'Grief doesn't fade': Couple settle home birth death case

Updated / Thursday, 19 Nov 2026 14:56

An exterior view of the Four Courts in Dublin

Getty

Niamh Gray and James Kane settled their action at the High Court

The parents of a little boy who died after a homebirth went wrong have settled their action against the HSE and the National Maternity Hospital.

Ben Kane from Lusk in Co Dublin, died five days after his birth in February 2022.

The High Court was told midwives from the Home Birth Service did not attend at the home of his parents Niamh Gray and James Kane until more than 12 hours after Ms Gray's waters broke.

The High Court was told that the two midwives should have attended the home much earlier.

Senior Counsel, Bruce Antoniotti, said it was a case where labour was failing to progress.

He said if the midwives had attended when they should have, difficulties with Ms Gray’s labour would have been identified sooner. He said she could have been transferred to hospital earlier and baby Ben would have been delivered in a healthy manner.

The court was also told that even when Ms Gray arrived at the National Maternity Hospital in Holles street in the early hours of 7 February 2022, Ben was not delivered as soon as he could have been.

The HSE and Holles Street hospital have apologised to the couple.

The court was told recommendations in a review carried out by the HSE have been implemented. Mr Justice Paul Coffey paid tribute to the "selflessness" of Ms Gray and Mr Kane in making sure the recommendations were adopted and trying to ensure the safety of other births in the future.

Outside court Ms Gray said Ben should have been enjoying his second year in preschool and was missed every day.

She said that for any parent going through a case like this, all they wanted was changes and to be heard when things go wrong. She said they wanted to know that there was a commitment to not letting this happen again to any other parents and she said they felt they had the strength to be able to pursue this.

The couple said homebirths were now more integrated into national maternity services. They said their main concerns had been about early checks for a woman in labour as well as better communication about labour and better communication between midwives and hospitals when a transfer was necessary.

Mr Kane said it was very important for Ben's legacy that they had fought for change.

He said nothing would bring Ben back. But he said if "his little life" could prevent other parents and families from going through "such a travesty" then that was the "little mark" their son had made on the world.

More stories on

内容来自 RTE,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

用 HomepageTab 新标签页关注 RSS,打开浏览器就能看到更新。

安装 HomepageTab