FCC restores PHC’s powers to hear Article 199 cases, ‘except in three categories’
The Federal Constitutional Court has modified its November 5 order, allowing the Peshawar High Court to hear Article 199 cases, except those involving 3-MPO detentions, emergency and governor’s rule. Meanwhile, the KP government insists military deployment remains necessary across the province
PHC allowed to resume constitutional cases except 3-MPO detentions, emergency and governor’s rule matters
KP govt tells FCC military deployment remains indispensable across entire province
Barrister Gohar disappointed, says order fails to provide relief to detained PTI workers
ISLAMABAD: The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) on Monday modified its November 5 order, allowing the Peshawar High Court (PHC) to resume hearing all cases instituted under Article 199 of the Constitution, except those relating to Section 3 of the Maintenance of Public Order (3-MPO), and the imposition of an emergency and the enforcement of governor’s rule in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP).
A two-member FCC bench, comprising Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan and Justice Aamir Farooq, issued the four-page order while hearing an appeal filed by the KP government against interim orders of the PHC directing executive authorities to release hundreds of Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) workers detained under the 3-MPO.
On November 5, the FCC had suspended proceedings before the PHC in cases instituted under Article 199 on or after October 12, following the deployment of armed forces in KP in aid of civil power. The order had affected proceedings challenging the preventive detention of hundreds of PTI workers under the MPO.
Subsequently, the PHC removed from its cause list all writ petitions challenging the imposition of an emergency and governor’s rule in the province, as well as arrests made under the 3-MPO.
During Monday’s hearing, counsel for the KP Bar Council informed the court that the council had filed an application seeking to become a party to the proceedings. The court accepted the request.
The council also sought clarification of the FCC’s November 5 order, with Latif Khosa informing the bench that proceedings in Article 199 cases before the PHC had come to a halt following the directive.
Justice Farooq observed that a plain reading of Article 245 suggested that all cases instituted under Article 199 could not be heard by the PHC, a situation that would bring the entire judicial system to a standstill.
The court, therefore, accepted the request for clarification and agreed to modify its earlier order, allowing the provincial high court to hear Article 199 cases, subject to the three specified exceptions.
Later, PTI Chairman Barrister Gohar Ali Khan sought relief for individuals detained under the 3-MPO, pointing out that a review board had not yet been constituted in the province. In response, the KP advocate general informed the court that the board would be established after three months.
Justice Aminuddin Khan told Barrister Gohar that miscellaneous applications filed at the FCC’s Peshawar Registry would be examined once placed before the bench. He added that applications submitted by other parties had not yet been fixed for hearing, as they had been filed at the registry only a day earlier.
Barrister Gohar urged the court to ensure an early decision on the pending applications, arguing that the maintainability of petitions before the PHC had yet to be determined. He said several PTI workers remained in custody and were being held at Police Lines.
During the proceedings, Justice Farooq observed that the case concerning the imposition of an emergency and governor’s rule in KP had important implications.
The court, however, adjourned the proceedings indefinitely.
KP GOVERNMENT INSISTS ON CONTINUED MILITARY DEPLOYMENT
The KP government has informed the FCC that it has no intention of withdrawing the armed forces from any district or area of the province.
In its written response, submitted through the provincial advocate general in compliance with the FCC’s November 5 order, the government maintained that the continued military deployment in aid of civil power remained indispensable across the province.
“In view of the persistent security environment and the severe public safety risks associated with any premature vacuum, the provincial government has formally resolved and reported that the continued deployment of the armed forces in aid of civil power remains strictly indispensable across the entire Province of KP without exception,” the response stated.
“Consequently, the provincial government does not intend the withdrawal or de-notification of Armed Forces from any district or area at this juncture,” it added.
The provincial government said the civil administration and law enforcement agencies required the continued support and operational presence of the military to protect human lives, public property and critical state installations.
In its November 5 order, the FCC had sought details from the provincial government about the deployment of armed forces, specifically asking which districts and areas still required military assistance and where such deployment was no longer necessary.
BARRISTER GOHAR EXPRESSES DISAPPOINTMENT
Speaking to reporters after the hearing, Barrister Gohar said the PTI had once again requested the FCC to allow the PHC to decide pending petitions and provide relief to detained party workers, but the request had not been granted.
Expressing disappointment over the latest order, he said the FCC had modified its November 5 directive but had failed to provide the relief sought by the party.
Barrister Gohar reiterated that imposing governor’s rule or an emergency in KP, or dismissing the provincial government, would be unconstitutional and undemocratic.
He said a petition challenging the imposition of an emergency in the province had already been filed before the FCC, adding that the matter should have been decided by the PHC.
内容来自 Pakistan Today,版权归原作者所有。
阅读原文 ↗