Bilawal stirs up 'political hornet’s nest,' calls for political reset and end to ‘revenge politics’

PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari calls for a political reset to restore public trust in parliament and state institutions, demands an end to revenge politics, backs returning PTI’s reserved seats and symbol, rejects a referendum on new provinces and warns against any forced division of Sindh

  • PPP chairman says governance system not collapsed but ‘made to collapse,’ insists reset must begin in parliament

  • Calls for returning PTI’s reserved seats and election symbol as confidence-building measures

  • Rejects referendum on new provinces, warns against any ‘unconstitutional’ move or forced division of Sindh

  • Says political prisoners must be released, acknowledges Imran Khan as a ‘political prisoner’

  • Questions lack of consensus on 27th Amend, urges federal government to engage opposition and Fazl

 KARACHI: Amid a raging debate over a possible system reset and the creation of new provinces, Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari on Tuesday declared that the governance system had not collapsed on its own but had been “made to collapse”, calling for a political reset to correct “injustices” and restore public confidence in state institutions and parliament.

“The proposed solution was not an actual remedy to the illness due to which we suffered a system collapse. Nobody objects that the system has collapsed, but there is no discussion and debate on why it collapsed,” Bilawal emphasised while addressing an event at the Karachi Press Club.

چیئرمین بلاول بھٹو زرداری کا دوٹوک مؤقف! پارلیمان کی مضبوطی کے لیے سیاسی انتقام کا خاتمہ اور ہر رکن کو خوف، دباؤ اور دھمکی سے آزاد ہوکر اپنی رائے دینے، قانون سازی اور ووٹ دینے کا حق یقینی بنانا ضروری ہے۔ آزاد پارلیمان اور اختلافِ رائے کا احترام ہی مضبوط جمہوریت کی بنیاد ہیں۔ https://t.co/qbbJgdTP3j

— 𝐓𝐨𝐟𝐢𝐪𝐮𝐞 𝐁𝐡𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐢 ᭄ᴰᵉᵖᵘᵗʸ ᴵᶰᶠᵒ ˢᵉᶜʳᵉᵗᵃʳʸ (@TofiqueBhatti5) November 17, 2026

He maintained that resolving the underlying causes of the crisis was essential to addressing public concerns, including poverty, unemployment and inflation.

“If we want to focus on resolving the issues of the public, if we want to fight poverty, unemployment, inflation, then we absolutely need to decide why the system collapsed,” he said.

Bilawal asserted that a reset was “definitely needed”, but insisted that it must be political, arguing that the system had not collapsed by itself but had been deliberately made to collapse.

“Why political? Because politicians are the representatives of the people, and if politicians do not play their role, then these fundamental issues won’t be resolved,” he said.

Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has stirred up a political storm after calling for the creation of new administrative units, arguing that the existing governance system had “collapsed” and needed a “reset”.

عالمی حالات اور معاشی بحران نے عام پاکستانی کی زندگی مشکل بنا دی ہے۔ بڑھتی ہوئی مہنگائی، غربت اور بے روزگاری کے باعث عوام شدید مشکلات کا شکار ہیں۔ ایسے وقت میں سیاست کا محور اقتدار نہیں بلکہ عوامی مسائل کا حل ہونا چاہیے۔ عوام کو ریلیف دینا اور ان کی مشکلات کم کرنا وقت کی ضرورت ہے https://t.co/GL1nvSeIpz

— 𝐓𝐨𝐟𝐢𝐪𝐮𝐞 𝐁𝐡𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐢 ᭄ᴰᵉᵖᵘᵗʸ ᴵᶰᶠᵒ ˢᵉᶜʳᵉᵗᵃʳʸ (@TofiqueBhatti5) November 17, 2026

“Everyone makes mistakes, but there comes a time when you must fix those mistakes. How do we fix that?” Bilawal asked rhetorically.

He contended that state institutions had “lost their legitimacy” and called for concerted efforts to restore public confidence in them.

Addressing the ‘Meet the Press’ event and responding to questions afterwards, Bilawal made it clear that the PPP would resist any “unconstitutional” move concerning the creation of new provinces.

He also opposed holding a referendum on the issue, questioning the “intent” behind the proposal, and said his party’s lawmakers were facing “pressure” but would not succumb to it.

Going beyond his oft-repeated calls for electoral reforms and political consensus, the PPP chairman called for the opposition Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) to be given its reserved seats as a “confidence-building measure”.

He also questioned the state of the judiciary, particularly in the wake of the 27th Amendment, which he had strongly advocated at the time of its passage just a year ago.

 ‘Injustices’ to PTI over reserved seats, symbol’

The PPP chairman observed that “some such injustices” had been committed which, if corrected, could quickly help restore the opposition’s confidence in the system.

In an indirect reference to the PTI, Bilawal recalled the revocation of the PPP’s election symbol in 1988, saying: “Revoking the symbol from a party is akin to you joking with the public, and the public denounced this tradition and action and responded to you in those elections.”

Departing from the ruling coalition’s position, Bilawal said that “what happened with the reserved seats was a joke”. He argued that the opposition had not only been deprived of those seats, but that “those in the treasury benches also put them in their pockets”.

The PTI, which was deprived of its reserved seats in the 2024 elections, was declared eligible for the seats by the Supreme Court. However, a constitutional bench constituted later through the 26th Amendment overturned that ruling while hearing review petitions filed by the coalition parties.

“And from those same reserved seats, which are not yours, you brought constitutional amendments not once but twice, and are now thinking to bring a third one,” Bilawal said.

He called for addressing reservations over alleged electoral rigging and restoring the party symbol so that the PTI could retain its political identity.

“It is a confidence-building measure that we, without any preconditions, return the reserved seats to the opposition, which is their right,” Bilawal said, whose PPP was also among the beneficiaries of the reserved seats case.

‘Imran Khan a political prisoner’

Reiterating his demand for electoral reforms, Bilawal stressed the need to restore the PTI’s and the wider opposition’s confidence in parliament.

مخصوص نشستوں کے معاملے میں جس طرح حزبِ اختلاف کو ان کے حق سے محروم رکھا گیا، نہ صرف یہ نشستیں ان سے چھینی گئیں بلکہ انہیں اپنی جیب میں ڈال لیا گیا۔ یہ آخر کون سا نظام ہے؟ یہ جمہوریت نہیں ہے۔ انہی مخصوص نشستوں کی بنیاد پر ایک نہیں بلکہ دو آئینی ترامیم کی گئیں، اور اب تیسری ترمیم پر غور کیا جا رہا ہے۔ میں سمجھتا ہوں کہ دھاندلی سے متعلق اعتراضات دور کرنے کے لیے محنت اور وقت درکار ہوگا، لیکن حزبِ اختلاف کو ان کا انتخابی نشان واپس دلوانا، تاکہ ان کی اپنی سیاسی پہچان اور شناخت برقرار رہے، ایسا اقدام ہے جو اتنا مشکل نہیں ہونا چاہیے۔ اگر حکومت بغیر کسی شرط کے حزبِ اختلاف کو ان کی مخصوص نشستیں، جو ان کا حق ہیں، واپس کر دیتی ہے تو اس سے اعتماد کی بحالی میں مدد مل سکتی ہے۔ کم از کم یہ ایک مثبت پیغام ہوگا کہ حکومت واقعی چاہتی ہے کہ حزبِ اختلاف بھی جمہوری نظام کا حصہ بنے اور تمام سیاسی قوتیں مل کر ملک کو درپیش موجودہ مسائل کا مقابلہ کریں۔ چیئرمین پاکستان پیپلز پارٹی بلاول بھٹو زرداری @BBhuttoZardari

— PPP (@MediaCellPPP) November 17, 2026

“If we want the system to be reset and the Parliament to start functioning, vengeful actions will need to be stopped. How much revenge will you take after all?” he asked.

The PPP chairman said not only should retaliatory actions be halted, but the “tradition of revenge inserted in Pakistan’s politics” must also be ended permanently.

He recalled a speech by PTI founder Imran Khan, in which the latter had questioned whether “we were ants”.

Bilawal called for ensuring that no one remained a political prisoner in Pakistan, saying this was essential for the system to function effectively.

“What a weird country this is; since 1947, whoever becomes the prime minister goes to jail, whoever gets out of jail goes to sit in the Prime Minister House,” he remarked.

“You broke [our] back, then ask ‘why did you fall’,” he quipped, stressing that political prisoners would have to be released.

Asked whether he considered Imran a political prisoner, Bilawal responded in the affirmative.

“A person becomes the prime minister and is later imprisoned. So I can either accept that every prime minister in the country’s history has been a thief, or I can accept that all prime ministers in our history have been victims of political revenge,” he said.

Acknowledging that the PTI had also made mistakes, Bilawal expressed hope that no future prime minister would have to face imprisonment, saying political consensus was essential to achieving that objective.

“One day, I hope no prime minister should have to go to jail, and for that, we need to develop consensus,” he said.

‘Federal govt must decide on reset’

Responding to a question, Bilawal called on the federal government to clearly explain its position on the proposed governance reset.

Outlining his own approach, he said: “The political reset that I spoke of, I will try to develop that consensus, and I would like to create a consensus for it in my own party so that we can engage other political parties.”

As for the federal government’s position, he said: “I don’t know what they are thinking.”

In an apparent reference to the interior minister’s remarks about being on the “same page” as Bilawal, the PPP chairman said: “I had heard we were on the same page, and if this is the page we are on, then nothing could be better.”

He said a debate had been “forced” on the country over the past few months without proper consultation among political stakeholders.

“Even the cabinet had not discussed the matter, let alone the parliament [...] So, how could it be that federal ministers are talking about it of their own accord,” he asked.

Bilawal said he would like to believe that Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif had “enough authority over his own ministers”.

“You are sabotaging your own prime minister, and then you complain that the system has collapsed [...] I believe that is unfair,” he remarked.

In recent days, Defence Minister Khawaja Asif of the PML-N has also advocated the creation of new administrative units, suggesting that the country could have up to 12 provinces.

Bilawal maintained that the PPP would welcome a debate and consensus on the matter, but hinted that genuine deliberation and agreement might not be on the agenda.

He said proposals were being floated from outside parliament, which, in his view, offered a “clear indication [...] that the opinion of Parliament, public, and cabinet did not hold any weight and you just want to use a backdoor channel”.

“Up until today, neither the prime minister nor a single member of the provinces has brought up the issue with the president of Pakistan or me,” he added.

On the possibility of rolling back the 18th Amendment, Bilawal pointed out that the Sindh government was providing the Centre with a surplus of Rs585 billion in financial support.

“Donations worth Rs260b were given in security and national interest,” he said.

“I am not even counting the rightful share of the province — of petroleum levy and gas levy — it is about Rs1.7 trillion from the petroleum levy,” he added.

He criticised the Centre, saying: “So, you will pickpocket the province, loot our resources and then come and ask us, ‘why the roads are broken and why no schools or hospitals have been built’.”

Bilawal argued that if a province was contributing a surplus of Rs585 billion, Rs260 billion for national security and Rs1.7 trillion through the petroleum levy, the federal government should be held responsible for inadequate public spending rather than the provincial administration.

He also claimed that the “easiest way to do corruption in Pakistan was to be on the state’s right side”.

 ‘Referendum has never been democratic’

Reacting to the interior minister’s proposal for holding a referendum on the creation of administrative units, Bilawal questioned the intent behind the suggestion.

“In our history, a referendum has always been carried out for an undemocratic act and never a democratic one,” the PPP chairman remarked.

He argued that since the Constitution contained relevant provisions for creating administrative units, proposing a referendum indicated that an unconstitutional route was being considered.

Bilawal vowed that his party would firmly oppose any such “unconstitutional” move.

He also rejected any “forced division” of Sindh, cautioning that although the PPP supported the creation of provinces, it would resist any attempt to impose a division on the province.

“We talk about the garbage on Karachi’s streets, but if Sindh is divided, we will see blood flow through its streets,” he warned.

Asked whether a compromise could be reached on the creation of new provinces, Bilawal recalled that the Sindh Assembly had passed several resolutions opposing the division of the province.

“Any more discussion on this issue is a slap to the people of Sindh,” he declared.

“I do not understand what Mohsin bhai is trying to do,” he added.

Responding to another question about new provinces and a possible system reset, Bilawal said the PML-N-led government had not discussed the matter with the PPP, questioning why the issue was being “made to discuss by the media”.

He said he had invited Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif to hold discussions with the Sindh government on public issues and had also suggested that the prime minister convene cabinet meetings in each province.

‘Pressure on PPP lawmakers’

Reiterating the PPP’s position on the creation of new provinces, Bilawal said that, as a politician from a political family spanning generations, he wanted decisions to reflect the wishes of the people.

“Those from whom these suggestions are coming, they have not won even a single election in their lives. And neither do they have chances in the next election … they would become a minister, prime minister or chief minister whether they get a single vote or not in the next elections,” he said, adding that political stakeholders were taking positions according to their own circumstances.

Responding to another question, Bilawal said that although no formal discussions were under way, PPP lawmakers were facing pressure over the issue.

“On the one hand, there are no discussions ongoing; on the other hand, there definitely is pressure on the party’s MNAs and MPAs, but PPP’s representatives do not function on someone else’s pressure, but the public’s,” he said.

He further remarked: “If tomorrow, my software is updated and I direct my party to vote for Sindh’s division, there will be a revolt against me. They will not cast a majority vote even on my directives.”

He quipped that “some people were dreaming of becoming the chief minister of their area, but they would not even be able to remain their house’s chief minister”.

The PPP chairman also reaffirmed that his party would not “back any conspiracy against Punjab”, adding that it would support only those decisions endorsed by the Punjab Assembly.

He pointed out that there had been little discussion on granting provincial status to Gilgit-Baltistan, despite what he described as a consensus in the region in favour of the demand.

‘27th Amendment passed with brute majority’

Turning to the judiciary, Bilawal said that the PPP’s longstanding aspiration for a constitutional court, as envisaged in the Charter of Democracy, had been fulfilled, but questioned whether the new judicial arrangement enjoyed public confidence.

“If the lawyers and judges themselves do not have confidence in the courts, then the system did not collapse, but was made to collapse,” he said.

The PPP chairman clarified that he was not calling for the reversal of the changes but for building broader political consensus around them.

He maintained that the 26th Amendment had been passed through a “bilateral agreement, if not complete consensus”, as opposition input had been incorporated through Maulana Fazlur Rehman.

However, he said the 27th Amendment had been “passed neither through political consensus nor bilateral agreement; it was passed with brute majority”.

Bilawal called for engaging the opposition in discussions on judicial reforms, describing this as essential to a “political, public and democratic reset”. Without such a reset, he argued, the country would struggle to address pressing public concerns, including inflation and unemployment.

He also highlighted the recurring allegations of electoral rigging, saying such accusations were usually levelled by opposition parties against the government, which would deny them.

“I have been in politics for the past 20 years, and usually, I have seen that it is the opposition that accuses the other side of rigging and the government denies it. For the first time, I am seeing that people from within the government are claiming that rigging has been done,” he said.

‘JUI-F chief has right to criticise govt’

Bilawal also defended Jamiat Ulema-i-Islam-Fazl (JUI-F) chief Maulana Fazlur Rehman amid escalating tensions between him and the government in recent weeks.

Over the past month, Fazl and federal ministers have exchanged harsh remarks after the JUI-F chief accused the Centre of depriving the provinces of their constitutional rights.

The developments followed Fazl’s decision to join the opposition in criticising the Centre’s imposition of governor’s rule and emergency measures in the PTI-governed Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. He also accused the federal government of reneging on its commitments during his efforts to mediate between the Centre and the KP government.

Addressing the issue, Bilawal said it was the opposition’s constitutional and democratic role in parliament to criticise the government.

“It is the opposition’s right to criticise you, and however he (Fazl) does it, it is their right,” he said.

Bilawal described the opposition’s role in parliament as the “most patriotic” one.

“For any government to question the patriotism of an opposition member [...] it is not only an injustice to that parliament or to the system, but the biggest injustice to the country,” he added.

The PPP chairman described differences of opinion within parliament as the “beauty and strength of democracy”.

اپوزیشن کی ذمہ داری ہے کہ وہ حکومت پر تنقید کرے۔ حکومت پر تنقید کرنا اپوزیشن کا جمہوری حق ہے، چاہے وہ تنقید کسی بھی انداز میں کرے۔ یہی جمہوریت کا حسن ہے کہ حکومت سے سوال کیے جائیں اور اس کا احتساب ہو۔ بالآخر آئندہ انتخابات میں فیصلہ عوام نے کرنا ہے کہ کون درست تھا اور کون غلط۔ لیکن افسوس کی بات یہ ہے کہ اپوزیشن کی تقریر کے دوران ہی حکومت کو یہ خیال آنے لگے کہ کسی کا گھر تجاوزات کی زد میں آتا ہے۔ یہی طرزِ حکمرانی اور یہی طرزِ عمل دراصل سسٹم کولیپس ہے۔ چیئرمین پاکستان پیپلز پارٹی بلاول بھٹو زرداری @BBhuttoZardari

— PPP (@MediaCellPPP) November 17, 2026

Reiterating his call for a political reset, Bilawal said the process must begin in parliament.

“If we want to reset the system, a political reset has to happen; it should begin from the parliament,” he said.

He acknowledged that the opposition had lost confidence in the system and said all political stakeholders needed to work towards restoring it.

“They genuinely have reasons to have lost confidence in the working of the Parliament, and we all have to regain this trust,” he said.

“The government cannot expect the opposition to clap along with every one of the government’s decisions,” he remarked.

Bilawal again claimed that the “easiest way to do corruption in Pakistan was to be on the state’s right side”.

He alleged that opposition figures were subjected to selective accountability and other forms of pressure when they criticised the government.

“When someone from the opposition makes a speech [...] then all of a sudden, you set the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) on them, arrest their sons; there was no such realisation before,” he said.

“Now, all of a sudden, there is encroachment (around their house),” he added, in an apparent reference to the Capital Development Authority’s (CDA) recent notice regarding “unauthorised construction” at the JUI-F chief’s residence.

“This is why the system has collapsed [...] you are making it collapse,” Bilawal said, urging the federal government to engage with Fazl.

On the question of governor’s rule in KP, Bilawal acknowledged that the PPP had its governor in the province but stressed that the arrangement could not continue indefinitely.

“If you are yourself saying that the majority of them (PTI) were ready but one or two people sabotaged the talks, then what is stopping the government from approaching the opposition again?” he asked, recalling remarks by the “minister for everything”.

“If the PTI is ready to fight against terrorism together with you, then the governor’s rule can also be ended,” Bilawal said, describing this as another way to rebuild the opposition’s confidence in the system.

内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅