Would Bilawal Bhutto Talk of Assembly Rigging If Provinces Were Not at Issue? Shahzad Iqbal
- English News
- Pakistan News
- Politics
- Would Bilawal Bhutto Talk of Assembly Rigging If Provinces…
Published 3 min read
Senior journalist Shahzad Iqbal questioned whether Bilawal Bhutto would still say that reserved seats should be returned, political prisoners should be released and talks held with the opposition if the issue of provinces were not at stake. “Where were these statements earlier?” he said, adding that when there is benefit from the system, they take it, and when they see the guns pointed their way, they become “democratic.”
ISLAMABAD, (Pakistan Point News - 17th Nov, 2026) Senior journalist Shahzad Iqbal said political parties benefit from the system when it suits them and become democratic when they feel its guns are pointed at them. He said the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) had contradictions in its positions on the creation of provinces and the democratic process.
If the issue of provinces were not at stake today, he asked, would Bilawal Bhutto be talking about alleged rigging in the assembly, the return of reserved seats, the release of political prisoners and talks with the opposition? “Where were these things before?” he asked. Speaking on Geo News’ programme Report Card, Iqbal said he agreed with some points, particularly the claim that the system had been undermined.
Pakistan’s history, he said, showed that the system had been damaged through martial law and governor’s rule.
Iqbal said the Constitution sets out a procedure for creating provinces and that it should be followed. The issue requires extensive consultation because it is not a minor matter, he said. A legal expert he had spoken to the previous day said at least 190 constitutional provisions would need to be reviewed. Iqbal said everyone’s views should be sought, but the process was being kept secret and little information was being shared.
He said Bilawal had contradictions in several other statements. Bilawal had said Karachi had a garbage problem and that creating provinces would lead to bloodshed, adding that he did not want bloodshed. Iqbal questioned whether making such a statement was democratic, saying that discussions about creating provinces with the PPP quickly turned emotional.
Recalling an earlier experience, Iqbal said he had spoken to Nisar Khuhro in 2019 or 2020 and asked whether the creation of more provinces in Sindh, or making Karachi a province, could be discussed on merit rather than on an ethnic basis. Khuhro gave his answer, he said, but a campaign then followed against him and Geo as a whole, demanding an apology for even discussing whether Karachi should become a province.
Iqbal said such arguments were emotional rather than democratic. He asked what evidence there was that creating a province would lead to bloodshed, urging those opposed to explain their case through arguments and constitutional principles, or say that the proposal lacked merit. There was no need, he said, to frighten or intimidate people with predictions of violence.
Discussing law and order in Karachi, Iqbal asked how the PPP could blame the federal government for its own shortcomings. He said some people linked street crime in Karachi to worsening national conditions and the economy, which could push people towards crime and theft. While acknowledging a connection to the economy, he said the provincial government could not absolve itself of responsibility: maintaining law and order was its duty.
Iqbal said he had been hearing for the past 15 years that a Safe City project would be established in Karachi and asked where it was. Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, which he said was considered less developed than Karachi, had launched Safe City projects in three or four districts, while Punjab had them in nine or 10 districts.
He said the annual development programme (ADP) plan for the current year was worth 400 billion rupees, and asked why Karachi’s project had still not been established after years of promises and whether the federal government was expected to do it.
He said that when the provincial government in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa had also called on the federal government over law and order, the PPP had supported imposing governor’s rule there.
Criticising the PPP’s political position, Iqbal said the party benefited from the system when it suited it, but adopted a democratic stance when it felt under threat.
He said the PPP was in government in three provinces, held the presidency and had the Senate chairmanship, yet claimed that the 2024 Assembly was rigged. He asked how the party could make that claim after introducing two major constitutional amendments that had effectively turned the Assembly into a constituent assembly. The party was now calling for an investigation into alleged rigging, he said.
Iqbal also questioned the PPP’s stance on reserved seats, saying it had called for them to be returned to the opposition. He asked whether the PPP could say how many seats it had “put in its pocket,” adding that, as far as he knew, the party had gained four to five seats in the National Assembly. He asked whether the party had failed to notice this at the time, when others were saying the Constitution was not being implemented.
He said the PPP had previously faced the PTI and now the JUI-F, and might expect to face the provinces issue itself in the future. The party spoke in its own interest and took advantage of the system when it suited it, he said.
Iqbal also asked how many political prisoners the PPP had previously spoken up for, given its current call for their release. He said the party had claimed that Mohsin Naqvi and other ministers were discussing the issue but were not in control, and asked why it had not raised the prospect of governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa when Faisal Karim Kundi was the province’s governor.
In conclusion, Iqbal asked whether Bilawal Bhutto would be talking about alleged assembly rigging, returning reserved seats, releasing political leaders and negotiating with the opposition if the issue of provinces were not at stake. “Where were these things before?” he asked.
内容来自 UrduPoint News,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗