How Madison Square Garden became a facial recognition flashpoint

Madison Square Garden may have done more to turn New Yorkers against facial recognition than any privacy campaign ever could.

The majority of New York City Council members signed on earlier this year as sponsors to a bill, known as Intro 213, that would curb the use of facial recognition in public establishments from shops to stadiums, and the proposed legislation received a nod from Mayor Zohran Mamdani in a statement shared with Fast Company.

“No fan should have to worry about their biometric data when they’re already worried about their team losing the game. Intro 213 would prohibit the collection and sale of your personal data at public accommodations like sports arenas throughout New York City,” Mamdani says. “It is time to ban the scan and protect New Yorkers’ privacy and civil rights.”

Councilmember Shahana Hanif, who introduced the bill, has pointed to widespread concerns about surveillance in New York City, dating back at least to controversial NYPD actions like the monitoring of Muslims after September 11.  

“I grew up in the backdrop of 9/11, and saw what surveillance, racial profiling, and a surveillance state is capable of,” says Hanif, the first Muslim woman elected to the City Council.  

But Hanif, like other advocates of limits on the technology, says she was also motivated by the applications of facial recognition at Madison Square Garden and other venues run by Madison Square Garden Entertainment, including an incident in late 2022 where a woman escorting her daughter’s Girl Scout group to Radio City Music Hall’s celebrated Christmas show was denied entry. The reason for the ban, apparently enforced by facial recognition technology MSG Entertainment has deployed since at least 2018, was a policy barring admission to lawyers from firms involved in cases against MSG Entertainment.  

In general, experts say public sentiment has turned against many surveillance-oriented technologies. For instance, in an August Reuters/Ipsos poll, 47% of respondents opposed the use of Flock Safety’s AI-powered license plate cameras in their communities; only 38% were in favor.

MSG Entertainment—which didn’t respond to multiple inquiries from Fast Company—has said the policy is necessary to prevent “improper disclosure and discovery” during litigation. But the seemingly Scrooge-like implementation, targeting an attorney who wasn’t personally involved in any MSG-related cases, still drew widespread public outrage. It also attracted a letter  from New York State Attorney General Letitia James warning that the policy could violate the law and expressing concern about potential racial and gender bias in facial recognition software.

Studies have found some facial recognition systems perform worse on images of darker-skinned people and women than on lighter-skinned faces and those of men, though vendors generally claim those concerns have been addressed in newer versions of the technology.  

MSG’s surveillance problem

For some time now, MSG has been a kind of flashpoint in the debate over facial recognition. In recent years, MSG Entertainment venues have been accused of pulling a Radio City concertgoer out of an admission line over a shirt he designed years prior that mocked MSG Entertainment CEO and New York Knicks owner James Dolan; tracking a trans woman’s movements at the stadium; and even maintaining a secret dossier of anti-facial recognition activists that was reportedly exposed in a data breach earlier this year.  

“I think Madison Square Garden has been a real eye-opener for a lot of people at all of the horrible ways that surveillance can go wrong, especially in public spaces like sporting stadiums,” says Reem Suleiman, senior campaign director at Fight for the Future.  

The company’s frequently combative posture, from continued defense of the attorney ban policy to Dolan’s feuding with Mamdani over security around public watch parties during the Knicks’ recent championship run, likely hasn’t helped.

After extensive reporting by Wired on the venue’s use of facial recognition and surveillance tech—including a July 2026 article that claimed based on data reportedly exposed in the breach that MSG maintained records of some celebrities’ gender identity and sexual orientation—MSG Entertainment sued Wired and its reporters for defamation, alleging the outlet “cherry-picked” from leaked data to “manufacture a false narrative portraying MSG as targeting the LGBTQIA community for discriminatory purposes.” Wired, in turn, called the lawsuit “baseless and ridiculous.”    

For New Yorkers especially, skepticism of facial recognition has become intertwined with criticism of MSG Entertainment and Dolan himself. Dolan previously helmed his family’s cable TV empire, Cablevision Systems Corp., before its sale to Altice in 2016, and now draws at least the usual level of fan ire expected for a wealthy team owner.

Critics have also pointed out that Madison Square Garden reportedly turned off its facial recognition system when it hosted the wedding of Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift. That came after the luxe, celebrity-studded July 3 celebration that closed parts of Midtown Manhattan streets during a busy holiday weekend had already come to symbolize the growing gap between the mega-rich and everyone else. 

“We saw recently how unnecessary this technology actually is for security at large venues and arenas when Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce had the facial recognition system turned off at Madison Square Garden during their wedding,” says Will Owen, communications director at the Surveillance Technology Oversight Project (S.T.O.P.). “That goes to show how unnecessary the technology is when they were happy to turn it off at one of the highest-profile, highest-security events of the year.” 

The backlash goes beyond MSG

Indeed, the association with MSG may be a gift to activists looking to curb the use of facial recognition, though most emphasize their concerns go beyond sporting venues or any one particular facility. Facial recognition is also used at other kinds of businesses, including major retail chains, to detect people banned from the business or suspected of crimes like shoplifting. It’s a fact particularly evident in New York City, where places of public accommodation using the technology are required to post signs to that effect. S.T.O.P., which supports the call for a facial-recognition ban, has compiled a map of some of the locations in the city sporting such signage. 

“Surveillance has always disproportionately targeted marginalized communities, and we fear how people of color, especially Black people, will face false flags from facial recognition systems at venues and arenas [and] stores,” Owen says. 

In 2023, pharmacy chain Rite Aid agreed to stop using facial recognition for surveillance purposes for at least five years, after the U.S. Federal Trade Commission alleged the technology generated false positives, particularly around people of color, that led to customers incorrectly being flagged as shoplifters or troublemakers, harassed by employees, asked to leave, and even erroneously reported to police. 

And Wegmans, the East Coast supermarket chain, has been criticized for using the technology at some of its stores, which it was required to disclose under the New York City Law. Wegmans has said it “collects facial recognition data and only uses it to identify individuals who have previously been flagged for misconduct,” and that the data is retained only for a limited amount of time. 

“Persons of interest are determined by our asset protection team based on incidents occurring on our property and on a case-by-case basis, by information from law enforcement for criminal or missing persons cases,” according to the company. “We do not share facial recognition data with any third parties, nor do any third parties have access to the data.” 

When your face becomes your ticket

Other venues are also increasingly using facial recognition technology for ticketing and even concession-stand purchases, generally through an opt-in system advertised as being faster than pulling up digital tickets or pulling out a wallet to buy a hot dog or beer. Facial authentication company Wicket got its start during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, working with the NFL’s Cleveland Browns on technology to allow fans to access the stadium without needing to remove their masks or interact too closely with employees. 

“They didn’t need to pull out their phone, they didn’t need to touch anything, they didn’t need to talk to anybody,” says Wicket COO Jeff Boehm. “It was a very safe and socially distant way to get people into the venue.” 

Instead, users take selfies at home that are associated with their tickets, and tablet-like devices at the stadium scan their faces and grant them entry. About half of Browns season ticket owners now use the system, Boehm says, which has since been deployed by about 75 teams around the world as well as by organizers of events like the Salesforce Dreamforce conference. At venues that support it, visitors can also use their faces to pay for food and even alcoholic beverages, with age-verification data from their IDs associated with their records in the system if they wish. 

The system is strictly opt-in, Boehm emphasizes, and it captures facial data only about visitors who expressly choose to sign in with the Wicket devices, since the company doesn’t provide broader surveillance systems that scan crowds en masse.  

“You don’t have to do this if you don’t want to use your face,” he says. “You can use your traditional ticketing mechanism.” 

Raw facial images aren’t stored, only mathematical “template” data abstracted from them, and the system has been found accurate across demographic groups in testing by the National Institute of Standards and Technology, Boehm says, noting that how long the data is stored is ultimately up to teams and venue operators. 

“The teams own the data—we do not,” he says. “We’re not creating some big, massive, centralized database that we’re monetizing or sharing or using for other purposes. The teams own the data, and it’s up to them as to how long they want to keep it.” 

Other facial recognition providers offer a mix of security and sign-in tech: FaceFirst, for instance, says its technology “proactively detects threats as they enter a venue” and can help provide “expedited entry to premium season ticket holders.” Similarly, eConnect advertises technology that can help venues like stadiums and casinos detect banned visitors, spot VIPs for special treatment, and reduce the need for ID checks for repeat customers.

A representative for FaceFirst parent Gatekeeper Systems said in an email to Fast Company that it does not share details about its software or its clients. eConnect declined to make someone available for an interview. 

Is opting in enough?

To some critics of facial recognition technology, even reassurances that certain ticketing systems are voluntary are still not sufficient to justify their use, especially amid concerns that facial data could one day be shared with law enforcement.  

“It’s left very unclear and opaque how this highly sensitive data may be retained or shared,” says S.T.O.P.’s Owen. “Our faces are not worth handing over for perhaps slightly more convenient check-ins to venues.” 

It’s still unclear whether the proposed New York City law, if passed, would ultimately bar even voluntary facial check-in programs. While the New York Mets highlight voluntary facial ticketing based on Wicket’s technology, a team spokesperson didn’t respond to an inquiry about the potential impact of the New York City bill.  

The exact language of any final law still appears subject to change, though it seems likely that curbing large-scale scanning of visitors to businesses—and venues like MSG—will remain a priority. 

“Right now, I think we really want to get to a place where the bill language satisfies all the parties, between the council and the mayor,” Hanif says. “And then we’ll push it for a full vote.” 


内容来自 Fast Company,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

用 HomepageTab 新标签页关注 RSS,打开浏览器就能看到更新。

安装 HomepageTab