New Provinces Plan or Mere Political Slogan? Asad Umar Poses 6 Questions to Mohsin Naqvi
- English News
- Pakistan News
- Politics
- New Provinces Plan or Mere Political Slogan? Asad Umar…
Published 2 min read
In his X post, the former federal minister said the prime minister and PML-N have not accepted responsibility for the proposal as a party, and the PPP has opposed it, so the only hope for answers to these questions lies with Mohsin Naqvi.
ISLAMABAD, (Pakistan Point News - 18th Nov, 2026) Former finance minister Asad Umar has joined the debate over creating new provinces and administrative units in the country, posing six key questions to Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi. He said that without concrete answers, a decision to create new provinces would be merely a political slogan, not a workable plan.
In a detailed statement on social media platform X, Umar said the entire country had been debating the creation of new provinces for several months, with reports that the powers that be had already made the decision. However, he said, the proposal remained extremely vague and its basic details had not been presented to the public.
Since neither the prime minister nor the PML-N as a party had taken responsibility for the proposal, and the PPP had opposed it, he said the only hope of getting answers to these questions rested with Mohsin Naqvi.
In his first question, Umar noted that administrative units were also being discussed as an alternative to new provinces. He asked the government and relevant stakeholders to clarify the fundamental constitutional and administrative differences between a full-fledged province and an administrative unit under the proposed system.
In his second question, he highlighted the financial burden, asking how much it would cost to create positions for 8 chief ministers, 8 chief secretaries, more than 250 provincial ministers and over 300 provincial secretaries. He also asked where the additional billions of rupees required to buy new aircraft for 8 chief ministers, acquire hundreds of government and luxury vehicles, and establish and run 8 chief ministers’ houses and 8 new civil secretariats would come from.
In his third question, the former finance minister said the government was already weighed down by heavy debt and the number of people living below the poverty line was increasing. He asked how the new administrative expenses could be financed when the IMF would not allow the budget deficit to increase and the public had no capacity to pay further taxes.
In his fourth question, Umar referred to the 1991 water accord, saying it had been reached with great difficulty and disputes between the four provinces over its interpretation and implementation continued to this day. If it had been so difficult to reach consensus among four provinces, he asked, how would agreement on water distribution be reached among the proposed 12 provinces?
In his fifth question, Umar raised the issue of resource distribution, saying the four provinces had been unable to agree on any changes to the seventh NFC Award or a new award for the past 17 years. If the four provinces could not get on the same page, he asked, how could consensus on a new NFC Award be achieved among 12 provinces?
In his sixth and final question, he asked what ordinary citizens would gain from reducing the distance to a provincial capital from under 300 kilometres to 150 kilometres. Could a poor or middle-class resident of Lahore visit the chief secretary’s office today and get their problems resolved, he asked.
Umar said that merely creating new provinces without changing the existing style of governance would not transfer powers to the public, and called for clarity on the practical mechanism for devolving authority to the grassroots level.
PakistanMan Killed, Wife and Young Son Injured in Motorcycle Crash Near Jalalpur Jattan 内容来自 UrduPoint News,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗