El Niño and Asia's food security
Why Pakistan has more to worry about
By: Hadia Allaudin
El Niño is most commonly discussed in terms of increased temperature; changed precipitation; and crop loss. However, there should be just as much emphasis placed on how this affects the affordability of food.
Millions of households in rural and coastal areas of Asia rely on agriculture and fishing as a means of making a living. As such they would be particularly susceptible to disruptions caused by changing weather. The potential strain on the communities affected by the 2026-27 El Niño event could cause additional stress. Specifically, Pakistan could experience considerable difficulty. While it is unlikely that Pakistan would suffer food shortages during an El Niño event, its concerns would likely focus on rising costs for consumers due to falling incomes for vulnerable families.
According to the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), El Niño had become firmly entrenched throughout much of the world's tropical oceans by late summer of 2026. Furthermore, the WMO predicted that El Niño would strengthen well into early 2027.
Effects of El Niño vary greatly depending upon the location within the tropics. Some locations may endure extended periods with below-average rainfall totals, while other regions could receive above-normal amounts of rain. Both scenarios can present significant problems to local agricultural-based economies.
For example, farmers require consistent seasonal rains, fishers require favorable sea conditions, and millions of individuals derive their employment from work activities associated with the production of food. Once these economic livelihoods are impacted, the impact of those effects begins to appear at the level of individual household marketplaces.
Southeast Asia provides a very good model for understanding how changes in weather can negatively impact individuals reliant upon natural resource extraction for their earnings. Rough seas off Indonesia's Maluku Islands have prevented fishers from reaching their normal fishing grounds. A monitoring station located near Ambon and Seram collected data regarding fisher's catches from April to July 2026. During that time frame, the average catch per fishing trip at one of the sites monitored was 3.6 kg compared to 8.3 kg during the same time frame in 2025.
While El Niño is a regional climate problem, the economic impacts will be influenced, in part, by the preparedness of individual countries. Indonesia and India demonstrate that the issue is not only a drop in production or even a lack of food stocks. This should be understood by Pakistan before it becomes difficult for it to control the pressure on its markets. Availability of wheat in a country's warehouse doesn't mean that the country has secured food supply. The true measure will be the cost to the average home.
Those reduced harvests can be expected to have negative economic implications for the many communities in which fishing continues to be a primary source of revenue. The decrease in fishing trips also translates to a decrease in fishing sales and the reduction in earnings to support the day-to-day needs of families. The problem, thus, is not just one of local market availability of fish. It also affects the livelihoods of people whose livelihoods rely on catching and selling them.
India is another example of the strain which changing weather conditions can impose on food markets. The monsoon season in 2026 has seen 12.6 percent of the long period average rainfall, according to the Reserve Bank of India. While the country has large public foodgrain stockholdings, these are not a sure way of curbing food inflation
Government stocks can take up some of the supply, but not ensure that food is available for all households to purchase in the market. The experience also demonstrates the importance of considering food security as more than just the amount of grain a country has. It's not just about food prices, it's about income and food access as well.
The situation in Pakistan is worse. The nation started the ongoing agricultural season with low stocks of wheat and agricultural fields are still suffering from water scarcity, production expenses and irregular rains. This has been exacerbated by the 2026 monsoon. Sindh had experienced around 50.8 percent below normal rainfall while Balochistan had experienced around 33.7 percent below normal rainfall. The importance of these figures is that water availability is critical to agriculture in both provinces. Drier conditions can impact crop yields, livestock and availability of farm labour. The tough harvest season can translate into a loss of livelihood for small farmers and daily wage labourers.
These agricultural pressures combined with the rising food prices become more worrying. Wheat flour, which is one of the major staples of the food in Pakistani homes, has seen a significant increase in its price. Wheat flour prices in the monitored markets in Pakistan were 50 to 83 percent higher in August 2026 compared with the same month last year, according to the Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO). It also set record prices in a number of markets in its next report. This rise comes on the back of a month in which inflation was running at the highest level in nearly 70 years and puts a strain on already strained budgets. Those families who rely on daily or irregular income are especially vulnerable since an increase in food prices does not necessarily lead to an increase in income.
Here lies the real food security problem. A decline in agricultural output may lead to higher prices, but it can be an even tougher situation for poor households if the income loss further impacts their purchasing power.
A farmer with a small output might not have as much to spend, and an agricultural labourer might have fewer job prospects. Meanwhile, both are having to buy food at higher prices. This is also the case in fishing communities, whose livelihood is based on daily sales, who suffer from a fall in catches and thus their income. In such instances, families' food intake is typically reduced, and they may opt for less expensive food or divert funds for other essentials. Markets might still be open, but how affordable food becomes is becoming more and more unclear.
This issue cannot be resolved by making emergency imports. Importing wheat can fill the gap, but it's not doing much to alleviate the losses to the wheat farmers or ease the hardships of the poor consumer. It is also likely to put further pressure on external reserves, especially if prices in the world market are high. The government should therefore look at the broader economic impacts of El Niño, rather than simply as a problem affecting agriculture.
If the situation does not deteriorate further, there are a few things Pakistan can do. Rainfall should be closely monitored by federal and provincial governments, availability of water, crop conditions and food prices, especially in the affected areas of Sindh and Balochistan. Agri farmers should have access to low cost seeds, water saving technology for irrigation, and effective agricultural support. Wheat stocks should be closely watched and distribution plans should be made for areas which may have difficulty getting wheat; this approach needs to be taken. Existing social protection programmes should offer specific financial support to low-income households with high food cost pressures, particularly. Small farmers, agricultural labourers and fishing communities should receive some assistance in safeguarding their livelihood sources.
While El Niño is a regional climate problem, the economic impacts will be influenced, in part, by the preparedness of individual countries. Indonesia and India demonstrate that the issue is not only a drop in production or even a lack of food stocks. This should be understood by Pakistan before it becomes difficult for it to control the pressure on its markets. Availability of wheat in a country's warehouse doesn't mean that the country has secured food supply. The true measure will be the cost to the average home.
The writer is a freelance columnist.
内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗