A US JURY convicted a man of setting a New Year’s Eve fire that grew into one of several deadly 2025 blazes in Los Angeles, killing 12 people in the Pacific Palisades.
It was the second federal trial of Jonathan Rinderknecht (30), after the initial prosecution attempt left the jury deadlocked and ended in a mistrial.
The former Uber driver is scheduled for sentencing on 17 March. He faces up to 40 years in prison.
Earlier this year, a separate jury leaned 10-2 toward acquitting Rinderknecht, but verdicts must be reached unanimously.
Jurors in the second trial were ordered not to take the previous proceedings or any mention of them into account in reaching their decision.
Friday’s verdict was on two charges: destruction of property by means of fire and arson affecting property used in interstate commerce.
Rinderknecht had pleaded not guilty to both.
This undated photo provided by the US Attorney's Office shows Jonathan Rinderknecht. US Attorney's Office via AP
US Attorney's Office via AP
But after approximately two days of deliberations, jurors found he used a lighter to ignite a brush fire near the wealthy, Malibu-adjacent Pacific Palisades neighbourhood.
Firefighters had thought they extinguished the blaze, but later found that smouldering embers underground were carried by strong winds and erupted, tearing through the affluent area and ravaging thousands of homes.
It proved to be among the most destructive wildfires in California history.
Rinderknecht’s defence attorney, Steven Haney, had argued there was no direct evidence that his client started the fire, and suggested errant New Year’s Eve fireworks could be to blame.
He said phone record evidence that Rinderknecht called 911 was efforts that he was trying to help alleviate the situation.
But the prosecution said evidence including mobile phone data put him at the scene of the crime.
They also pointed to a combination of video surveillance footage and analysis of fire spread dynamics to insist on his guilt.
The prosecution also said that Rinderknecht asked ChatGPT whether someone could be held liable for starting a fire with cigarettes.
Homes destroyed by the Palisades Fire are seen from the air in the Pacific Palisades neighbourhood. Andrea Hanks / White House Photo/Alamy Live News
Andrea Hanks / White House Photo/Alamy Live News / White House Photo/Alamy Live News
One of the jurors, who identified himself as Cameron, told reporters outside the courthouse that while he had originally leaned not guilty, Rinderknecht’s interview with federal investigators was incriminating.
“It was a clear, calm night. You know, no one else was on that hill that day, or that day or night,” the juror said, but the defendant “happened to be smoking, and because he happened to be smoking, he had a lighter.”
“Everything kind of started to point towards one conclusion.”
Bill Essayli, who leads the US Attorney’s Office for the Central District of California, lauded the verdict as “a measure of justice for the families who lost loved ones and the thousands whose lives were upended.”
Fierce winds fuelled the 2025 Los Angeles fires that resulted in a total of 31 deaths.
Alongside the blaze that devastated the Pacific Palisades, a second fire scorched Altadena, in northeast Los Angeles, razing parts of the neighbourhood.
That fire was tied to an idle transmission tower owned by local power company Southern California Edison, whose sparks ignited dry vegetation.
Two years later, the city is still working to rebuild after the disaster.
Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass – who just lost her reelection bid and was widely criticised for her handling of the fires – said in a statement that “no verdict can bring back the lives lost or erase the pain families have endured.”
“So many are still struggling to rebuild,” she said. “For those still displaced, the devastation remains a daily reality.”