'Are your hands clean?': Khawaja Asif hits back at Bilawal over govt criticism

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif on Wednesday hit back at Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari over his criticism of the government and calls for a "political reset", questioning his moral standing to lecture others while pointing to the PPP's 18-year rule in Sindh. “He who claims equity must come with clean hands. This is a centuries-old legal maxim. Are your own hands clean? Do you have the right to lecture others or issue threats?”, said Asif in a post on X. Asif’s remarks came a day after Bilawal delivered a hard-hitting speech at the Karachi Press Club, calling for a “political reset” and criticising the government over its handling of governance and constitutional matters. The PPP chairman had rejected proposals to hold a referendum on the creation of new provinces, questioning the intent behind the move and warning that any attempt to divide Sindh against the wishes of its people could lead to bloodshed. In his response, Asif challenged Bilawal's criticism of the existing political system by drawing attention to the PPP's governance record in Sindh, where the party has been in power for 18 years. "Mr Bilawal, you have had the government in Sindh for 18 years. Sindh has become a paradise. The condition of Karachi city is something the world looks upon with envy," he said sarcastically. Asif also referred to the PPP's partnership with the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) in the federal government since 2022, questioning whether the party was willing to share responsibility for the government's shortcomings. "The profit is yours, while the loss belongs to the PML-N or Pakistan," he said. Asif said no system could be reset without public support and stressed that the people’s right to have a say in the country’s affairs could not be denied. “If you are talking about a system collapse, then, as we are all connected to this system, it is also necessary for us to take stock of our responsibilities," he added. بلاول صاحب آپ نے سسٹم ری سیٹ کی بات کی لیکن کوئی سسٹم اس وقت تک ری سیٹ نہیں ہو سکتا جب تک اُسے عوامی تائید حاصل نہ ھو/اگر آپ system collapse کی بات کر رہے ہیں تو ہم سب کا اس سسٹم سے منسلک ہونے کے ناطے اپنی ذمہ داریوں کا احاطہ بھی ضروری ہے۔ اس ملک میں سیاست دانوں کا احتساب نہ تو… — Khawaja M. Asif (@KhawajaMAsif) November 18, 2026 The defence minister added that accountability of politicians was neither new in Pakistan nor was any politician exempt from it. Asif described Bilawal's speech as "certainly very fiery and focused on criticism" of the ruling government; however, Asif said that political people should refrain from calling the process of turning to the people "a backdoor". “Our foundation as politicians is public opinion. There is no restriction on parliamentary debate and discussion alongside a public referendum,” Asif said. He added that the issue of a “system reset” would certainly be debated in parliament, but this should not deprive the public of their "fundamental right." “If the opinion of the people is also sought alongside parliament, then, in my view, that would be the pinnacle of legitimacy,” the minister added. Read: Bilawal stirs political storm with no-holds-barred speech The defence minister said that the only objective should be to improve the lives of ordinary Pakistanis and ensure that they could live with dignity. “Make public participation in governance a reality. The power of rulers is a trust belonging to the people, not anyone’s inheritance. Do not confine the rights of the people to the pages of the Constitution,” Asif said. Referring to Pakistan’s diplomatic and military achievements, the minister said the country had received honour and respect on both fronts during a particular period in its history, attributing these achievements to the blessings of Allah. “After victories on these two fronts, the battle now is to transfer governance to the street and neighbourhood level, in which the opinion of the people and the role of parliament are entirely democratic and constitutional,” he said. Asif stressed that governance was not the exclusive domain of any individual or political party and that all citizens had a right to participate in the country’s affairs. “Governance is not anyone’s monopoly. This right has been bestowed by Allah upon 250 million people,” he said. Talal Chaudhry also hits back at Bilawal Meanwhile, Minister of State for Interior Talal Chaudhry, addressing a press conference, questioned Bilawal's opposition to a referendum on the creation of new provinces, asking why he feared a public vote if he believed political decisions should be made through the ballot rather than the bullet. “The question is: does casting a vote lead to bloodshed, or does it prevent bloodshed? You have always maintained that decisions should be made through the ballot, not the bullet. So why have you started fearing the vote?” Chaudhry said, referring to Bilawal’s warning that blood would flow in the streets of Sindh if the province was divided. “From law and order to corruption, from health to education, and every other problem that exists in a province, you are saying that the province where all these problems exist should not be divided. Instead, the provinces where governance is the best in Pakistan should be divided,” he said. “In other words, the administrative units where governance is good should be broken up, while those where governance is poor should be allowed to remain intact. Is that what you mean to say?” Chaudhry also challenged Bilawal’s claim that votes on the 27th Constitutional Amendment had been cast under pressure, “You used a term like ‘brutal power’. What you mean by that is that you should remember whether the 1973 Constitution or the 18th Amendment was also passed through votes cast under similar circumstances,” he said. “Or do you think that you can cast your vote in this manner and then, one day, hold a press conference, pretend to be innocent, and convince people that you had nothing to do with it and that you knew nothing about what was happening?” He said Bilawal should similarly vote on the proposed legislation concerning administrative units and later claim it had been passed through “force and brutal power”, adding that “sins are not washed away like this”. The minister referred to Bilawal’s speech in the National Assembly in support of the 27th Amendment, recalling his remarks in which he said that "a constitutional court was Quaid-e-Azam's dream", and had also referred to his late mother's speeches supporting the constitutional courts. “And then you said, ‘This is our legacy. By carrying our legacy forward, we have accomplished today what we had been trying to do for the past fifty years.’” “In other words, this was something the Pakistan Peoples Party had been trying to accomplish, but it had not happened. And you took credit for this entire amendment. Today, you say that the vote was cast through coercion and force,” he said. He accused Bilawal of seeking to retain control over provincial resources and the benefits they generated for the PPP rather than the people living in those provinces. Chaudhry also criticised his warning that “blood would flow in the streets of Sindh.” “In seventeen years of your rule, your governance has drained the blood of Sindhis and the people of Sindh. First, look at whether there is any blood left in them at all,” he added. He accused Bilawal of accepting only part of the Constitution while claiming that the remaining provisions had been “wrongly framed” and were “unconstitutional”. “Democracy is not just about delivering speeches, interpreting the articles of the Constitution, or explaining what the rights of the people are under those articles. Democracy is also about performance. Democracy is also about governance.” He said constitutional provisions had to be implemented in practice in a way that allowed ordinary people to “breathe a sigh of relief”. “And this is precisely why amendments are made, why changes to the Constitution take place: to respond to the needs of the time, the circumstances, and the people, to improve conditions and ensure better governance. Such amendments have continued to take place at different points in time. And this is how the 27th Amendment has also come about,” he said. He added that constitutional changes would continue as circumstances evolved and demanded decisions according to the needs of the time. Politicians respond to Bilawal's address Bilawal’s remarks drew a mixed response from the government and opposition, with several political figures challenging his criticism of the existing system and his position on a referendum. Adviser to the Prime Minister on Political Affairs Rana Sanaullah said the PPP chairman’s comments about the 27th Constitutional Amendment being passed under pressure could provide grounds for his disqualification as a lawmaker. He pointed out that the PPP had been part of the coalition government and had participated in every stage of the legislative process, including the passage of the 26th and 27th amendments. Sanaullah also questioned whether Bilawal was implying that he had cast his vote under someone’s influence, rather than of his own free will. Information Minister Attaullah Tarar, meanwhile, defended the proposed referendum, saying it was a constitutional and legal way to ascertain public opinion on the creation of new provinces. He said the debate on governance and administrative reforms should not be suppressed and questioned why political parties should object to asking people what they wanted. Tarar also reminded Bilawal that the PPP was part of the same government, saying political parties that had been in power for decades could not distance themselves from the weaknesses of the existing system. He further criticised what he called the contradiction of political parties enjoying government positions and privileges while presenting themselves as opposition. Read more: Bilawal's statement on constitutional amendment could lead to 'disqualification', says Sanaullah The opposition response was more supportive of Bilawal’s criticism, though some parties questioned the PPP’s own record. Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam-Fazl (JUI-F) spokesperson Aslam Ghauri welcomed his remarks, saying the PPP chairman had endorsed the party’s position that a referendum was unnecessary where the Constitution already provided a mechanism to resolve an issue. The Tehreek-e-Tahafuz-e-Ain Pakistan (TTAP) also welcomed his comments in principle but said there was a contradiction between the PPP’s words and actions, urging Bilawal to translate his statements into practical steps. PTI, however, said the PPP could not absolve itself of responsibility for the country’s economic and political situation while remaining part of the ruling coalition. Party spokesperson Sheikh Waqas Akram also criticised Bilawal for supporting the 26th Amendment and demanded that the PPP help secure the return of PTI’s reserved seats if it was serious about democratic representation. 28th amendment and proposed referendum The proposed 28th Constitutional Amendment has been discussed in the context of reorganising Pakistan’s administrative structure and creating additional provinces, with reports suggesting a possible plan to divide the country into 12 provinces. One proposal reportedly envisaged dividing Punjab into four provinces, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan into three each, and Sindh into two. However, no final draft or formally approved 28th Amendment has been presented, and the proposal remains part of the political debate. A referendum, meanwhile, is a direct vote in which citizens are asked to express their views on a particular question. The idea of holding one on the creation of new provinces was floated by Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi, who argued that it could help establish public opinion on the issue and settle the debate.

内容来自 The Express Tribune - CHECKED 01/07/2020,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

用 HomepageTab 新标签页关注 RSS,打开浏览器就能看到更新。

安装 HomepageTab