Back to the drawing board
The proposal may not have been thought through
AT PENPOINT
The latest foray by Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi into the provincial question has led to a surprising denial by President Asif Zardari, though there seems to have been a follow-up by Zardari with Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif which has led to a party-level decision by Sharif’s PML(N).
Naqvi has said that the creation of more provinces would depend on the result of a referendum. He had raised the issue, which has been something that has come up every now and then ever since Partition, with a new plea, that of governance. His argument was that the present four provinces were ungovernable because of the increase in their populations. Thus governance joins development and language as a reason for the break-up of provinces.
The governance argument seems to mirror that of development closely. Naqvi appears to have thought first of process rather than outcome. This is not entirely unjustified, for the problem many people face is that decisions are made in distant capitals. The problem is that a bureaucrat or politico living a stone’s throw away is not necessarily going to be less contumacious than one living at several days’ distance. One effect is going to be that provinces are going to be weaker than present vis-à-vis the federal government.
Another problem even with the referendum proposal is that either the question comprises several pages of close print, or the voter will be asked to give a blank cheque. That referenda under the Constitution are indicative, not mandatory, is another matter. Actually, referenda are not part of the Constitution’s procedure for creating a new province. The Constitution requires the ability to amend the Constitution, which means two-thirds majorities in both Senate and Nation Assembly, as well as simple majorities in the assemblies of affected provinces, which have to pass enabling resolutions.
Referenda have not got a particularly appetizing history in Pakistan, with only two previously held, and the provision not being part of the 1973 Constitution, being introduced after the 1977 election, as a sort of loud thinking on a possible solution to the crisis which broke out after the opposition refused to accept its results. The provision was used by Ziaul Haq for his 19 December 1984 referendum, and Musharraf for his on 30 April 2002. Zia’s got 98.53 percent ‘Yes’ votes, Musharraf’s got 97,97 percent. Both resulted in Zia and Musharraf being elected for five years as President. A referendum this time around would not have anyone being elected anything presumably, but there is a danger of similarly skewed results.
Nothing is sacred about the present provincial borders. The oldest does not go back more than a couple of hundred years, but is changing the present ones going to achieve anything beyond the most almighty confusion? Why not try empowering local bodies?
The real problem is that Naqvi has asked too global a question. It may be that someone may support the idea of more provinces, but the idea is meaningless without concrete proposals before one. It is no coincidence that Seraiki nationalists rejected his initial proposal, on the ground that apart from a Seraiki province, no other demand for a province had any preparation behind it.
At the moment, all provincial movements have a linguistic basis. There are two Seraiki movements in Punjab, one centred around Karachi, another based on the old Bahwalpur state, which only lost separate existence in 1955 when it was merged into One Unit. There is a lively debate on whether Bahwalpur Division should become part of the Seraiki province, or form a province on its own, one where a different dialect of Seraiki, Riasati, is spoken.
Language and dialect are problematic in Punjab, and raise questions that have not yet been answered. Without answering those questions, political questions cannot be decided. For example, is Hazarawal (spoken in KP) a separate language or a dialect of Potohari? And is Potohari a separate language or a dialect of Punjabi. Or is Hazzarawal a dialect of Seraiki? The language spoken in Dera Ismail Khan is certainly a dialect of Seraiki, but is it a separate dialect or is it a subdialect of Derawali?
Even Sindh has problems, even if one was to ignore the Urduphone elephant in the room. Let the differences between Karachi’s Urdu and Hyderabad’s be swept under the carpet, Sindhi has still got issues of its own, such as its Seraiki dialect. The problem is that Sindhi Seraiki has not become so strongly differentiated from Sindhi as to make it clearly a separate language. Another problem is that speakers are so intermingled, that separating out any area would be difficult. Sindhis do not distinguish between Sindhi and Seraiki speakers. If President Zardari was to be asked, he would call himself a Sindhi speaker, even though he speaks Seraiki.
Zardari has a problem. The proposal has been floated by someone considered his protégé, but has evoked a very strong reaction from the Sindh PPP, because it does not want to see Sindh divided, and probably given a province which Muhajirs could claim for their own.
The problem with the sort of province-creation being contemplated, or at least spoken of, creates grave strains on the federal structure. The Constitution was drafted with four provinces in mind, with a united Kashmir as a possible fifth. Luckily, the Constitution is federal, but it includes the provincial constitutions. If Balochistan wishes its executive to be headed by a Grand Panjandrum rather than a Chief Minister, it needs to convince the Parliament in Islamabad to pass that amendment.
The biggest issue is that the National Finance Commission and the National Economic Committee will swell. The NFC will go from its present nine to as many as 25, and instead of a commission, will become a seminar. As for the Council of Common Interests, the number of federal ministers (including the PM) is specified as four; as CMs are the other members, there are an equal number. Does that change with the greater number of CMs, or remain the same?
How is the Senate to be affected? Do all provinces continue to elect 19 senators each, so that a parliamentary joint session has a Senate majority?
New provincial assemblies will have to be established. What will be their size? And how does all of this affect the presidential election, in which the Houses each have as many votes as the smallest House. What happens to sitting MPAs? Because of this, it might be best to change only after an election.
It might mean that the entire federal compact will have to be re-examined. So far, Pakistan has been following the US Constitution, for though it is a parliamentary system, it is a federation.
Why is all of this being done? Considering that the local bodies have not been operationalized, would it not be better to try that?
One major obstacle to the creation of new provinces is the bureaucracy, if the aim is better governance. The bureaucracy would be made happy, because it means an immediate multiplication of secretariat posts and a gradual expansion of mofussil posts, as expansion takes place. However, the deputy secretary in Lahore, unhelpful to the applicant from Sadiqabad, will be as unhelpful, as stiffnecked, when moved hundreds of kilometres closer to Bahwalpur. The civil services need an attitude change, which the proposal does not address.
At the root is the referendum idea. Is there to be a national referendum? Why do voters in KP get a say in the division of Sindh? What if Vehari voters are against the idea, while those in neighbouring Khanewal favour it? How does one measure where voters in Sadiqababad want to go? Ghotki in Sindh or Bahawalpur in Punjab?
Nothing is sacred about the present provincial borders. The oldest does not go back more than a couple of hundred years, but is changing the present ones going to achieve anything beyond the most almighty confusion? Why not try empowering local bodies?
内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗