Minister! Without Information, Without Knowledge

  1. English News
  2. Pakistan News
  3. Politics
  4. Minister! Without Information, Without Knowledge

Published 2 min read

PPP leader Syeda Shehla Raza responds to Attaullah Tarar, saying the PPP holds constitutional offices but is not part of the cabinet; she adds there is no ambiguity in the Constitution and this matter is not subject to a referendum. She says a minister gives government policies, not personal opinions—calling it ignorance and an open contradiction.

ISLAMABAD, (Pakistan Point News - 17th Nov, 2026) Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) MNA Syeda Shehla Raza said Information Minister Attaullah Tarar appeared to lack information and knowledge, saying the PPP holds constitutional offices but is not part of the cabinet. In a post on X responding to Tarar’s statement, she wrote: “Minister… without information, without knowledge.”

Raza said Tarar did not know that the PPP held constitutional offices, supported the government but was not part of it, and that the Constitution had clarified the matter without ambiguity. She added that it was not a matter for a referendum.

“A minister presents the government’s policies, not personal opinions. Is this not ignorance and an open contradiction?” she asked.

Meanwhile, Federal Information Minister Attaullah Tarar said an agenda could not be imposed on anyone without knowing the people’s wishes, and asked what was wrong with holding a referendum. He said it was not political wisdom to turn smaller administrative units into a source of conflict or talk of bloodshed. If a referendum had been conducted undemocratically in the past, he asked, could the public now be deprived of its democratic right?

Speaking to the media in response to PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto’s statement, Tarar said that “you and all of us” had been part of the system for decades and could not now distance themselves from its shortcomings. He said the law and the public rejected the suggestion, made under the cover of politics, that anyone was exempt from accountability.

He said the government had itself introduced reforms to the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) but was now blaming the bureau, calling this difficult to understand. Enjoying the benefits of government while also acting as the opposition, and holding protocol and positions at the same time, was a contradiction and a double standard, he said.

The information minister said the underlying issue behind the current discussion appeared to be the ongoing debate about the provinces. The debate was taking place openly among the public, he said, asking whether people should be silenced and prevented from discussing it or from calling for better governance.

Tarar said the issue would be discussed both inside and outside parliament. People could not be stopped from speaking with the public or discussing their welfare, he said, adding that democratic and political processes required the debate to continue.

He said the central question was what the problem was with taking the matter to the public. The decision about what people wanted was not for him or others to make, but for the people, he said, adding that no political party should have reservations about going to the public.

The federal information minister said a referendum was part of the Constitution and that seeking public opinion through it was a constitutional and legal process. The people were the ultimate decision-makers, he said, adding that good governance was part of every political party’s manifesto and that no party disagreed with it.

He said that if the people of Pakistan and Sindh wanted more provinces, they should be created; otherwise, they should not. Public representatives came from the people, not the other way around, he said, adding that the public were the ultimate decision-makers.

Tarar said it would be better to consider smaller administrative units constructively rather than turn them into a source of conflict. He asked whether talking about bloodshed over the issue reflected political wisdom and maturity. If a referendum had previously been used in an undemocratic manner, he asked, could that now be used as a pretext to deprive people of their democratic right?

He said an agenda could not be imposed on anyone without knowing the wishes of the people of Sindh and the views of all the other provinces. They were part of the same government, he said, and should sit together to make the best decision for public welfare and the national interest, based on the people’s opinion.

Related topics SindhPakistanNational Accountability BureauInformation MinisterParliamentShehla RazaPakistan Peoples PartyPostMedia
Sanaullah Nagra
Next story Trump Arrives in Manila Ahead of Key China Visit as Protests Continue for Fifth DayPakistanTrump Arrives in Manila Ahead of Key China Visit as Protests Continue for Fifth Day

内容来自 UrduPoint News,版权归原作者所有。

阅读原文 ↗

把喜欢的内容,留在你的新标签页。

打开我的订阅