Analysis: Big Three converge in Shenzhen for 'mini Yalta'
Chinese President Xi Jinping will host his US and Russian counterparts for an unprecedented trilateral meeting today (Thursday), on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in the southeastern city of Shenzhen. It will bring the leaders of the world’s three major powers together in a way that has never happened before.
In Beijing, Foreign Ministry spokesperson Guo Jiakun said Presidents Xi, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin would have an in-depth exchange of views on global peace, calling the summit one of “groundbreaking significance”. His colleague Mao Ning added that it would be the first face-to-face meeting among the heads of state of China, Russia and the United States. They would explore ways to safeguard global peace and promote strategic stability in major-power relations.
The symbolism was clear even before the meeting. In an unusual gesture, President Xi personally received his US counterpart at Shenzhen Bao'an International Airport on Wednesday, seemingly returning the courtesy Trump showed him in September, when he broke decades of US protocol and greeted Xi at the aircraft during his visit to Washington.
Xi welcomes Trump at Shenzhen airport
Chinese President Xi Jinping on Wednesday welcomed U.S. President Donald Trump at Shenzhen Bao'an International Airport in south China's Guangdong Province.
Trump is in Shenzhen to attend the 33rd Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC)… pic.twitter.com/imaMgdeh1u
— People's Daily, China (@PDChina) November 18, 2026
The rare planeside welcome, which included a fighter-jet flyover trailing rainbow-coloured smoke, drew considerable attention.
“The two most important leaders in the world met at the bottom of the stairs with a handshake and a hug,” Lebanese-Australian commentator Mario Nawfal wrote on micoblogging site X, formerly Twitter.
🇨🇳🇺🇸 Trump arrived in China to fighter jets performing a flyover with rainbow smoke trails, as Xi broke protocol by meeting him directly on the tarmac.
The two most important leaders in the world met at the bottom of the stairs with a handshake and a hug.
The APEC Summit is now…
— Mario Nawfal (@MarioNawfal) November 18, 2026
Later, ahead of the APEC gala reception, the three global heavyweights exchanged greetings and spoke briefly, a moment Russian media described as “a handshake that shakes history”.
Beyond the optics, though, the summit raises a harder question. Can the three powers find common ground in an increasingly volatile world, or will their competing strategic interests reduce the meeting to diplomatic symbolism?
Watch as Trump, Putin, and Xi take part in a family photo at the banquet in Shenzhen, in this historic moment.https://t.co/v3YSEePFur
📺 Sky 501, Virgin 602, Freeview 233 and YouTube pic.twitter.com/0VszWRzShw
— Sky News (@SkyNews) November 18, 2026
For Mushahid Hussain Syed, former chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, the summit matters in three ways. First, he sees it as Washington's first formal acceptance of a multipolar world, an acknowledgement that the US is no longer the sole superpower. Second, he contrasts it with the 1945 Yalta Conference, where Stalin met two Western leaders, saying that China's role as host reflects a changed global order and the rise of Asia as a major centre of power.
Most importantly, Mushahid calls the meeting a “positive development” at a time of conflict and confrontation, because it signals that the major powers are willing to discuss some “rules of the game” for managing global tensions.
Former ambassador Masood Khalid agrees, saying that the summit sets a new precedent for three major global powers to sit down together and discuss pressing international issues.
“If sustained in the future, this format could help ease tensions and manage crises," adds ambassador Khalid, who served longer than any other Pakistani envoy in Beijing.
The meeting takes place against a backdrop of heightened geopolitical and geostrategic volatility. The wars in Ukraine and Iran, growing security uncertainty in the Persian Gulf and Israel’s genocidal campaign in Gaza have all added to global instability, and Trump's unconventional approach to diplomacy has complicated matters further.
The three leaders have arrived in Shenzhen with very different priorities. Trump wants trilateral nuclear talks, while Beijing is keen to present itself as the host of an unprecedented gathering of the three powers. Russia seeks international recognition, Washington is interested in arms control, and Beijing wants greater status in a multipolar world.
As analysts point out, each leader may use the occasion primarily to reiterate established positions rather than negotiate solutions to the pressing global challenges.
On the bilateral front, experts do not expect major breakthroughs on trade, technology or other bilateral issues between Washington and Beijing. Preserving the existing trade truce and preventing relations from deteriorating further are seen as more realistic goals.
Trump's room for manoeuvre may also be limited by pressures at home and abroad. The Republicans’ losses in the US midterm elections have weakened his political position, which could restrict his ability to take bold decisions. Internationally, strained relations with traditional allies, the erosion of the US-led international order, a diminishing emphasis on democratic values and freedoms, and the difficulties of the Iran war have together undermined America’s leverage, resources and global influence.
Khalid says the issues facing the three leaders are too contentious to be settled in a single meeting. "Their differences are stark, with Ukraine, Iran, nuclear proliferation and China’s containment among the issues on which their positions are diametrically opposed," he adds.
Drawing on earlier diplomatic engagements, he points to the Kim Jong Un-Trump summits, which yielded virtually nothing tangible. The Chinese and Russian leaders, he adds, are also sceptical of Trump’s ability to deliver on his promises. “Not much should be expected from the Shenzhen meeting beyond diplomatic optics; substance is likely to remain elusive,” he says.
Former ambassador Sanaullah Abbasi is similarly cautious about expectations. He argues that the meeting’s significance should not be confused with the circumstances that led to the 1945 Yalta Conference.
“The meeting of the three leaders is significant for several reasons, though these may be quite different from the factors that led to the 1945 Yalta Conference. The outcomes, too, are likely to be different. Optically, it will be a major event — a bonanza for photographers — but it may not substantively resolve today’s political challenges,” he adds.
Abbasi believes Putin and Trump have their own disputes to resolve, while Xi will want to keep China out of any military adventure. In his view, Beijing's aim is to gain strategic mileage from the meeting by placing itself at the centre of international diplomacy.
Putin may gain diplomatic stature, Abbasi says, but he doubts the Russian leader can make himself an indispensable partner in any future security architecture beyond Europe. He also warns that any understanding the three powers reach may not be acceptable to Iran and other regional states, which these global powers have not defeated in war.
“At best, a shared understanding among the three leaders could ease tensions and prevent an abrupt escalation of the Iran-US conflict," he says.
On the war in Ukraine, hopes of a breakthrough are slim. Washington is not expected to make the conflict a central item on the trilateral agenda, and Beijing is unlikely to press Moscow to end the war, given its strategic partnership with Russia.
On Iran, Trump may seek support for ending the war and raise nuclear proliferation. But the prospects for substantive US-China cooperation remain uncertain, since Beijing prefers negotiations to sanctions or military action and has limited leverage over both Tehran and Washington.
The US-China relationship is likely to get more immediate attention. Trump and Xi are expected to focus on preserving their fragile trade truce and managing disagreements over tariffs, rare earth supplies, technology restrictions and agricultural purchases, rather than pursuing a sweeping reset.
To sum up, the summit's greatest significance may lie in its symbolism rather than its immediate results. It brings together the leaders of the three most consequential global powers in an unprecedented trilateral setting, at a time when established international arrangements are under considerable strain.
For Xi, hosting the summit strengthens China’s standing as a central player in global diplomacy and boosts its image as a potential broker of international understanding. For Putin, a seat alongside Trump and Xi offers diplomatic recognition and a chance to offset Russia's diplomatic isolation. For Trump, the encounter is a platform to present himself as a global dealmaker who can engage Washington’s principal strategic rivals.
Even without concrete outcomes, the rare summit could establish a new diplomatic format, encourage direct communication among major powers and create channels for managing future crises. Whether that symbolism can turn into sustained dialogue, workable understandings and practical outcomes remains the central test of the Shenzhen summit.
内容来自 The Express Tribune - CHECKED 01/07/2020,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗