Federal Constitutional Court orders pension restoration and arrears for Punjab Road Transport employees
The court said restoration periods under the 1963 Pension Rules depend on employees’ ages, not a universal 15-year rule. It also ordered payment of arrears and annual increases due for previous years.
ISLAMABAD, (Pakistan Point News - 17th Nov, 2026) The Federal Constitutional Court has ruled that an incorrect judicial decision cannot be relied upon as a precedent in subsequent cases under Article 25 of the Constitution, and ordered the restoration of withheld pensions of Punjab Road Transport employees in accordance with their ages and the relevant pension rules.
The Federal Constitutional Court issued a 20-page written judgment in a case concerning the pensions of Punjab Road Transport employees. The judgment was authored by Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi.
Setting aside the decisions of the Lahore High Court’s division bench and single bench, the court directed that the restoration of the employees’ pensions be determined in accordance with their ages and the applicable pension rules. It also ordered the payment of pension arrears and annual increases due to the employees for previous years.
The written judgment observed that the 1963 Pension Rules did not prescribe any universal principle requiring the restoration of pension after 15 years. Depending on the age of an employee, the applicable restoration period could be shorter or longer than 15 years. Therefore, each case must be decided in light of the relevant rules and the employee’s age.
According to the judgment, the employees had opted for a golden handshake in 1977. Under the agreement, they were to receive a lump-sum payment equivalent to 15 years of half pension, while the remaining half was to be paid monthly. It was also agreed that the remaining half of their pension would be restored after 15 years.
The employees contended that their pensions were due for restoration in 2012, but the department restored them in 2017. Consequently, they were not paid the outstanding pension arrears and annual increases.
The Federal Constitutional Court held that an erroneous judicial decision cannot be upheld merely because it has previously been treated as a precedent, nor can such a decision be relied upon as a precedent in future cases.
内容来自 UrduPoint News,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗