COP31 venue failed the disability access challenge
Süheyla Düğen has walked a kilometre on days she attended COP31 using a cane from the tram station to the Blue Zone, crossing the entry point. The 69-year-old activist, known for leading ecological protection efforts in the Kazdağları region in Türkiye, says there should have been some effort to ensure that attendees with mobility issues have access to a shuttle from the tram stop to the Blue Zone. To get there, people had to walk up one pedestrian bridge, climb down, and then climb up and down a second pedestrian bridge to reach the Blue Zone area, roughly a kilometre of walking on foot in crowds that don’t usually stop or give space. “Everyone rushed to get in,” she noted. “And everyone rushed out of the venue.”
Düğen managed to get a wheelchair from the accessibility counter at the COP31 venue, which was manned by an overwhelmingly local Turkish staff. But while the wheelchair allowed her to navigate the sprawling venue to a certain extent, it did not quite help her at the end of her day. “The wheelchair had to be returned before the exit at the venue,” she said with visible frustration. Inside, she pointed to a lack of space for wheelchairs in a crowd of an estimated 100,000 attendees, delegates, negotiators, and observers.
Della Leonor, a disability advocate from the Philippines, confirmed a similarly exhausting daily journey. “Well I had a great challenge because from the hotel we have to walk to the bus stop every day,” she said. “There was a slope from the exit down to the road, after that the road had humps, and a wheelchair needed to be carried to access the bus. Upon arrival sometimes volunteers pushed us up the venue, but more often my personal assistant pushed me the whole way. It was so tiring, and having a wheelchair is a big challenge.” Her suggestions were direct: “The bus should have fetched participants directly from the hotel exit. A separate route should have been provided for persons with disabilities.”
The official record describes something very different. Turkish state-linked outlets reported that the entire 1.1 million square metre Blue and Green Zone was “planned as accessible,” supported by a 114-person Accessibility Team, 102 of them volunteers in purple vests, assigned to 521 registered disabled delegates. For physical access, organisers reported deploying 77 wheelchairs (61 manual, 16 battery-powered), alongside guide paths, Braille markings, tactile maps, and audio guidance for blind and low-vision attendees. For deaf participants, the Ministry of Family and Social Services assigned 30 sign language interpreters who worked across 31 different halls at the venue. Organisers also stated that seven Quiet Rooms were available for attendees with sensory sensitivities, and that 69 guests had been directed to them. Mustafa Ertok, COP31’s accessibility lead, was quoted saying that “we have met the needs of all 521 participants, both in transportation and within the venue,” and that accessibility was being treated “not as a preference, but as a human right”.
But the official COP31 accessibility page itself, as of the scheduled final day of the conference, was still publishing placeholders. Quiet and decompression spaces were “being explored,” with information to be provided “if these spaces are confirmed” (cop31.tr/accessibility). Sign language interpretation arrangements were “being coordinated with the relevant authorities,” with session-by-session details promised only “once arrangements are finalised”. These are not descriptions of services already delivered, they are prospective commitments, published while the conference was underway, for provisions that disabled attendees were told to expect.
Clare Gibellini, an Equality at Work Ambassador and policy leader advancing the rights, inclusion and employment of women with disabilities, who attended COP31 representing the National Disability Research Partnership (NDRP), Australia, assessed the same arrangements in a word that leaves no room for diplomatic ambiguity: “Honestly, they failed. Not partially, not ‘could do better.’ They failed.”
Read More: COP31 negotiators publish revised deal draft with no mention of fossil fuels
Gibellini’s account directly contradicts the official inventory at every layer. “There was no closed captioning, no sign language interpretation, and no quiet spaces anywhere in the venue,” she said. For blind and low-vision attendees, information was “not being provided in accessible formats,” and she specifically flagged the absence of Easy Read or plain language materials, meaning people with intellectual disabilities or low literacy were “shut out of the very documents and announcements that shape their futures.” On mobility, she pointed to the same first-mile failure Düğen described: “Wheelchair users are struggling to even get to the venue because the transport is not accessible.” And for sensory access, the pavilions were “so noisy that people with sensory or hearing impairments simply cannot participate.”
A blind attendee from the Global South, who spoke on condition of anonymity, described a further gap that official claims of tactile maps and Braille markings did not address. The entire pavilion area where booths were set up lacked any floor markings for visually impaired participants, no tactile strips, no Braille signage on the ground, no guided path through the exhibition space. “I could not visit the pavilions at all,” the attendee said. “There was no way to know where anything was, no way to find the booths I had come to see. The guide paths the organizers talk about did not extend into the areas that mattered most for networking and learning.” The account directly contradicts the official claim that guide paths and tactile maps were in place all over the venue. While such measures did exist at entry points or along main corridors, they did not reach the pavilion floors where the substantive exchanges of COP31 took place.
Gibellini framed the failure not as a logistical oversight but as a human rights problem. Both Türkiye and Australia have ratified the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, which obligates states to ensure accessible information and the full participation of disabled people in public and political life. “A summit that decides the future of our planet, while locking out the people most affected by climate change, is not an inclusive summit,” she said. "It is a summit that has decided whose participation matters and whose does not.”
She described accessibility as operating on three layers, and said COP31 “essentially missed that entire layer” of practical accommodations, ramps, captions, interpreters, accessible formats, and quiet spaces. The second layer is the cost transferred onto disabled people themselves: the energy, the planning, the recovery time, the extra support required “just to get through a venue that was not built for them.” The third is attitudes, whether organizers treat lived experience as expertise or as “a box to tick.” The message from the setup of this COP, she said, is that “our participation was never really planned for.”
Her recommendations for UNFCCC were concrete: make accessibility standards a condition of hosting, verified through a published pre-conference audit; co-design with disabled persons’ organisations and establish a complaints mechanism so barriers are fixed “in days, not years”; make captioning, interpretation, Easy Read, and quiet rooms the default, backed by a dedicated budget line; and recognise the Disability Caucus as a formal constituency within the UNFCCC. “Inclusion that only works for non-disabled bodies is not inclusion,” she said.
The gap between the official numbers and the lived accounts is not merely a matter of degree. It is a gap between provision on paper and access in practice. The International Disability Alliance, at its Disability Climate Caucus press conference at COP31, made the same point in structural terms: “Accessibility cannot be limited to physical access alone. Persons with disabilities must be able to meaningfully participate, influence decisions, and shape climate policies that directly affect their lives and communities.” Reporting from the ground noted that even where sign language interpretation was nominally available, it was offered only in select sessions and required 48 hours' advance request, a procedural barrier that undermines the very purpose of on-demand access.
The Express Tribune approached the UNFCCC office, the media desk at the venue, and the press office, including Tim Davis, Manager of the International Broadcast Centre (IBC) of the UNFCCC, for comment on the accessibility arrangements. Despite repeated reminders both in person and over e-mail, no response was provided. The accessibility desk set up at the front of the venue not only declined to comment, Can Ergün, a staff member deployed there, became hostile to any sort of inquiry. The UNFCCC remained silent on questions about the number of wheelchairs present at the venue until the end of the conference. But activists and attendees at the disability caucus were not muted about their concerns. The official record will show that 77 wheelchairs were deployed, 30 interpreters assigned, and seven quiet rooms designated. What it will not show is the kilometer Düğen walked on a cane, the wheelchair she had to return before she could leave, the bus Della Leonor could not reach without being carried over road humps, the pavilion floors that offered no path for a blind attendee, or the Accessibility Help Desk that turned them, and the journalists asking about them, away.
This story was produced as part of the COP31 Climate Change Media Partnership, a fellowship for journalists covering the UN climate talks
内容来自 The Express Tribune - CHECKED 01/07/2020,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗