AI firms turning books into toilet paper, committee told
Updated / Tuesday, 17 Nov 2026 16:10
AI companies are ripping apart books and turning them into toilet paper, an Oireachtas committee has heard.
The Committee on Artificial Intelligence heard this morning from writers and artists concerned about the impact AI will have on their livelihoods and on Ireland's cultural landscape.
Conor Kostick from the Irish Writers Union accused tech companies of ransacking centuries of book publishing, and destroying books in their race to train AI.
The writer told the committee that tech giants have bought around two million books through second-hand and antique booksellers around the world.
Mr Kostick said old, rare, and out-of-commerce titles are then "subject to bulk scanning and being destroyed in the process".
He said within what he described as "AI scan factories" in the US, the spines are cut from a book so its pages can be fed through high-speed scanners before the remaining physical copy is "discarded, shredded, and recycled into toilet paper".
Mr Kostick said the digitised files are then "exploited for the development of large language models".
"Many such books will never be found again and will exist solely as the digital property of an AI tech company," he said.
The Irish Writers Union, the committee heard, wants to see rare books protected from this practice.
Mr Kostick said UNESCO considers the systematic destruction of books to be a "serious breach of the Hague Convention", adding that the majority of their members do not want their works used in AI training.
There has been a tsunami of AI books flooding the market, he said, and asked readers on the committee how they would feel if they found out a book they were reading was created by AI.
The IWU has also called for remuneration, regulation of how their works are used, and robust enforcement of copyright legislation.
The committee heard that AI-generated products that imitate novels, poems and essays do not have to be mandatorily labelled.
Call for 'fair playing field'
Mr Kostick said around half a million AI books have been published on Amazon and are being "passed off" as being written by humans, adding that books which are 100% human-made should be distinguishable from AI-assisted books.
Writers are simply calling for a "fair playing field", he added.
The Chairperson of The Praxis Artists Union, Robbie Kitt, told the committee AI models are scraping free and publicly available material from galleries, archives and museums for training.
The musician and DJ said publicly funded institutions are now under acute pressure due to the flood of automated bot traffic.
Mr Kitt said vital energy goes into creative works which provide depth and meaning to humankind.
"AI companies are seeking to transfer this vital energy into profit," he said, adding that the implication of this go beyond arts and culture.
"It's something we should take profoundly seriously," he said.
The CEO of Visual Artists Ireland Noel Kelly, acknowledged that AI can "produce remarkable results".
However, he said: "Producing something and creating something are not the same thing."
He added: "We shouldn't confuse output with the human experience of making it, nor should we minimise the necessity for protecting the existing and future rights of artists.
"Artists are not trying to stop progress. We're not here to smash the machines.
"Artists want to know whether our work has been used to train AI systems, by whom, and on what basis."
Mr Kelly asked how individual artists are expected to challenge large technology companies.
"Knowing that rights exist is quite different from being able to exercise them - and an individual artist does not have a large legal team to tackle this on their behalf," he said.
Mr Kelly said Generative AI adds further pressures on visual artists facing financial uncertainty.
He said: "We don't need to choose between technological progress and human creativity.
"But we do need to consider how the benefits of that progress are shared, who might be left behind, and what safeguards need to be in place."
Mr Kelly said artists have always "played a role in questioning and interpreting the world around them".
"That's something society needs, particularly during periods of significant change," he said.
Independent senator Alice-Mary Higgins said "things that are part of our collective cultural heritage" are "being pulped".
Meanwhile, Fianna Fáil TD Malcom Byrne said AI is a tool, "and we need to see it as a tool".
However, he said intellectual property is creativity, and how we measure this in a new world will be critical.
More stories on
内容来自 RTE,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗