Two Dynastic Families Are Blocking New Provinces, Says Irshad Bhatti
Senior journalist Irshad Bhatti says the existing system has failed and new provinces are needed, questioning how government members who challenge the system and Parliament’s legitimacy can make decisions for the public.
ISLAMABAD, (Pakistan Point News - 20th Nov, 2026) Senior journalist Irshad Bhatti said during Geo News’ programme Report Card that two “royal families” were preventing the creation of new provinces and, instead of resolving people’s problems, were warning of bloodshed.
He said the current system had failed and new provinces were needed. When members of the government themselves questioned the system and the status of Parliament, he asked, how could they make decisions on behalf of the people?
Bhatti questioned the government’s announced support for a referendum, asking which government was meant and suggesting it was probably the PML-N government. He asked whether Nawaz Sharif had held a press conference to support a referendum, whether Shehbaz Sharif had addressed the nation on the issue, and whether Maryam Nawaz had announced that the party would hold one and that people should prepare.
He also asked whether the PML-N had held a party meeting after which a minister had made such an announcement.
He said several PML-N members told him off the record that when asked why they remained silent, they replied that they had seen what happened to those who spoke out, and that they had intended to say the same thing. Asked whether they shared that view, they said to set opinions aside: they would do what others were already doing.
Bhatti said they were effectively opposed to new provinces and administrative units, insisting they could not be created, and telling people to discuss the idea and then return to them.
Bhatti said these comments were made off the record, while two or four people spoke publicly in a light-hearted manner and misled the public and the media by saying this or that would happen. He said the PML-N was doing silently what the Pakistan Peoples Party was doing openly.
He said the other argument was that the political elite—the two “royal families”—should be allowed to proceed without being rushed, because they would be held accountable later. Bhatti asked why they should be allowed to proceed and whether anyone had actually held them accountable.
He said they had signed the Charter of Democracy, then asked whether anyone had demanded accountability over what they had done with it, adding that they had buried it themselves. He said the 18th Constitutional Amendment contained many good things, but its key principles had not been implemented. He asked whether anyone had held them accountable for that, and said they kept raising the issue but had never received an answer from them.
The senior journalist referred to Bilawal Bhutto, saying that after the 28th Constitutional Amendment he had said “thank God,” but was now speaking of a “coercive majority.” Bhatti asked whether anyone had held them accountable. He said they had introduced the NAB amendments, enacted the PECA Act and passed laws on rallies and processions, as well as the 26th and 27th constitutional amendments.
He challenged anyone to name a single instance in which they could be held accountable for the benefit of the public or the country. He said they could not, and that the political figures acted when it served their own interests, so there would be no accountability.
Bhatti said new provinces were needed because the system and the existing structure had failed to deliver. He said the creation of new provinces and administrative units would change things and bring changes to people’s lives.
He said proponents had stated that the matter would be dealt with in Parliament and that the constitutional process would be followed, including holding a referendum in accordance with the Constitution. But he questioned whether those in government, including Bilawal, represented the public. He said Bilawal had sparked a brief “revolution,” but Asif Ali Zardari was now in control and had made considerable efforts to that end.
Bhatti asked whether this was a representative Parliament and the government the people had elected, and whether these were the same faces who had come to power.
He said that if those in power were not genuine and there were doubts about the Parliament’s legitimacy because of Form 47, how could they make decisions for the people? He also asked how anyone could oppose a positive step, and how a referendum could lead to bloodshed, rebellion or brothers killing one another.
Bhatti said all opponents of a referendum should say plainly that they did not want a province created; then it would not happen. Even if all of Sindh voted in favour, he said, the decision would still rest with them and would have to go before Parliament. He said he would accept the case against new provinces if Bilawal Bhutto first presented five logical reasons for opposing them, but argued there were none and that two “royal families”—two dynasties—were preventing the change.
He added that people privately said new provinces should be created but that they could do nothing unless their party agreed. Bhatti said he hoped new provinces would be established, every province would have an effective local government system, and the alleged conspiracies of the two “royal families” would fail.
He also hoped the two private limited companies that he said had been imposed on the public in the name of democracy would be defeated, and that new provinces and new people would bring solutions to public problems and improve performance.
Bhatti concluded that their performance was “zero upon zero,” the country was in reverse gear and the public was suffering. He said people were being warned not to speak or they would be kicked, and not to speak or there would be bloodshed and rebellion, adding: “This is democracy.”
内容来自 UrduPoint News,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗