Irish scrum set for defining test against the Springboks

When it comes to the scrum, perception is reality.

Given the amount of actions and reactions that can occur when two packs of roughly 900kg each slam together cheek by jowl, it's a near impossible task to referee perfectly.

Because of that, your reputation precedes you. When a team or individual is known to be dominant, you will naturally get a few 50/50 calls your way. By the same token, a scrum that struggled last week is also likely to struggle the next week.

Sometimes though, there's very little ambiguity to the scrum, and last year's meeting of Ireland and South Africa was the perfect example, as the Springboks minced the Irish setpiece in one of the most dominant scrummaging performances the game has seen.

Ireland gave up six scrum penalties to the world champions that evening, with Andrew Porter and Paddy McCarthy both sent to the sin-bin, in addition to the three other cards Ireland picked up that afternoon.

However, those numbers don't actually paint a full picture of the dominance, as there were four further penalty advantages from the scrum which were never cashed in – two of which led directly to tries.

That was a line in the sand day for Ireland from a scrummaging point of view.

In the Six Nations, their setpiece was improved but still inconsistent, which was somewhat understandable given the extent of their injuries at loosehead prop.

Andrew Porter's return has been instrumental in their improvements this month, with two dominant scrum outings against Argentina and Fiji, while the Leinster loosehead prop has spoken of how he has changed his approach to the setpiece, focusing on going "smarter, not harder".

Given the storm that Rassie Erasmus has created in recent days, the scrum has hardly been a point of discussion in the build-up to this week's game, but just like any other Springboks Test, it will be one of the main battlegrounds on which this game is won and lost.

On Thursday, a South African journalist did his best to sugar-coat his question to Farrell by suggesting the setpiece proved to be "quite challenging" when these teams met in 2025, an understatement which even the Ireland head coach had to laugh at.

"Since then, it's not just been this week, it’s been building since then and I feel we have certainly made improvements," Farrell said.

"I think a lot of teams have had those types of days against South Africa by the way, but it does bring a little bit of a heightened sense of awareness.

"There’s been a lot of work done since. To say it’s going to be perfect? It’s not going to be perfect on Saturday because they are world-leading in that regard, but again it’s another challenge that we are willing to take on."

South Africa won eight scrum penalties against France last week

The scrum was key battleground – both on and off the pitch - in the Greatest Rivalry series between South Africa and New Zealand earlier this year, with All Blacks head coach Dave Rennie doing his best to highlight what he believed were some less-than-legal tricks to wheel and run around the side of scrums.

Whether there was any validity to his complaints, it doesn't appear to have landed; the Boks scrum was in ominous form against a usually dominant French pack last week, winning eight penalties from that area of the game alone, while you could make the case they should have been awarded even more.

It leads us to the question, what makes a dominant scrum?

"I can't really tell you a secret. There are no secrets in it," said South Africa's 6ft 1in, 125kg tighthead prop Wilco Louw.

"That's probably a very technical question. I think it's years and years of really hard work and sticking in our system and trying to do what we pride ourselves in.

"I just think it's something that Springboks and our country are proud of. We have pride in our forward game and the backs in their game and everyone in their department.

"I think that's the beauty of it all. Everyone has got an opportunity to dominate there. Sometimes you dominate, sometimes you get dominated.

"It's just the way rugby goes. There's no secret in what it is. It's just focussing on our system and trying to do it as best as we can."

Sometimes, that dominance has become a weakness.

Andrew Porter was one of five Ireland players card

In this fixture last year, they were having so much joy toying with the Irish setpiece that they almost forgot the keep the scoreboard ticking over.

In their first Test with the All Blacks in August it was a similar story, and this time they were made to pay for it with a 33-16 defeat, while their 21-19 loss against France last week also saw them use their scrum as a means to humiliate the opposition rather than score against them.

And on Monday, their head coach acknowledged the need to turn penalties into points.

"Maybe if we just took the penalty right in front of the poles and we win the game, if Mannie [Libbok] kicked it over, maybe we would have won," Erasmus said.

"Maybe kick for the corner or kick for the poles and give the referee something else [to think about], just to give him breathing space as well. And I'm not saying this with any, any malice.

"I'm thinking that sometimes we can manage the game better than to try to get reward from the same thing, over and over from the referee."

A lengthy injury list at number 8 has led to Ireland captain Dan Sheehan moving to number 8 this week, and while it is a major risk for such a big game, it opens the door for Rónan Kelleher (above) to start at hooker while keeping Sheehan on the pitch.

Kelleher is regarded as the better scrummager of the two, and Ireland's last two wins against the Boks in 2024 and 2023 came with the 28-year-old starting at hooker.

Ireland's preparations haven't been helped, however, by an injury-enforced switch to their front row replacements, with Sam Illo ruled out due to concussion, and Thomas Clarkson drafted onto the bench.

It will be a first outing of the month for the Leinster tighthead, and a defining test of the Irish scrum.

Follow a live blog of Ireland v South Africa on Saturday (4.40pm) on rte.ie/sport and the RTÉ News app, and listen to live commentary on RTÉ Radio 1's Saturday Sport

内容来自 RTÉ - Sport,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

用 HomepageTab 新标签页关注 RSS,打开浏览器就能看到更新。

安装 HomepageTab