Google rejects UK request for Russell Brand YouTube video to be removed, sources say

Google has refused a government request to remove a YouTube video posted by jailed rapist Russell Brand’s wife in which he claims his innocence, Whitehall sources have told the BBC.

The Prison Service of England and Wales submitted the request. A Ministry of Justice (MoJ) spokesperson said “it was only right” to ask for content that was “distressing for victims” to be removed.

The disgraced comedian is currently in prison after being sentenced to 10-and-a-half years following his conviction for rape and three counts of sexual assault.

Google told BBC News in a statement it was “aware of the new content and our teams are investigating”.

It added: “We suspended Russell Brand’s channel from the YouTube Partner Program in September 2023. The channel has not been able to monetise on YouTube since then.”

On Sunday, Brand’s wife Laura shared a video on their YouTube channel and read out a message from Brand in which he claimed: “I am not guilty of the offences I have been jailed for.”

The MoJ spokesperson added that while “removal ultimately depends on the platform’s own terms”, the department strongly believes “YouTube should remove this content”.

The Prison Service of England and Wales formally requested that the video be removed on the basis that they believed it was offensive to Brand’s victims and had reached a substantial audience.

The BBC was initially told a minister had met Google to request the deactivation of Brand’s account.

The MoJ later clarified the request had focused on the controversial video, and it is now understood a minister did not meet Google and the request was made via an established mechanism the prison service has with tech companies to request deletion of material.

The BBC has been told that Google declined the request, saying that its rules had not been broken.

However, speaking on BBC Breakfast, housing minister Matthew Pennycook described the video as “abhorrent” and said the government remained in “close dialogue” with Google.

Jess Phillips, the former minister for safeguarding and violence against women and girls, told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme the government “doesn’t have the power to enforce that this video is taken down”.

“It relies on YouTube, in this instance … to do the right thing, which is a much, much broader argument about whether Ofcom codes that are in the Online Safety Act are there actually to protect women,” she said.

An Ofcom spokesperson said in a statement that the current guidance was ultimately voluntary, and “any changes to the legislation to make it mandatory would be a matter for government and parliament”.

Phillips, describing Brand as an “absolute narcissist”, suggested it was “very likely” that the government would look at introducing a second online safety act to address gaps in the current regulatory framework.

“Before, we haven’t had prisoners who had massive YouTube followings,” she said. “This is an entirely new era.”

Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said she would not immediately demand Google remove the video, if she was in power – although agreed it was concerning “if people in prison are able to use other conduits to send messages”.

Badenoch told Today YouTube was a private platform, and demanding content be taken down “without looking at exactly whether a law has been broken is not where I would start from”.

“If we want to make legislation for that, then we can look at that. But I’m quite worried about government intervening,” she added.

Brand’s message has prompted an investigation into whether he had broken prison rules.

Downing Street previously called the message “clearly appalling”, adding: “Prisoners are strictly banned from making statements that cause distress to victims, and speaking to the media is only permitted in exceptional circumstances.”

Justice Secretary Alex Norris said the case was being “urgently investigated, and I expect action to be taken if he is found to have broken the rules”.

Prisoners’ phone conversations are routinely recorded, but not necessarily listened to by prison authorities. If Brand is found to have breached the rules, possible repercussions could include a temporary phone ban or live monitoring of his calls.

In 2022 notorious inmate Charles Bronson reportedly had restrictions placed on his phone use after he sent Sky News an unauthorised audio message about his bid for parole.

In recent years, Brand has positioned himself as a Christian influencer and has a large following.

Mia Latter, a woman who has made allegations against Brand, said she found the message shared by Laura Brand on the couple’s Sunday Service show “upsetting” and was appalled to hear “this Christian message alongside absolute lies”.

Latter, 37, has alleged she was raped by the comedian when she was 16. She was not a complainant in his recent criminal trial and he denies her claims.

“I just felt for those women that stood trial and everything they went through,” she told the Today programme this week.

She is one of the women who made allegations against Brand in 2023 as part of a Times, Sunday Times and Channel 4’s Dispatches investigation.

The video and the Brands’ YouTube account are still available on the site, and also still active is Brand’s X account, where a message last appeared on 11 November.

“There was never a Russell Brand, according to @meta,” it read, referring to Meta’s decision to disable Brand’s social media accounts on Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp.

“Thank God for @elonmusk,” the message added, referring to X’s owner, before concluding: “Stay tuned.”

The BBC has approached X for comment; Musk himself has criticised Brand’s conviction for historical sex offences.

Children’s minister Josh MacAlister told the Today programme the Meta decision provided a clear template for taking action.

“Meta’s community standards prohibit accounts owned by or run on behalf of convicted sex offenders, and it’s as simple as that,” he said. “Google should take this down.”

内容来自 Myjoyonline,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

用 HomepageTab 新标签页关注 RSS,打开浏览器就能看到更新。

安装 HomepageTab