The Threats to Pakistan’s Federation
Pakistan’s debate over creating new provinces raises critical questions about administrative reforms, provincial autonomy and the balance of political and economic power, including the establishment’s influence over the country’s political economy.
The political tensions that have emerged following the announcement of plans to create new provinces in Pakistan and hold a referendum on the issue cannot objectively be viewed merely as a debate over administrative reforms. The fundamental question is: what is the purpose behind the creation of new provinces? Is the objective to improve public services and ensure better governance, or is there a political strategy behind it aimed at further strengthening central authority, curtailing provincial autonomy, and weakening the influence of the civilian political leadership? Given the existing balance of power in Pakistan, this question is far from insignificant. In Pakistan, the influence of the establishment is not confined to matters of defence and national security. The presence of military-affiliated business enterprises and economic networks also means that the establishment’s economic interests cannot be overlooked in any analysis of Pakistan’s political economy.
In this context, provincial autonomy establishes an important constitutional and political limit on the centralising influence of the establishment. The provinces have their own elected governments, assemblies, financial resources, and constitutionally defined powers. These institutions have the capacity to challenge federal policies, question the distribution of national resources, and defend their respective regional interests. In particular, when a political party with strong public support is in power in a province, it can also use its political weight at the federal level.
The fundamental cause of the civil-military conflict in Pakistan is not merely the distribution of power, but also the question of who should have ultimate authority over state policies and resources. Elected political leadership seeks to govern on the basis of constitutional powers and public mandate, while the establishment has historically maintained its influence over political and administrative decision-making. If the creation of new provinces is used as a means to restrict the political position and powers of elected provincial governments, this conflict is likely to become more intense.
Provincial governments would regard such a move as interference in their constitutional powers, while political parties could view it as an attempt to undermine democratic representation. This could further deepen the existing mistrust between civilian political leadership and the establishment. If Parliament, provincial assemblies, and political parties resist such a decision, it could lead to a new institutional crisis within the country. In such a situation, the establishment would face greater political resistance, while the weakening of democratic institutions would further intensify the crisis of governance.
Pakistan’s fundamental problem is not the number of provinces, but the undemocratic centralisation of power. If, instead of addressing this problem, efforts are made to strengthen central dominance through the creation of new provinces, this could intensify tensions, conflict between the centre and the provinces, and the crisis of the federation. Rather than seeking to expand its political and economic influence, the establishment should play a role in strengthening the country’s constitutional and democratic system. Abandoning the insistence on creating new provinces and respecting provincial autonomy are essential considerations in this regard. This is because the path to keeping Pakistan united lies not in weakening its provinces, but in ensuring that they are empowered and politically satisfied
One of the major possible consequences of creating new provinces would be a change in the balance of power between the federal government and the provinces. The existing provinces hold a particular position in federal politics on the basis of their population, geographical size, natural resources, and political representation. Dividing them into smaller administrative units could alter this political position.This is particularly sensitive for Sindh. Opposition to the division of Sindh cannot be linked merely to the interests of any one political party, because the province’s geographical unity, historical identity, and control over its resources are fundamental issues in its politics. If an attempt is made to divide the province without the consent of its people and its elected assembly, it could seriously damage political trust between the federal government and Sindh.
The experience of 1971 in Pakistan’s history is a clear example of how serious the consequences can be when political majorities, provincial autonomy, and democratic rights are ignored. Instead of recognising the political aspirations of East Pakistan, attempts to maintain control through the use of force ultimately led to the breakup of the country. This historical experience should not be regarded merely as an event of the past, but as an important lesson for present-day federal policies.
If, even today, provincial political aspirations and constitutional powers are treated as obstacles to central authority and efforts are made to undermine them, regional tensions within the country could become more intense. Such a situation could further strengthen provincial nationalism, anti-centre politics, and extra-parliamentary resistance.
The establishment may assume that smaller administrative units would make central control easier. However, the political reality could prove quite different. The creation of new provinces could give rise to new power struggles, disputes over resource distribution, competition among emerging provincial leaderships, and questions of identity.
If these issues arise from central intervention rather than public consent, the crisis within the federation could become even deeper.Therefore, it would not be an exaggeration to argue that if the underlying objective behind the creation of new provinces is to restrict provincial autonomy, such a policy could pose new threats to Pakistan’s federal unity. The survival of the country should be linked not to the dominance of any single institution, but to the consent and equality of all federating units.
Pakistan’s fundamental problem is not the number of provinces, but the undemocratic centralisation of power. If, instead of addressing this problem, efforts are made to strengthen central dominance through the creation of new provinces, this could intensify tensions, conflict between the centre and the provinces, and the crisis of the federation. Rather than seeking to expand its political and economic influence, the establishment should play a role in strengthening the country’s constitutional and democratic system. Abandoning the insistence on creating new provinces and respecting provincial autonomy are essential considerations in this regard. This is because the path to keeping Pakistan united lies not in weakening its provinces, but in ensuring that they are empowered and politically satisfied.
内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗