns the result? Beyond financing and productivity, Iqbal points to an accountability gap, with responsibilities spread across the Finance Division, EXIM Bank, commercial banks, the Ministry of Commerce, FBR Customs and the ECC, leaving no single institution answerable for how many new exporters the programme creates and how many sustain exports over two years. He proposes that EXIM Bank publish financing allocations separately for first-time exporters, early-stage exporters and established businesses. This would reveal whether the relaxed eligibility conditions are actually bringing new businesses into export markets or primarily benefiting existing exporters. He also recommends that EXIM Bank coordinate with the FBR Customs and the Pakistan Single Window to match borrowers' National Tax Numbers with customs records every quarter, tracking first-time shipments, continued exports after 24 months and improvements in export prices per unit. Iqbal further proposes linking the subsidy to sustained export performance. Businesses that continue shipping should retain concessional financing, while those failing to meet the export threshold in the fourth year should automatically shift to market-based rates. As his assessment suggests, Pakistan has repeatedly built runways for exporters but has yet to establish a system that keeps them flying.

内容来自 The Express Tribune - CHECKED 01/07/2020,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

用 HomepageTab 新标签页关注 RSS,打开浏览器就能看到更新。

安装 HomepageTab