KP inquiry finds no evidence of illegal felling among 362 trees in Shamsher Valley
A Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Forest Department committee said the trees in Battagram’s Compartment No. 8 were marked and felled under an approved plan. It recommended separate investigations into unresolved local incidents and the circulation of a viral video.
PESHAWAR, (Pakistan Point News - 17th Nov, 2026) Allegations of illegal tree felling in the forests of Shamsher Valley in Allai tehsil of Battagram district have been declared unfounded, with a high-level fact-finding inquiry confirming that the cutting of all 362 trees was carried out in accordance with the approved record and prescribed departmental procedures.
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Forest Department in a statement here Tuesday said the inquiry committee found no evidence of unauthorized or illegal tree felling in compartment No. 8 of guzara forest at Shamsger Valley at district Batagram, contrary to allegations circulating on social media.
Physical inspection confirmed the stumps, markings and departmental records of all 362 trees, while allegations of collusion or negligence on the part of forest department officials could not be substantiated.
The three-member fact-finding committee, constituted by the forest department, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, conducted a detailed inspection of the forest compartment on November 11, 2026, following allegations and a viral social media video showing timber in the area.
The committee was constituted under Office Order No. 26, dated November 8, 2026, issued by the Office of the Chief Conservator of Forests, Northern Forest Region-II, Abbottabad. It was headed by Conservator of Forests Rais Khan, with Divisional Forest Officer Torghar Ijazur Rehman and Divisional Forest Officer, Patrol Squad, Shah Fahad, as members.
All 362 trees physically verified. According to the inquiry report, the marking of trees in gunter guzara forest was carried out under the approved revised working plan for Allai Valley for the period 2016-17 to 2025-26.
DFO Battagram, had formally marked a total of 362 trees on April 7, 2024, with an estimated volume of approximately 147,689 cubic feet.
The marking had been duly approved by the competent authorities of the Forest Department. An independent monitoring team of the forest planning and monitoring circle, Peshawar had also declared the marking process satisfactory in its report dated March 12, 2025, raising no objections.
During the physical inspection, the inquiry committee examined the stumps of all 362 trees and cross-checked their felling numbers, marking numbers, species, diameters and other technical particulars against the original approved record.
The report stated that no discrepancy was found between the approved marking list and the trees felled in the compartment.
The committee also inspected the surrounding and adjoining forest areas but found no evidence of freshly cut unmarked trees, illegal felling or any unreported damage.
The committee also examined the viral social media video in the light of departmental records and ground realities.
According to the report, the timber shown in the video had been obtained from trees felled under the approved marking. Its temporary storage at different locations inside the forest and along a traditional timber transportation route locally known as Patro was attributed to the closure of the access road, which prevented its immediate transportation.
Departmental records showed that approximately 70,886.24 cubic feet of timber had been extracted during the operation launched in November 2025. Of this, 20,111 cubic feet had already been transported to the designated roadside depot at Nogran Kas, while the remaining timber was awaiting transportation from the forest, Patro and other temporary locations.
The report stated that after restoration of the road, the remaining timber would be transported through the prescribed procedure to the Nogran Kas depot and subsequently to the main timber depot at Goharabad, Haveliyan.
Following the relevant monitoring and measurement procedures, the timber would be sold through a transparent open auction.
It said no collusion or negligence by Forest Department staff established. The inquiry committee also examined the role of field staff, the Joint Forest Management Committee (JFMC) and other forest department officials.
According to the report, available documentary and physical evidence did not establish any involvement, collusion or deliberate negligence on the part of departmental officials or JFMC members in illegal tree felling.
The committee observed that tree felling in the forest was scattered and consistent with the principles of approved scientific forest management. Unmarked seed-bearing trees and trees essential for natural regeneration had been preserved.
The report also referred to local disputes, including the closure of an access route, damage to an electricity transformer and the reported burning of approximately 774 cubic feet of timber.
However, the committee clarified that these incidents and the allegations surrounding them could not be conclusively verified within the scope of the present inquiry and recommended separate independent investigations.
It recommended that the competent authorities initiate a preliminary departmental inquiry into the conduct of two wildlife department employees, namely Fazal Wahab, Range Forest Officer (Wildlife), and Sartaj, Head Watcher.
The proposed inquiry would determine whether they had exceeded their official authority, interfered in the legal affairs of the Forest Department or engaged in any other inappropriate conduct.
The committee stressed that any departmental action must be based on verifiable evidence, fulfilment of legal requirements and provision of a full opportunity to the concerned officials to defend themselves.
It also recommended referring the matter relating to the production and circulation of the viral video to the relevant Cybercrime Investigation Wing of the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) for further investigation.
The proposed investigation would establish the video's original context, authenticity of its contents, possible dissemination of misleading information and the potential involvement of any other party.
The committee emphasized that responsibility should be assigned to any individual only on the basis of verifiable evidence.
In its recommendations, the inquiry committee emphasized that forest conservation should not remain confined to administrative measures but should be developed into a sustainable system through the active participation of local communities and forest owners.
It proposed regulating access to areas where forestry operations were underway and ensuring transparency in visits by media representatives and social activists. Such visits should be facilitated in the presence of the relevant Forest Department officer and an authorized JFMC representative.
The committee further recommended that, after completion of felling operations, the concerned compartment should be protected and prepared for natural regeneration.
Measures should also be taken to prevent grazing, forest fires, illegal timber extraction and other damaging activities, alongside additional plantation of indigenous tree species suited to the local environment.
It also called for creating employment opportunities, providing basic facilities, promoting ecotourism, ensuring equitable economic benefits and encouraging community-based conservation initiatives for local populations dependent on forests.
The report also recommended reviewing the role and communication strategy of the media cell of the Climate Change, Forestry, Environment and Wildlife Department.
According to the committee, instead of issuing immediate responses to viral videos or environmental allegations, authorities should first verify ground realities, examine relevant records and obtain information from all stakeholders to ensure that accurate, authentic and balanced information reaches the public.
In its final findings, the inquiry committee concluded that the marking and felling of trees in Compartment No. 8 of Gunter guzara forest had been carried out under the approved working plan, competent departmental approvals, independent monitoring and prescribed procedures.
Based on the available evidence, neither illegal tree felling, excessive marking of trees nor collusion by Forest Department officials could be established.
The report also highlighted the importance of relying on ground realities, authentic documentation and independent investigations before forming opinions on allegations, claims or viral content concerning sensitive national assets such as forests.
Forest conservation is a collective responsibility; however, fulfilling this responsibility also requires ensuring that neither trees are harmed nor innocent individuals are falsely accused, and that rumours never take precedence over facts in decision-making.
APP/fam
内容来自 UrduPoint News,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗