Laws remain headline act despite weekend of excitement
Another week of international rugby matches has brought yet another distraction and focus on the laws rather than the quality of rugby on display.
In a week where South Africa and New Zealand have both been beaten by northern hemisphere opposition, the public discourse has been focusing on a hip drop tackle and subsequent citing for Ireland's Sam Prendergast.
There is little argument that the hip drop tackle needs to be eradicated from the game. The potential for injury is significant, and World Rugby is right to take action to protect players. However, as another change to the laws surrounding tackle technique comes into effect, there is a question about how quickly players can realistically adapt to what is being asked of them.
The new hip drop tackle law was implemented early in November, meaning it arrived in the middle of the season.
The definition is relatively straightforward. A hip drop tackle occurs when a ball carrier is tackled from the side or behind, the tackler swings around or through them, and subsequently drops their hips or bodyweight onto the ball carrier's legs or lower limbs as they are brought to ground.
The action is now explicitly illegal, with a penalty the minimum sanction. More serious examples, involving greater contact with the lower limbs, can result in a yellow or red card.
The intention behind the change is understandable. Player welfare has to remain at the forefront of decisions made by the game's governing bodies, particularly when a specific action carries such a clear risk of serious injury.
The objective might be straightforward, implementing the change in the real world of rugby is considerably more complicated.
One of the difficulties with some of these law changes is that they are attempting to change human behaviour rather than a player's decision-making process.
There is an important distinction between a player deliberately carrying out an illegal action and a player finding themselves in a position where their natural reaction results in an offence. In many instances, the latter is what coaches and players are trying to understand and address.
Many are in agreement that in order to change behaviour, there will be some instances where it feels harsh to penalise or sanction the player. With any of the recent law changes, the shock regarding decisions reduces over time and many accept the stricter sanctions in order for the game to become safer.
The introduction of the sternum-height tackle at AIL level provided a good example of this. There were plenty of occasions when players found themselves penalised for high tackles, despite having no intention of making contact above the sternum.
It took time for players to understand the situations in which they were most vulnerable. A defender chasing hard across the pitch in a scramble situation, for example, could find that an attacking player stepped inside them at the last moment. The defender's momentum and body position made it extremely difficult to adjust their height in time.
It was not necessarily a case of poor technique or a deliberate decision to tackle high. It was a reaction to a situation that had developed in a split second.
Changing that reaction required players to recognise the circumstances that were putting them at risk and gradually adapt their approach. Most wingers would now approach a scramble tackle situation with more foot control and would most likely show the opposition the outside so they can't step in.
Nobody sets out to make a hip drop tackle. More often than not, the situation develops because a defender has missed the initial collision or failed to get the contact they wanted. It might also occur when there is a significant difference in size between the tackler and ball carrier, with a smaller defender struggling to deal with a more powerful opponent.
It is most likely to happen when a defender has the best intentions of making a proper tackle that has not gone according to plan. Rather than accepting that the ball carrier has broken through, there is an instinctive reaction to finish the job, whatever way possible. That does not make the action safe or acceptable, but it does help explain why it happens.
The difficulty with implementing a new tackle law during the season is that it doesn’t allow time to change behaviour. Time is needed to develop the thought process and training situations to minimise the chances of these types of tackles happening. This law in particular needs full contact to mimic the same situation.
Players will only really find themselves in that scenario during full contact training, which is used sparingly in the training week nowadays. In a congested period of the season, contact is minimised as much as possible. Contact can be reduced to a lower level while working on tackle height and footwork on entry into the tackle, but this hip drop law will only be practiced if players lose real collisions.
However, when they do miss that initial collision, the reaction that follows is not always something they have consciously planned. It is an instinctive response in a physically demanding environment, where players have very little time to make adjustments.
This is where the challenge for coaches becomes particularly interesting. It is not enough to show players a video of an illegal hip drop tackle and tell them not to do it. They need to understand the situations that lead to the action in the first place. That process will take repetition, education and time.
It is understandable that the change caught plenty of people by surprise. While the dangers associated with the hip drop tackle were not new, its inclusion in the laws has forced players and coaches to reconsider some of the movements that can occur during a tackle.
The objective is right, to make the game safer and to protect players against career-ending injuries. Peceli Yato was injured as a result of the tackle. Most sympathy will be directed at him, although some will be preserved for Sam Prendergast in this situation as well.
This is a newer law change with little time to adapt. The details of this law also pertain to speed of the ball carrier, control of the tackler and the significance of the contact. Due to the less dynamic nature of the tackle, it’s assumed that Sam Prendergast will be free to play against South Africa this weekend, though this is new and less familiar territory for all involved.
内容来自 RTÉ - Sport,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗